This take is… insane (on so many levels it’s hard to know where to start).

I’m a former rural hospital COO. I’ve been in the trenches. This take could not be more idiotic. And it stems from what I’ll call TKESTM (“Trump Knows Everything Syndrome”). So, a doctor and Senator who knows better, and who’s NEVER taken this position before, suddenly thinks somehow “giving” people money so they can have “choice” via a fictional “free market” will solve our healthcare cost dilemma. All because an ignoramus who professes to know more about everything, than, well, anybody else comes up with a really stupid randomly generated “thought”.

Remember, Trump and Republicans have been saying for years that they’ll come up with a better plan for healthcare than the ACA (“Obamacare”), but they never do. Why? Basically - and I wish the media would point this out every f*^king time a Republican says they’ll come up with a better plan - because healthcare policy is complex and Republicans really have no interest or desire to do the hard thinking to figure this out (yes - it’s that simple).

Also, lest we forget what it was like in the ACA before-times, remember that the ACA did the following:

  • Guaranteed everyone could get health insurance at standardized rates (previously, insurers could deny you for having a “pre-existing condition” - asthma, diabetes, pregnancy, past surgery, even acne - and they could also charge sick people much higher premiums).

  • Removed lifetime benefit “caps” on health insurance policies (previously, plans could legally say, “We only cover $300,000 - or $1 million - in your lifetime,” which would wipe people out during serious illness).

  • Mandated every policy provide defined “Essential Health Benefits” - hospitalization, emergency services, maternity & newborn care, mental health & substance-use treatment, prescription drugs, preventive care, pediatric care, lab services, rehab services, and outpatient/doctor visits (previously plans could omit many of these, rendering them semi-useless to patients needing care).

  • Mandated that preventive care be free. The ACA dictated that plans must cover things like vaccines, colonoscopies, mammograms, and annual checkups without copays or deductibles (previously, most preventive care cost money out of pocket).

  • Critically, mandated the insurers spend a minimum amount of premiums received on medical care instead of on profits/admin costs. This is known ss the Medical Loss Ratio - “MLR” - and the ACA stated that insurers had to spend a minimum of 80-85% of premiums received on medical care, and if they didn’t they had to send rebates back to customers (previously, insurers could do whatever they wanted with premiums received from customers).

  • Banned gender-based premium differences (previously, women were often charged more than men for the same plan coverage).

  • There’s more, but that should be enough for now.

  • One final point - in order to make the ACA work, risk needed to be spread over the biggest possible pool of people (blending different health status, ages, etc.) - THIS IS HOW INSURANCE WORKS - IT SPREADS RISK OVER A LARGE POOL IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO BE SOLVENT WHILE ALSO HANDLING CLAIMS. This meant 1) expanding Medicaid, 2) mandating the otherwise uninsured to be part of the ACA (or else pay a penalty to incentivize the healthy to sign up), and 3) offering subsidies to those who couldn’t normally afford health insurance premiums. SCOTUS said 1 and 3 were unconstitutional (I call BS) and Congress got rid of the penalty provision in 2. Still, the ACA continued to materially reduce the number of uninsured in the country.

Let’s quickly explore why Republicans “know-nothing, death of expertise” view of the world is so harmful and dangerous. I like this analogy from Dean Baker in this article.

Given the difficulties in designing health care policy — which would be known to anyone remotely familiar with the debate — it’s hard not to be reminded of a famous Doonesbury comic strip from a half-century ago. In the strip, Michael Doonesbury, who is a typical college student, is sitting at a desk with his housemate, B.D., the star of the college football team.

B.D. asks Michael about the topic of the paper he’s writing for the biology class they are taking. Michael says he is writing on “juxta bronchial organ secretions in the higher mollusks.” He then asks about B.D.’s paper topic, which is “Our Friend the Beaver.” We are getting a ton of Our Friend the Beaver vibe out of Trump, and indeed much of the Republican Party, when it comes to their alternatives to Obamacare and the system of exchanges it created.

You Can’t Just Give People Money to Buy Health Care

As people who even very casually followed the debate over recent decades know, health care presents problems that cannot be solved just by giving people money to buy their own healthcare or insurance. Most people are healthy and have relatively modest bills, but the problem is that some people do have serious issues and end up with very large bills.

This is the reason for insurance. Putting aside a few thousand dollars a year on your own is not going to cover the cost of heart surgery or cancer treatment. This means that both people who have health issues need insurance, and even healthy people buy insurance in the event they could be in an accident or develop a serious health issue.

Incredibly, Trump and many Republicans seem to think it’s some sort of slam that a large portion of the people on the Obamacare exchanges don’t use their insurance. This is also true with auto insurance and fire insurance. In any given year most of us don’t use these; in fact, many of us may never use them in our lifetime. But we still mostly think it’s a good idea to have them in case we are in a bad car accident or our house burns down.

The big problem with health care insurance, which the “our friend the beaver” crowd misses, is that insurers don’t want to cover people who have major health issues. Unless the government forces them, insurers will either charge people with heart conditions or a history of cancer exorbitant premiums, or refuse to cover them altogether.

