There’s a lot of criticism falling on the New York Times right now for their stupid piece about which boxes Mamdani checked on this Columbia application. The piece was apparently sourced from some right wing nutter and the paper is being defended by the guy responsible for butter emails, who now has a title that includes the words “standards and trust”. It was a clear piece of trolling by a right winger who wanted to point out that Mamdani was not a white man, and also to make blacks in New York City think that Mamdani was trying to pretend to be black to get into Columbia. Here’s Eric Adams picking up that thread.

I’m guessing Mamdani will respond to this appropriately and it won’t have a long life as a “scandal,” but the Times is both trying to advance a pretty weak and stupid attack as well as trolling the left, subscribers or not. They are very successful at it. It’s corrosive and terrible, and I wish it could be ignored more easily.

Something else I could do without is the performative “will s/he or won’t s/he” around these big votes. It’s very clear that two things are true about the Trumpian Congress: everything Trump wants to pass is going to pass, and most of the doubts expressed by Republicans are bullshit. The DC press should be far more skeptical about the blather than escapes the pieholes of Republican Members of Congress. It’s the votes that count, including the pattern of voting.

It’s worth studying Mamdani’s campaign and taking away the lessons that might be more universally applied. It’s worth noting how eager Republicans were to vote for a bill that is going to destroy their districts. The trolling by outlets like the Times, and the gallons of virtual ink spilled over the supposed qualms of Republican Members of Congress should mostly be ignored.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Kent Argent1 year ago

From a paranoid lunatic on a cultic blog who thinks 92,000 scattered and impotent DSA members control the US:

Not a fan of either Mamdani and his tankie politics or the Garbage Times and their Republican party enabling ways.

Both his parents are of Indian origin so by no definition is Mamdani black

Tankies and MAGAs have a symbiotic relationship. Tankie DSA type politics helps Rs not the Democrats

They traffic in similar bigotries. On the right they hide their intentions using patriotism as a cover on the horseshoe left its economic justice.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Mmm. So who was it, Schrodinger's Cat or Professor Bigot?

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

The NYTimes would rather have the completely corrupt Adams or Cuomo rather than ANYONE on the Left. Ethically bankrupt entity. Purely ideological.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

It’s incredible entirely predictable how many Zohran hit pieces boil down to one of the following: a) he’s Muslim b) he’s from Africa c) he’s not a landlord.

The real FTFNYT's story is that three white reporters teamed up with a white supremacist to write a hit piece implying that the Africa-born child of a leading African intellectual conveniently identified as African for college admissions.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Eh, it takes practice to become un-pwnable but getting set free of that, becoming less flappable in the face of attempted domination, is a skill set worth working toward. It helps when the continuous attempts are so very predictable. And juvenile.

That's not to say there aren't serious matters to get genuinely upset and to rage about.

Senility Prayer:

God grant me the senility to forget the people I never liked anyway, the good fortune to run into the ones that I do and the eyesight to tell the difference.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Jamelle Bouie had to delete his bsky critique of this story because they violated the New York Times social media standards.

https://bsky.app/profile/jamellebouie.net/post/3lt44uitxc22x

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Bouie is probably the next good columnist to leave the NYT. I don't see how he stays there with his worldview.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Persistent paycheck?

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Stubborn defiance?

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I'm in the minority that I don't like Bouie, mainly because he spouts a lot of trickle-down, abundance BS. If he's not actually one, he's very very adjacent. He blocked me on twitter a couple of years ago when me and the rest of the housing justice people in NYC started beating down on his crap.

He'd fit in perfectly at the Atlantic.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Some of the discussion I was seeing on the article was about the nature of the data. The data came from a hack. Hack Clinton, and we get the "But Her Emails" scandal. Hack Trump, and it would be unethical to build articles on hacked data. Hack Columbia, and it is okay to race troll Mamdani. IOKIYAR.