One of the many people that I thought were a bit overblown sometimes, and now I read as having excellent powers of prediction, is Steve M, who’s been blogging at No More Mister Nice Blog since the start of the blogging era. He has a post today where he argues that the Democrats aren’t even going to try to leverage the impending government shutdown. He quotes a report where Chris Von Hollen wondered what the point was of shutting down the government since Trump (really Musk) has ignored Congressional mandates. Steve M’s take on that:

❝

The need for a continuing resolution (CR) to keep the government open is the one point of leverage Democrats have because it require 60 votes in the Senate. Republicans can pass an actual budget through reconciliation, with 50 votes in the Senate. So the CR is the pitch Democrats should swing at.

But it appears that they won't even try.

Chris Van Hollen is probably right when he suggests that it doesn't matter what constraints are included in the bill, because Trump will ignore them, Republicans in Congress will shrug, and the courts will be slow to rebuff Trump, if they rebuff Trump at all. But if you think Trump will simply do what he pleases no matter what, that leaves you with two choices: You can put up a fight and look as if you're soldiers in an anti-Trump battle that millions of voters want to see fought, while offering an alternate view of how the country should be run to millions of voters in the middle, or you can meekly hide in a corner and appear to be giving assent to everything Trump is doing, while conveying the impression that you think Trump is on the right course because you won't even challenge him. Never mind the possibility that you might stop the juggernaut, or at least slow it down.

Why do Republican voters (and many non-Republican voters) like Donald Trump? They offer a two-word answer: He fights. He lost an election in 2020, he lost court battles in 2023 and 2024, but he always fought. Meanwhile, Democrats think they'll impress voters by not fighting.

I’m in constant correspondence with keynesaddiction, a reader on BlueSky, who is politically smart and very disappointed with the Democrats. He shares posts with me like this one:

and this one:

So we have Amy Klobuchar, who styles herself as a staunch supporter of Ukraine, relying on Marco Rubio to do something. (Spoiler alert: he won’t.) And we have Hakeem Jeffries running to Silicon Valley to get donations from companies that include SpaceX in January. No wonder he’s holding off on a full-throated opposition. (Steve M takes Jeffries to task on that point.)

Molly Jong-Fast, the person who did the Walz interview that I posted the other day, writes this at Vanity Fair:

❝

The base of the Democratic Party is mad. They aren’t going to be satisfied with cringe nicknames and punching left. They don’t want to see leaders lying down, but out there making noise on TV and social media. Sure, there are electeds pushing back, like Senator Chris Murphy; governors Maura Healey, Janet Mills, and JB Pritzker; and representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Jasmine Crockett, and Maxwell Frost. And billionaire Mark Cuban is out there offering support to laid-off government tech workers. But party leadership isn’t meeting the moment and speaking to the deep frustration across the country.

I would add Becca Balint (D-VT-AL) and Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders to the list, but she’s not wrong that the number of Democratic officeholders consistently showing a lot of fight can be counted on two hands. Note that I said “consistently” here — the days of someone writing one letter or having one press conference are over, but I’d sure like to hear if anyone thinks that some other Democrat has been consistently great in pushing back on Republicans. The great song Coltrane covered, the title of this post, should be how every Democrat treats their role as an opposition leader.

By the way, I fucking hate writing these posts. I hate that the bulk of Congressional Democrats haven’t met the moment. I hate that we have to call and nag them to do what I think is their job. It is the opposite of hallelujah.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

It’s so disappointing that the majority of Democratic representatives are failing to meet this moment.

The only thing we can do is keep lighting up the phone lines and pushing them to do better. MAGA doesn’t care what we think, but we would hope that our own leaders DO.

Thanks to you and all the others out there who keep shining a light on both bad behavior and good behavior.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

In my darker moods I feel like "Democrats failing to meet the moment" has been my entire adult life.

We needed an FDR after the 2008 financial crash and we didn't get one. We needed an Abe Lincoln after the 2021 coup attempt and we didn't get one either.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

My darker, lighter and in-between moods think that.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

They are talking in Senate Speak while the world burns.

I’ve been a loyal Democrat all my life but I’m tired of carrying their water. We need them to sound and act like they know we are in a crisis.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Senate brain is a scary thing.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

I'm tired of them spamming my phone and email every election season with their hair on fire telling me that this is the most important election in history and if I don't cough up $25.00, we're literally all going to be living in Auschwitz... and then, as soon as they're elected, coughing uncomfortably that, well, yes, we do think what Republicans are doing is pretty bad, but it's important that in fighting them we don't do anything crazy and radical that would make us just as bad as they are, like ::checks notes:: abolishing the filibuster so we can actually pass legislation. You can't just keep doing that and expect to be taken seriously in perpetuity. At a certain point, either you never believed a word you were saying, or you don't give a shit.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

The most risk averse approach is to wait until Trump implodes which is not a bad bet, but is also cowardly and doesn't solve the fascism problem. We have to actually beat them, not just wait until they beat themselves - that gives us one cycle.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Yeah. At a certain point, "wait until the fascist implodes" becomes "wait until the fascist has overextended himself by conquering most of Europe and part of North Africa and engaged in war with the three most powerful nations in the world, and hope that when those nations have bombed, shelled, and bulldozed their way through every part of our country, put their boot on our neck and turned us into a vassal, they'll actually be NICE about the reconstruction!"

And that is in fact what happened in 1930s/40s Germany, so yay, I guess?

At the same time, a lot of people would've appreciated it if Hitler's enemies within Germany had gotten their shit together long before that instead of just waiting for somebody else to clean up the mess.

Avatar

green goblin1 year ago

They are squeamish about a government shut down over the CR? Are these Dems aware that the Republicans are planning a "petmanent" shutdown with the RIF of all feds that get furloughed during a shutdown?

That fact would insulate them if they repeat every hour on the hour the shutdown lasts that this could be permanent.

JFC. Who supports this crap?

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I think they're aware, and feeling a combination of denial and fear of leaving the status quo (money from big donors).

Avatar

green goblin1 year ago

But why the fear? Have they forgotten all the small donor groups that came together for Harris through Zoom? Why not encourage White Dudes Against Facism? Teachers For Democracy, etc.?

My God the stupidity. People - even in Republican districts - are looking for leaders of the opposition and the Dems just look around like "anybody but us!"

Avatar

green goblin1 year ago

I want to add that lots of small donors are more than money. They are support, ambassadors to undecided voters, and votes. Rich guys have one vote and everybody hates them.

Avatar

green goblin1 year ago

But why the fear? Have they forgotten all the small donor groups that came together for Harris through Zoom? Why not encourage White Dudes Against Facism? Teachers For Democracy, etc.?

My God the stupidity. People - even in Republican districts - are looking for leaders of the opposition and the Dems just look around like "anybody but us!"

Avatar

green goblin1 year ago

Apologies for the double post. Got an error message the first time.