Dave Weigel interviewed Tim Walz, who’s campaigning in Wisconsin in support of Supreme Court candidate Susan Crawford, who is running against a candidate who has millions of Musk dollars behind him. Weigel asked an interesting question:

❝

How much can Democrats can rebuild, of what Trump is un-building right now? We’ve seen cases where employees are laid off, a court orders them back, but they’re still laid off. Do Democrats run in 2028 on re-establishing it?

I use the analogy of the car running out of gas. Car runs out of gas, you go get a can, you pour some in, you start it up, and it’s all fine. This is the car running out of oil, and it’s broken. And what I’m saying is, he is breaking it. This is a little bit in the Ezra Klein space: Democrats need to acknowledge that not all these agencies work perfectly. All of us who teach would agree to that. You know, we say how important the Department of Education is, how it does incredible work, but we would all argue there’s ways they could be better.

I think we need to start messaging right now. We need to put our experts on this. How will we build back next time? I think it’s an opportunity. I think it’s an opportunity to create the agencies the way we saw them in the first place, functioning better, without all the barnacles. So, Trump might be doing us a favor. He stripped it down, he blew the motor up. We’re going to put a new motor in it and take off. And I think that’s how we have to start thinking about it.

Let’s ignore the “Ezra Klein Space” for the moment and talk about putting the engine back in the car. What would that look like?

I think it begins with a frank discussion of the breakdown that occurred. Democrats embrace the legitimate role of government and acknowledge, as Walz says, that important departments like Education could be changed to do a better job. That acknowledgment shouldn’t take the form of “Republicans had a point, actually” but rather that “any government department can function better, and we’re going to take this rebuilding opportunity to make them better.”

After that, we talk about punishing those who broke the law in order to wreck those departments. For example, the dismantling of the US Institute for Peace, which isn’t a government agency, happened because DOGE convince their security service to switch sides or lose all other government contracts. The DOGErs who did this need to face criminal charges and punishment. We don’t need a repeat of the Merrick Garland situation — instead, we need a solid promise from Democrats that this time we’re going to go after lawbreakers swiftly and forcefully. This will serve as an example to potential DOGErs, who will think twice about being the tip of the spear for some rich dude who wants to destroy government to get sweetheart contracts and tax breaks.

We need to restore Congress to the role that it was supposed to serve. Our reforms should take the form of legislative packages that address each of the different agencies where Musk and Trump ran rampant. Those pieces of legislation should pass through Congress individually, with the responsible committees working from a template that was shared during the election by Democratic candidates. Those templates should be very simple bullet points, not long policy papers.

Finally, the courts need to be respected and put in their proper place. The Supreme Court isn’t a bunch of little kings. Apparently, Congress can specify that pieces of legislation aren’t subject to judicial review. We should do that liberally. Also, we need to pass ethics reform for the courts, and plan on packing the Supreme Court if necessary.

Every single thing I stated above is too radical for most of the Democratic establishment in Congress and in the ranks of consultants. They will fight it, hard. That’s why we need to get started now so we won’t have another replay of Biden 2020, where we just expect the garbage of the former Trump administration to take itself out.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Run Goose1 year ago

I have so many pet issues that of course I feel would lead to a dream platform, but mostly I think we need to be better about putting populist policy wins out front while doing the "make government work" stuff quietly. There is quite a bit of overlap between the two (FTC, CFPB, SSA, etc) but it needs to be a unified theme.

Anti-enshittification of government and society would be broadly popular.

Expanding the house and obliterating the filibuster are key to a resurgent legislative branch and necessary for the republic to have a hope of recovering from this obliteration of the old order.

Avatar

Run Goose1 year ago

I think my standalone line in the middle there actually negates my entire first paragraph. Oops!

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

Have to add statehood for DC and PR. That would change the composition of the Congress and right longstanding injustice.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Yes. Also universal health care. We need to swing for the fences.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

Something to keep in mind is that the labor unions put in the muscle and the money to get the ACA passed. For decades when unions were negotiating contracts they chose benefits including lifetime benefits over salary increases. So a major reason the ACA kept the insurance framework was because we would not have had union support without it. Now the situation may have changed since then. I can’t speak to that. Even if we keep the insurance system there are still a lot of improvements we could make to achieve universal coverage.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

A question to ask is how do "we" restore to Congress "the role it was supposed to have" when Congress has abrogated much of that responsibility itself over the last 40 years?

