The WSJ had an “exclusive” yesterday on the upcoming GOP tax bill- the tax on OT part. I’m a little suspicious of this “exclusive” - it reads so favorably to Republicans I’m pretty sure it’s planted by Republicans, but this tax bill is coming so we have to look ahead:

❝

WASHINGTON—A new Republican proposal aims to turn President Trump’s open-ended “no tax on overtime” slogan into a practical reality, denying the new deduction to some top earners and capping it at $10,000 for individuals and $20,000 for married couples.

Under the legislation from Sen. Roger Marshall (R., Kan.), the break for overtime pay would start phasing out once individual adjusted gross income reaches $100,000 or when a married couple’s income reaches $200,000. At the 22% marginal tax rate that applies to many taxpayers in this range, a deduction for $20,000 in overtime pay would save $4,400 in taxes. 

Marshall’s proposal is a candidate for inclusion in the giant tax-and-spending bill that Republican lawmakers are assembling to carry Trump’s agenda. Most of that “one big, beautiful bill” would extend expiring tax cuts that Trump and Republicans passed in 2017, but Congress is also trying to squeeze in versions of the president’s campaign-trail tax-cut slogans.

Marshall’s bill, slated for introduction Tuesday, would limit the overtime-pay break to people who get at least 1.5 times their normal pay rate, either under the Fair Labor Standards Act or an agreement with their employer. 

The break would be an above-the-line income tax deduction. That means workers can claim it whether they itemize deductions or take the standard deduction. They would still pay payroll taxes on the income. 

❝

According to the Yale Budget Lab, about 8% of hourly workers and 4% of salaried workers regularly work overtime. 

Every single Trump voter I spoke to about this no tax on overtime promise - and they were all talking about it - believed that Trump meant no PAYROLL taxes on overtime. So we’ll see how this rather small and stingy technical compliance with the promise shakes out. Also? Democrats need a counter.

Discuss this or anything else - I’m working today.

open thread

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

It’s almost impossible to target messaging to a constantly moving target. He definitely promised tariffs and people either pretended he wasn’t serious or didn’t bother to find out what they were. He promised no taxes in overtime, tips, and social security. If anything goes wrong he just pivots and somehow people move on. Too many Americans are just embarrassingly, catastrophically ignorant. I don’t know what we do about it.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

This is definitely all the rage with the MAGA crew. I just spent 5 days in Florida surrounded by my MAGA family, and all I heard was:

  • Everyone is mean to poor Elon Musk, when everyone should be grateful for all the sacrifice he is making for nothing in return.

  • Trump has kept every one of his promises, and we will all be grateful when we start rolling in the golden age that is upon us.

  • Everyone is mean to RFKJ and should be thankful for his efforts to MAHA, and he never said anything bad about autistic people.

  • Trump is the best friend of the Jewish people, and everyone is going to love visiting the Trump Heights (they really renamed the Golan Heights) and Gaza Lago.

  • I love my family, but thank god I’m about to board a plane back to Seattle. I had enough of visiting bizarro land.

    Avatar

    TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

    Teh stoopid, it burns. Glad you can emerge unscathed!

    Avatar

    Sepideh M1 year ago

    Why am I looking up "Is weed legal in Florida?"

    No reason. No reason at all.

    Avatar

    mister mixAuthor1 year ago

    What about "no taxes on tips"? I wonder if that's going to be income-capped or a giveaway to rich folks who will restructure their compensation to be tips on top of a small wage.

    100K/200K is pretty stingy for urban dwellers (like the core Trump constituency of cops).

    Avatar

    TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

    Wonder why we don't hear anymore about all the unpaid bills for security services at his rallies that he's left in his wake. /s