I’ve been seeing quite a bit of blather on vocational/trades training on Bluesky, so I thought I’d add some background to the discussion so we can be a little more discerning on what worker and student-centered skills trades or vocational training looks like. I had such high hopes for Bluesky but all I see on there is low quality info, liberals scolding other liberals on language use and insufficient loyalty to the Democratic Party and a lot of crappy AI illustrations. Honestly, you’ll learn more on Tik Tok and definitely reach a broader audience.

Anyhoo. This is the building trades JATC system, which operates in all 50 states:

❝

To be sure, a skilled craft union apprenticeship is the "other four-year degree."

And I would wager that most people in America, including and especially lawmakers at all levels of government, would be stunned to learn that:

•Nearly two-thirds of all registered apprentices in the U.S. are trained in the construction industry

•Among construction apprentices, roughly 75 percent are trained in the unionized construction sector - known as the joint apprentice training committee (JATC) system.

•Every year, North America's Building Trades Unions and our signatory contractors direct over $1 billion in private investments towards this JATC system.

•When wages and benefits that are paid to apprentices are factored in, that annual investment exceeds $11 billion.

•Our unions and contractors operate more than 1,600 training centers in the United States

•If the Building Trades training system, which includes both apprentice-level and journeyman-level training, was a degree granting college or university, it would be the largest degree granting college or university in the United States -- over 5 times larger than Arizona State University.

•If we were a public university system, we would be the third largest public university system in the United State -- almost twice as large as the University of Texas system.

•And if we were a K-12 school district, we would be the fourth largest school district in the US, only behind New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago.

The only comparable skills-based training in existence today that has the track record of success enjoyed by the union construction industry's skilled craft apprenticeship infrastructure is that which is provided by America's armed forces.

JATC is a joint effort and investment between labor unions and contractors, with some federal funding. Yes, you read that right: the private sector pays for part of the training cost of their future employees. Imagine that! The 1960’s (when JATC was established) were a heady time. We still expected employers to cover some of the cost of training employees back then.

JATC programs operate with “standards” (pdf) - regulations that protect the apprentices from employers or entities or politicians that would turn apprenticeships into rip off, for profit “training” that the apprentice pays for. This is important because conservatives are flooding the zone with garbage that they’re calling “apprenticeships”. During Trump’s first term, for example, the Trump people developed a food service “apprenticeship” where the apprentice was to pay 25,000 a year for a certificate in food service that pays 10 dollars an hour. Cheap garbage that ticks the “apprentice” box but is wholly centered on the employer to the detriment of the student/employee. The public and employees shouldn’t be funding training at Taco Bell franchises.

Could we have something like the JATC for health care or tech skills training? Sure. But that would involve health care or tech employers paying some of the cost of training their future employees instead of shifting that cost to the public.

Trades are great. I’m a huge supporter. One of my sons is an IBEW journeyman electrician and he makes 46 an hour working for Stellantis in Detroit. I completed trades training after high school and although I ended up going to the postal service and then college and then law school. I don’t regret it at all. But not all trades training is a good deal for students. Without real regulation and a contract between the apprentice and the training center, vocations/trades training will turn into just another opportunity to turn young people into an ATM - paying for training that doesn’t pay off.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

C P1 year ago

My only observation with "the trades" is that in the general discourse, it's currently filling the slot that in other recent decades was filled with things like "learning to code," "going to college," and "starting your own business." All excellent things, except they're sold as an all-purpose gateway to the Good Jobs and away from the Loser Jobs. It's the latest in substitutes for a proper social policy; the only social policy we need is to scold people for not [for now, until another shiny object comes around] going into the trades like a smart and hardworking person instead of [whatever the current job to be denigrated is].

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

There was the usual blather by the usual glibertarians in trench coats at the other blog about this yesterday (the ones that represent the Dem's "gentrification problem" I write about). I brought up immigration and "the trades":

Interesting piece recently in of all places realtor.com, talking about immigration and the construction trades (which is what most people think when using the generic phrase “the trades”):

https://www.realtor.com/advice/home-improvement/housing-market-hispanic-workforce/?cid=soc_shares_article_X

One of the salient observations:

As more students are steered toward four-year college degrees, fewer are entering apprenticeship programs or vocational tracks that lead to construction careers. That shift has created a deficit in the kind of skilled, hands-on labor it takes to build homes and infrastructure.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

A non-blather response to that was:

*One thing Democrats have missed in terms of education policy; the discussion has mostly centered on childhood education and financing university.

These things are important. But we need a more comprehensive look at access to education. We need to push, publicly, for more support for trade school and helping people with professional certifications.

University isn’t for everyone at all times. Sometimes the same person will have different educational needs at different times. Not even everyone who might benefit from university in some respects necessarily needs a four year program.

