There’s long been speculation that a number of Senators who are hiding their true views on hot-button issues for the base. These Senators may make public statements that indicate certain, probably more progressive, views, but in reality they don’t want to take the votes to back up those views. So, Schumer addresses this issue by making sure that nobody has to take a “hard” vote when it will damage them.

If you look at who voted for cloture, note that only retirees and probable retirees (Durbin) who are up in 2026 took the vote. Note, too, that everyone but King and Shaeen tried the too-clever-by-half trick of voting for cloture and voting against the CR itself.

Were these the only Dems who were inclined to vote for cloture? We’ll never know, because a good number of Senators obviously believe that lying to their constituents to avoid criticism is a valid strategy. Schumer only needed 7 and a couple extra so nobody looked like the “deciding” vote, as if that was something that people care about. My guess is that if he had needed more, he would have gotten more.

At least one of these votes was a surprise: Schatz. There’s a guy who talks a good progressive game on social media. But, in reality, he either believed that he was taking the right vote, or he got something for that vote. He’s pretty junior (first elected in 2012), and he’s young (52), so maybe he got a promise of some leadership position out of it. What’s for sure is that he stayed very, very quiet, voted for cloture, then issued a statement that wasn’t persuasive (to me, at least). Note that his statement wasn’t part of his press page, because he wants this vote to go away.

Maybe I’m sounding a bit like a conspiracy theorist, but where are we as a party when our electeds hide their votes from us because they know we’d object, then after they vote they issue a statement that we know is bullshit? The ease at which Schumer told his lies about the vote makes me think it’s something he and his colleagues do a lot.

Schatz seems like a well-liked Senator in Hawaii, and he delivers for his constituents, so probably he thought this vote would be a nothing, certainly not an issue in his 2028 race, since who knows what will happen by then. I don’t blame any politician in Hawaii for not announcing a primary challenge tomorrow, just as I don’t expect a smart politician like AOC to announce a primary against Schumer until after 2026, if ever.

But let’s consider Durbin, who’s probably retiring anyway. If I were a credible candidate in Illinois thinking about taking a run at that seat, I’d announce my primary challenge tomorrow. You’d get a bunch of small-dollar donations, but, more importantly, you’d get a shit ton of free media. Every mainstream political show would want to interview you, especially if you were a feisty fighter who went hard at Durbin and his history of inaction. The “resistance” media, or whatever we’re calling it nowadays, would have you on all their podcasts.

Our party has a problem getting its message out. But a tough-talking challenger who had a strong anti-Musk, anti-Trump message would get a lot more attention than, say, Elizabeth Warren (I’m sad to say). They’d be a new shiny object. Unfortunately the Democratic fetish for hierarchy and people taking their turn would probably mean that no Illinois Democrat with a real chance at beating Durbin would step up. Still, I think it’s a hell of an opportunity for someone to show that they’re a risk-taker, which is what we so sorely need in this party.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

My opinion is that if Schumer had a bunch of members in his caucus who had dug in their heels on voting Yes, then fine. Prepare the ground properly for this and set expectations accordingly. Give the usual "members are free to vote their conscience (or lack thereof)" and prepare the rank and file that the vote might not go the way they want. The rank and file would probably still be disgusted, but they wouldn't be feeling like they were duped and bertrayed. Instead, Schumer came out with that hideous, "They don't have the votes" statement and set the expectation that Senate Dems would be united in opposition. He got House Dems to stick their necks out on that opposition and then yanked the rug out from under them.

Even if you think a "Yes" vote for cloture was correct, the way Schumer handled this was a disaster and he should step down. His credibility is shot.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Agree. I think Patty Murray would be a good replacement. She gets it. He doesn't.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

You know I love Patty, and I think she is great. She could also serve as a bridge to the next generation of leaders since I’m not sure she will seek reelection in ‘26, and if she does it would surely be her last. She’s already 74, and I don’t think she intends to die in office.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

If I had any inclination to be in politics (I got it out of my system in college), that’s exactly what I would be doing. People want fighters. And the worst part is that the Democrats know that to be true, which is why they put this out:

https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2025/03/06/watch_democrats_create_choose_your_fighter_video.html

That clip is so ridiculous. It makes a mockery of Democrats, and reduces their “fight” to something ridiculous and performative. I honestly can’t believe they got AOC and Crockett to participate in it. But this seems to be as much “fight” as the party is willing to have.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

This clip is participation in a Super Smash Bros meme. This, like AOC showing up on Twitch, is an attempt to reach gamers who are probably in their 20s and 30s.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Yeah, I get that. I’m a gamer myself. I thought what AOC did on Twitch was cool. This completely sucked.

