❝

Cardi B and NYC Mayor Mamdani launch contest to create jingle for new free 2-K childcare program
Program aims to provide free childcare for 2-year-olds, regardless of income or immigration status
Winning jingle will become official theme and receive radio play

Just think, if we had let the Right and Center of the Party knock Mamdani out with pre -election smears we’d have gross, corrupt liar Cuomo instead of the great person that we got.

I have a local story about universal pre K. About ten years ago, I was asked to volunteer to head up outreach to women to get them to vote for a public school levy. The levy included universal pre K (but not starting at 2, ours starts at 3).

My city and county are about 50% “free and reduced lunch”, in public schools parlance, which means “50% lower income households with children”. But that’s not how we sold the pre k. We sold the prek as “certified teachers, safe and on the same campus as the public school where your children already go”.

The levy passed, with my higher income neighborhood turning in the best pro levy performance. The higher income pre k kids go to the public program, and so do the lower income kids, therefore assuring the pre K will always be funded. I think of this as putting upper middle and middle class people “in front” of poor people. Set it up right, and any future political actor has to GET THRU the upper and middle to harm the poor people,

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic8 months ago

Studies have shown that most programs that are "universal" in nature have much higher support than those that target lower socio-economic people only. I have no problem with means-testing certain programs, but politics in a democracy is historically about assembling coalitions to pass laws (i.e., compromise) and if it takes "universality" in a desired program to gain enough support, so be it. As MM wrote, there are other ways to skin the cat (i.e., an income tax surcahrge for higher earning New Yorkers).

Avatar

Scott H8 months ago(edited)

I'm all for means-testing if you can do it so that Busted Knee's fav demographic aren't the overwhelming beneficiaries. Good example of how not to do that was Denver's original e-bike rebate program. The wrote it such that every entitled white colonizer/transplant who moved here got this sweet gubmint subsidy to buy their $10k cargo bike to haul little Liam and Emma around in. Even when they redid it because of that, it's still basically an upper-middle-class benefit.

The problem with means testing in general, however, is that means testing has the effect of excluding many of the people who need help the most — people with limited education, limited time and stressful lives. Also, means testing leads to a narrative that the program is benefiting only Those People, and should therefore be eliminated.

The right has been trying to kill social security since day 1 and one approach has been "means testing". FDR knew back then that such an approach would kill it.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor8 months ago

Means testing every program is a ton of overhead. Taxing it back is more efficient and it encourages universality.

Avatar

Scott H8 months ago

Preaching to the choir. Means-testing is simply another Reagan-era dog-whistle to cut shit.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor8 months ago

The NYT wrote a piece about how a bunch of rich folks in some nice neighborhood in Manhattan were going to get some school freebee from the Mamdani administration. "They pay $34 for burgers, should their child care be free?" is the headline. (Of course it should, sheesh.)

Of course, these upper-middle-class folks pay more taxes, too. New York has a special additional income tax in addition to the already pretty stiff NY State Income Tax, but the NYT is too busy trying to bash Mamdani to discuss that.

https://bsky.app/profile/parsnip.bsky.social/post/3miljgcuyhs2i

Avatar

Sepideh M8 months ago

Mamdani does a lot to highlight how government works. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1vbAdFkVvA

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur8 months ago

SHAZAM!