Education needs to be more accessible, flexible in its goals, and involved in local communities.*

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Red states are doing this with “state technical colleges”. The one I lived near for 22+ years:

https://krcgtv.com/news/local/over-24000-students-enroll-at-state-tech-breaking-previous-records

Back then it was an after thought of a school, definitely for locals. In the late aughts, it became a “state” school which meant it’s credits were more integrated into the university system but still retained a “trades” attitude.

Do you learn how to be an electrician? No, but it is the kind of school that kinda tracks students into future bachelors degrees if they go that route in a construction trade.

And enrollment is booming.

And I’m seeing this approach in just about every Flyover Country state I travel thru, all red, all doing something that pertains to your comment.

People who continue to discount this as an entry to what’s considered middle class now are unserious thinkers. Not everybody is cut out for a 4-year degree and that shouldn’t be a pre-reg for economic upward mobility.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

In some areas, people are getting pigeon holed into low-paying nursing assistant jobs with no path to anything more lucrative than that.

Someone I know was considering one of those medical transcriptionist ads and considering it, but that is an area that could be wiped out by AI quickly, and the school is expensive. The appeal is the ability to work from home.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Our edumacation system, hollowed out the way it is, is (now) setup to do exactly that. It's sad and preventable. One way, as MM mentions frequently, is adequately funding public education and rethinking our approaches from K-12 and after.

But nope, ain't happening.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Medical transcriptionist -- is that even a thing anymore? Aside from AI wiping it out, most docs chart directly into e-records.

Avatar

Jeffrey C1 year ago

It’s still a thing. Many surgical notes or procedure notes would take too much time even with AI to compose. You can dictate 5 notes in the time it would take to write one. A bigger issue is understanding what is written. High school graduates often don’t understand the specialized vocabulary of health care, and takes time to bring them up to speed.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I have clients who "stack" credentials in health care. So a CTNA plus a cert so they can collect blood. That seems like a workable route.

Avatar

TXG1112 1 year ago

What annoys me most about the “trades discourse” which you allude to, but don’t mention explicitly is that the only reason that these jobs are good and viable is due to unions, not just for the training, but for the salary and benefits.

$46 per hour (~$90k per year) is about the average starting salary of a STEM college graduate with a ceiling of about double that (triple for some fields/regions). The idea that people don’t want to do Trade work because it isn’t respected is just an extension of typical white male grievance. Manual labor sucks, even if it pays decent and it sucks more the older you get. People go to college because email/laptop jobs pay well and don’t destroy your body. Working in the trades is only good in comparison to retail or food services. And the gulf between someone who is a journeyman versus a business owner is vast, and owning a trades company is totally different from merely being a licensed practitioner.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Manual labor has an age limit due to the body's ability to work under those conditions. One of my family friend's children is going to welding school so he can get a lucrative offshore job.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Yesterday I looked up plumbing jobs here in Denver. $36/hr to start seems somewhat normal. The apprentice programs that pay you $25/hr with an upward track is a way into what's left of the middle class that doesn't require a 4-year degree much less this automatic assumption now that the only thing worth getting in college is a friggin STEM degree.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

True. Thanks for the addition.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

The stuff that I post on BlueSky that gets traction is weird. 300 characters is still not enough to say anything nuanced, and the non-nuanced stuff is what seems to get the likes. But I don't see much AI imagery and Dem cheerleading, but that's because I unfollow that stuff.

Sepideh and I have both posted about our experiences with coding bootcamps, which are a massive scam in my opinion. I'm not a huge believer in "do what you love" as an employment strategy, but JFC you at least need some aptitude and interest in whatever training program you undertake, especially "coding". Millions of dollars, wasted, on the vast array of scammy coding training courses.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Turing was an excellent coding bootcamp in Denver, and I worked with excellent engineers out of their program. They closed this year after demand collapsed. Galvanize did not seem great. They had the people who had been ski bums until mid-life and were trying to figure things out and too much access to alcohol, in a way that created conflict in the space. The one that I tried to get into (that I do not remember the name of) had a ten step process for applying that was created to be very stressful. "Get this back to us in 24 hours" nonsense. They paid minimum wage while you attended, but there was some real condescension in this process because they had so many applicants. And it was just very surreal and unlike applying to actual tech jobs. It seemed like that bootcamp relied on a lot of material from https://www.freecodecamp.org/

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

There's no reason a bootcamp can't work for a certain small group of individuals who didn't have the patience/maturity in school but have aptitude. That's just not a very big group.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

The dirty secret is that most of the successful bootcamp graduates that I know had college degrees. They just had them in music or were school teachers.

Bootcamp allowed them to gain skills in the tech that was ubiquitous and in demand at the moment because jobs are not investing in training anymore.