❝

When Mr. Musk purchased X in 2022, he promised to create a free speech haven and named himself a “free speech absolutist.” Critics still feared that Mr. Musk would use his control of the app to pick and choose his favorites, amplifying voices he admired while suppressing people or topics he loathed.

The New York Times found three users on X who feuded with Mr. Musk in December only to see their reach on the social platform practically vanish overnight.

Many others who criticized Mr. Musk have claimed they were quietly suppressed on the platform, a tactic known as shadowbanning or ghost banning. Though The Times did not identify other accounts that were artificially suppressed, such changes would be difficult to spot if users did not post frequently, or did not have many popular posts.

“If he did it to small accounts, nobody would notice,” said Ms. Loupis, who has more than one million followers on her original account. “But when he starts doing it to really, really big influencers with millions of followers, everybody notices.”

The accounts are the starkest signs yet that Mr. Musk or others at the company have the power to punish critics and that they may be willing to use it, startling free speech advocates who hoped that the billionaire would be their champion.

“This is working against the type of environment that he claimed he wanted to build,” said Ari Cohn, the lead counsel for technology policy at the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, a free speech advocacy group. “Don’t sit here and cloak yourself in the First Amendment and free speech, and then do things like that.”

Ya think? There are no bigger suckers than “free speech advocates”. That Right wing social media personalities Glenn Greenwald and Matt Taibbi fell for the lie that Twitter was suppressing Right wing speech only to turn Twitter over to this controlling, authoritarian South African techbro is hilarious.

Now they all have to kiss Trump’s and Elon’s ass in order to “monetize” and promote their stupid careers as Right wing pundits. Trump and Elon stuffed their mouths with cash and now they all work for the regime. Unless they promote and praise Elon and Trump they don’t get paid.

  • This is an open thread, so feel free to post links you want to share in the comments.

 

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Pacem Appellant1 year ago

They were never "free-speech warriors". That was pure and evil marketing. They wanted to be able to be bigots without getting criticized. Now that they have that—X is platform devoted to silencing woke and amplifying hatred and bigotry—they're upset because the people they want to punch aren't there to punch anymore. It is 1000% telling that the "free-speech warriors" are coming out with non-fiction essay book this year warning of the evils of leftists silencing free speech. In 2025. As Trump et al. disappear immigrants and citizens without due process. Anyone in media (not here or at BJ of course) who took these asshats at their word when it was transparently about ego and power deserve the derision and complete loss of prestige media.

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 1 year ago

Thanks for this, Kay! I’d read mostly speculation before that Musk had been doing this—in addition to welcoming in the Nazis and promoting them.

For what it’s worth, that lawyer quoted at the end is probably not voicing his actual opinion. Sounds like lawyer-style accusation.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

A lot of free speech absolutists are also egomaniacs and think their opinions are better, more important, and more valuable than everyone else. I don’t think Musk thought that the more he spoke freely the more people would hate him. He also didn’t think the more he spoke freely the more he would reveal himself to be a fucking idiot.

These free speech absolutists also love the free market. Well, in Musk’s case the market is correcting. It turns out that the base of support for an electric vehicle/battery company is left leaning people who care about the environment. They also tend to be more educated and less racist and misogynistic. He has now lost his base.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

I used to bombard MM with stuff like this but an open thread might absorb the pressure better ;-).

Here's an interview with Dan Davies, another Crooked Timber alum, about his book "The Unaccountability Machine". I read it when it came out and it's terrific.

https://www.salon.com/2025/04/26/why-the-world-stopped-making-sense-how-the-neoliberal-class-war-fueled-global-chaos/

His book on the Brombton bicycle company is excellent as well. My wife and I are very familiar with all these dynamics underlying the (mis)management of companies.

Finally, port traffic looking grim:

https://bsky.app/profile/calculatedrisk.bsky.social/post/3lnsmpskkc22u

The blue bubble is way too small but be sure to try peark.es Very decent chap for an econ-head.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Thanks for the book recommend - right in my wheelhouse :)

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Apparently Tesla batteries are shit compared to the batteries BYD is using. Kind of upends the notion that the Chinese only steal tech and don’t innovate, which looking at Tesla and other big tech companies, is starting to seem an awful lot like projection.

https://www.thecooldown.com/green-tech/tesla-byd-batteries-study-comparison/

Avatar

r po1 year ago

So in AZ Gallego and Kelly are feuding with the AZ Dem leadership (I have no idea what that is) and the shitting on each other that I have seen (which now I can't find again) does not actually say why this is. There was a mention that the two senators don't like someone appointed to a top position.

Anybody have some pointers on how to dig deeper into this? We're moving there at the end of the burning hell summer.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Avatar

r po1 year ago

Thanks. That's basically the same as I read before. Hard to believe this about incumbents being rude during a transition (of what, underneath?).

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

My guess is that chair is gone soon, because even if he had a point or a case, now it's a "feud" in public, and that's a bad look.