If a guy in his 40s thought this was lame, I highly doubt anyone younger than me thought it was awesome.

Avatar

Paul W.1 year ago

I wonder at how deep the rot goes, I'm not ready to feel completely betrayed by the entire Dem caucus (though that could be a me problem). But I certainly have been thrown a loop by Senator Schatz but then I see Adam Schiff (who I actually thought ran a really disappointing Senate race and moderating of his strong stances in the House) release this: https://x.com/SenAdamSchiff/status/1900682134320230456

Its 6.5 minutes, but he calls the spade a spade and says he is disappointed in the Dem caucus, something I don't think you say if you are trying to make the vote disappear. I believe in replacing everyone over the age of 70 at this point in primaries where possible, the people want some radicalism from our Senators and the leadership is just not going to get them there. But, I still retain some hope for an AOC 2028 run, maybe Schiff continues on this path, and Warnock and Ossoff voted against - maybe fake, but for now I take them at face value.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Josh Marshall posted another Schiff video where he explained a shutdown and how it was the Republicans' fault.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vobvw7JLuEM

As far as the deepness of the rot, I don't know, but I'm tired of the kabuki play acting bullshit. Just state your position and vote. This week was a rollercoaster that I didn't need to ride.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

It needs to be pointed out that at the state level, the problem of "Democrats hiding their true views from constituents" has been CHRONIC. Democrats sweep New York... then a bunch of them form the Independent Democratic Conference, which promptly hands power back to the Republicans. Tricia Cotham wins an election as a Democrat in North Carolina... and then switches her identity to Republican just in time to hand the Republicans a veto-proof majority. We've had reports of Republicans in California simply registering as Democrats to run for office and then govern as Republicans to subvert the state's blue supermajority. Etc.

At the national level, it's usually been a BIT less blatant, but honestly, not that much less.

This is why "controlled opposition" narratives proliferate, and it's why a lot of progressives have real trouble trusting the institutional Democratic Party. Even if most of its members are well-meaning, which I'd like to think is true, it's compromised as fuck.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Yep. Cuomo was functionally a Republican. In fact, in NY, in the 90's there were Republicans who were pretty much what we'd consider a Democrat, in terms of their positions, today. Shelly Boehlert was the last of them, but there were a few socially liberal a bit fiscally conservative Republicans around. That's all gone now -- they're MAGA.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Until the 90s, it was the norm that both parties were loose coalitions of progressives, moderates, and conservatives - even when one faction was clearly dominant, a certain amount of the others still existed. So the 90s Republicans don't surprise me.

What's changed is that since the 90s the GOP has essentially purged itself from anyone who wasn't a conservative and then charged off to the far right. Which should have left to a similar hardening for the Dems. But instead, the party just seems to get more and more determinedly committed to being a twentieth century party, as if that's somehow going to bring twentieth century politics back.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I know, I've lived it, sadly.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

“I’ve known Andrew Cuomo for decades,” Senator Gillibrand said when NY1 recently asked her about his frontrunner status in the mayoral primary. “He has a lot of talent as an executive, he’s been a very strong governor and done very good things for New York.”

This from the person who threw Franken under the bus over far less than what Cuomo did. What a fucking fraud she is.

Avatar

Paul Anderson1 year ago

It is equal parts depressing and infuriating how much sense this makes.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

The Democratic base is the most valuable part of the Democratic Party. That the leaders treat the base with such disdain is mystifying to me, and indicates a bigger problem with leadership than just one vote - they don’t know where their strength comes from. I feel much more loyalty to fellow members of the base than I do to leadership - they’re the reason I stay in the party.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

I am done apologizing for Democrats. For years I made calculated votes and made excuses. I also worked really hard to advocate for issues I cared about and have been volunteering for the party for decades. But after they campaigned on Trump and his cronies being an existential threat to our democracy then turned around and behaved so weak and duplicitously, I cannot continue to support them. I do think that Rep Pingree and our state elected Democrats are not just doing good work but also behaving honestly and appropriately for the crisis we are in. I am furious with King. He is smart, he knows what he is doing. He has had serious health issues and as our governor tried to create a universal health care system for our state. That he made it possible for this budget to pass that will absolutely make cuts to health care is inexcusable. Next time I see him I’m going to tell him. We usually try to keep social things social but no more. It will probably be my last invite. Oh well.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I wonder if he'll retire early. He's 80.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

LOL, only in the Senate would that statement make any sense.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

Ha!! He’s had cancer several times and was just reelected to another six year term. I’m more worried about who will run against Suzie C and who will run for Governor.