This isn't about yet another tired rehash of the 'Joe Must Go' debate because we can point to a myriad number of reasons about the electoral outcome that went well beyond the 'mental decline' debate.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Well this has to be done by the candidates for Congress, and the leadership, under pressure from the base. Congress appropriates, and the executive distributes those appropriations. The discussion can start by distinguishing between Congress and a king. Not saying it will be easy, but it's important.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

This is a sore point for Democrats but I think it's important. Information is going to come out about Biden's condition in the last year of his term. I would like Democrats to not knee jerk deny this information but instead honestly evaluate it for reliability, truth, etc.

I believe we in the US got here because we refused to face uncomfortable truths over decades - the cure to that is to demand rigorous honesty from our elected leaders AND the public.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

It is going to be incredibly damaging and I think unfortunately it will take a lot of people out of future leadership roles.

We need more transparency and we need to look honestly at how we defend Democrats even when they have failed to change with the times or address current concerns.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I think part of the reason we lost credibility with young people is they saw the decline and we refused to see it. I heard it over and over from young people and I denied it too - until it became impossible to deny. We have to be credible. We have to regain their trust.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

Same for me. I was seeing clips from Normandy and trying to push back about his neuropathy, edited clips, etc. They were not having any of it. My sons were all at defcon1 about young men going hard right. I regret that I dismissed it until the debate.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Or we have to offer, and more importantly, mean, a better vision. And figure out a way to compellingly sell that 24/7/365 and we as a party are far from that.

I use the phrase "bullshit orthodoxy" but another way to put it is the Centrist Bullshit Machine as it exists both in the media and in the party's usual reaction to losses.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Not just young people. My normie Democrat wife (who is now probably more politically engaged than me) asked me in early 2024, "Are we really going to have to choose between Biden and Trump? Biden looks so old." Democrats were in a real bubble about Biden.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

My defenses of Biden notwithstanding, your description of spouse, normie status, now-non-normie status and reaction to Biden after the first debate are identical.

I wasn't in a bubble per se because I saw where much of the Dump Joe noise was coming from within the (D) party and as we all know, I spend a lot of time pushing back on those people.

But, my wife would always ground me on that given her reaction so yeah, that bubble was very, very real, no matter who might have been pushing it.

One thing I learned is that "Vote Against Facism" didn't resonate.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

There is also a sort of blue MAGA issue. Democrats turned their backs on the right to protest and were willing to deny that there was an active genocide taking place in Gaza because a Democrat was president and enabling it. This was one of the most distressing things for me to witness. We have to be honest especially when we are part of the problem.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Agree completely. Abandoning not just the protestors but the whole concept of dissent on campus was a real mistake. We’re now in a position where we are not on solid moral or legal ground to criticize Trump in Gaza. That was inevitable when we decided to pretend Gaza what was happening in Gaza wasn’t real. Young people (again) knew it was real

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

There is also asymmetry to how these issues are recognized. We were concerned about drones when Obama was in power because there was transparency into the data on drones. When Trump gained power, the issue disappeared because the data transparency disappeared.

And we are now disappearing the data on maternal mortality and infant mortality.

Data transparency should not be a thing that can be undone so easily.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

He was also transparent about the NSA even establishing audit trails to enable accountability. Tried to close GITMO and 98 Senators including Sanders voted against it. Tried to get Congress to authorize military action in Syria and they wouldn’t and criticized him for not taking military action. Clinton was absolutely punished for being transparent with her tax returns. I don’t know how we deal with this problem.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Just because one student has a teacher that sucks or one school needs to be shuttered because the principal is promoting a lord-of-the-flies culture does not mean the whole education system is broken, and we need to destroy the whole thing. I do think we are doing far too much testing so highly-paid administrators can pretend to do stuff with data, but the type of thing that the federal department of education is funding is "school for poor children" or "educational access for disabled children." The ways that education should be fixed are typically state and district level fixes, and some states-rights people are running roughshod over some states.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

The "one thing sucks" excuse is always the cover the usual suspects need to sell something even worse only with better sounding words.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

The right wing is great at picking out the one thing and making it everything. Media asymmetry is another issue we need to address.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

This could be a great discussion w/in the Party - reforms. Im grateful to Walz for raising it.

I would like to see the DOJ reformed - I would like to see them stop making deals with monied, powerful actors where we are essentially accepting payment instead of prosecutions. We need a renewed commitment to EQUAL treatment under the law. Federal.prosecutors absolutely hammer ordinary defendants - they need to apply that same harsh standard to rich and/or powerful actors.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I truly admire your ideas and am glad that I subscribed to your newsletter.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Dare to dream!