Over the weekend, the Trump Administration ignored a clear court order to not use the Alien Enemies Act of 1798. They deported some alleged Tren de Aragua and MS-13 gang members to El Salvador, and the President, Nayib Bukele, tweaked the nose of the court, and Marco Rubio thanked him on X.

Bukele is the guy who is currently clearing an old-growth forest to build an airport to serve his dream of creating a “Bitcoin hub” in his country. He calls himself the “world’s coolest dictator”. Presumably, he’ll write yet another chapter of loss and despair into his country’s history at some point, but right now he’s riding high in part because he’s hosting a 40,000 person detention center that the Trump Administration will use for deportees that they want to hide. Who needs another Gitmo when you have this guy on your side?

Anyway, the question here is obviously what the court is going to do about this. The judge hearing the case was James Boasberg. He’s an Obama appointee, and chief judge of the DC Circuit. Clearly, someone is in contempt here. Is he going to issue a contempt citation and have the Federal Marshalls go and round some person up? Or is he going to bang his gavel harder?

As usual, my take on this is “Faster, Faster, Disaster”. If Boasberg isn’t going to do anything, let’s find that out as soon as possible, so we can keep track of the institutions, if any, that are going to resist the Trump Administration’s authoritarian takeover. We know Congress isn’t on that list. Universities seem to be unable to muster any response but “please, sir, may I have another?” My guess is that Boasberg, like most lawyers and judges, are heavily invested in the position of the courts in the social hierarchy, and they’re afraid of doing something that will trigger a realization that the courts, like Congress, have almost no influence over the Trump Administration.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

A little constitutional crisis is good for a healthy democracy, right?

When the President of a country is shitposting like a troll (and the SOS is giving him a pat on the head for it), it’s time for social media to die.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Solace

May the blessing of light be on you— light without and light within. May the blessed sunlight shine on you and warm your heart till it glows like a great peat fire.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

They did this to get the video - it’s all over Right wing Tik Tok. Pure fascist propaganda

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

Exactly.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I don’t know - the BBC report said this was an oral statement from the judge and not in the order judge issued. If that’s true the Trump people didn’t violate an order. It’s absolutely a violation of due process though - the relatives of these people say they are NOT gang members. As usual, the low quality Trump hires are just making shit up.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Ken White (Popehat) said that when he was an AUSA, ICE would raid a house and the number of coyotes in the house would oddly be the number needed to make their quota. Now it's masks off for them, and they're wilding around the country. I'm sure many of the people arrested in this round up weren't gang members.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Right - but if judges want to issue an order it needs to BE IN the order. Lectures from the bench don't count You're only required to follow what w/in the four corners of the order

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

Also, as I am given to understand it, the plane carrying the "deportees" was over international waters by the time the order was issued and thus outside his jurisdiction.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Even if that turns out to be the case, this will not be the last time Trump tries to do something like this. He’s a child pushing to see what he can get away with. And so far in his life, nobody has ever told him “NO” or punished him for his actions.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

This is a stupid argument put up by Trump folks pretending that they don't know how law works or incompetent enough that they really do not know how law works.

Shoebomber didn't suddenly become "whoopsie unprosecutable over international waters" because he was on a trip from Paris to Miami. It was an American plane, and he was prosecuted in US federal courts.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

The AP reported that Boasberg issued the order regarding the initial 5 detainees 9:20 on Saturday morning.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

So very frustrating! It's always been up to us, but collective cohesion in focusing on purpose is hard to come by these days.