That isn’t a conspiracy theory; insurers don’t make a profit paying out large amounts of money in claims. This means that if we want people with serious health problems to be able to get insurance at an affordable price, the government has to regulate the market and limit the ability of insurers to discriminate based on pre-existing conditions.

For the “Our Friend the Beaver” crowd, this means that relatively healthy people will pay more than if we let insurers exclude unhealthy people from their pool. However, if the point is to ensure that people who actually need health care can get it, there is no alternative to government regulation with private insurers.

Finally, hard as it is to say, I agree with Trump on one thing. For-profit insurance companies are “money-suckers” (but NOT because of the ACA, which, again, limits how much these companies can use for profits/admin costs). Given his barely intelligible rantings, I assume The Trumpster is also against these same “money-sucking” companies receiving direct federal support payments in the scam we call the Medicare Advantage program, which is the only way these for-profit companies can make insuring high-risk seniors worthwhile.

If Insurance Companies Are the Problem, There is a Solution

We could go the opposite direction, which would fit some of Trump’s recent anti-insurance comments, and just have a universal health care system provided through the government, as we already do now with Medicare for our older population. A universal Medicare system would eliminate the problem of selective coverage and also get rid of hundreds of billions of dollars of administrative expenses and profits being paid to private insurers.

Along with excessive payments for drugs and doctors, this is one of the main reasons Americans pay so much more for health care than even everyone else. But there is no indication Trump is looking to establish a universal Medicare system.

Instead, we have a confused 79-year-old president leading his loyal followers in the Republican Party on a bizarre path in Never Never Land, where they make bold pronouncements on healthcare that ignore all the issues that have troubled serious analysts for decades. It would be great entertainment except that at the end of the show, millions of people may not get the health care they need.

The healthcare policy debate is, IMHO, the culmination of everything wrong with this perverted version of the Republican Party: relying on TKES (see above), worshipping words like “choice” and “free market” without actually understanding how they relate to the real world or a specific issue, unwilling to acknowledge the complexity of an issue (and the world in general) that requires complex solutions, ignoring - and looking down on - the needs of regular people, and banking on their view that low-information voters (i.e., people who are ignorant on politics/policy) will support their simplistic yet stupid ideas.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

r po1 year ago

For some reason, my wife and I are in a pretty complicated place wrt US health insurance. Perhaps it's because my wife turns 65 in Dec, but was on GA Access ACA for most of the year but we moved to AZ two months ago, which is not GA Access, and is signed up for Medicare, but boy howdy, is Medicare a mess. And I need to get switched to AZ ACA. Financing the move optimized the total costs but one of those costs is going to be working out the partial years along with ACA penalties due to the impossibility of estimating our income in 12/2024 given the uncertainties. Now dump on to this the load of steaming shit that is Republican ACA funding uncertainty.

We're going to be fine!

But do notice that the total benefit to us of all these multiple 10s of thousands of $$ plus many hours of working out the bridging details, including tax impacts, is about $200 for the entire year.

This is a world beating fucked up way to run a country's health care system. USA USA USA

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Totally agree r po. As someone who ran a hospital, my experience tells me that now that your wife is signed up for Medicare, I think you'll find it gets a lot easier after the first few months of billing are ironed out. Hope you guys are getting a supplemental plan for her as well. Plan G has the most comprehensive coverage, but your choice of plan obviously depends on provider and premiums.

Yeah, the system is effed up. Mainly, as I've said before, b/c it's not really one system. It's a patchwork of several different kinds of systems, plus we're the only developed country with for-profit insurers that really don't add value other than to make shareholders and management wealthier 🤦🏻‍♂️

Avatar

C P1 year ago

The problem with the entire patchwork is that you end up with a whole bunch of voters who are happy ("happy" here having the meaning of "I've got health insurance, it hasn't fucked me yet so I guess it's okay, and I'm terrified of change") with what they have and scream bloody murder when you talk about replacing it.

Even my dad, when you mention that single-payer would mean replacing his employer-provided health insurance, immediately hates the idea.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

I didn't see your comment, apologies, because you're absolutely correct about the voter dynamics.

Another anecdote: through my wife's corporate health insurance I got semi-elective foot surgery to correct some pretty debilitating dysfunction. This was a few years before the ACA. Before surgery: the doc says, your insurance tells us the copay is $400. I'm thinking it'll be $2K before this over, but we're ok with that. After surgery, nothing... for 4 months. Then I got a bill for $23K, discounted to $16K, and the letter was so happy telling me the percentage size of the discount! Finances then were tight and the Good News is after an hour I realized I probably didn't have heart disease, because otherwise I would have had a heart attack.

Here's why this matters for voters: The wife took the issue to corporate HR, which then went to bat for us, and through no further efforts on our part, got the bill reduced to IDK maybe $3K.

Constituent service, you might say.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

The anecdote I always remember is the time I had to rush to the nearest hospital to get an EKG because my heart seemed to be... not firing on all cylinders. I was scared enough at the time that I didn't really pause beyond asking the front desk if they took United Health Care, and they said they did. A couple months later, I naturally get a bill telling me that since they don't take my health care, I'm on the hook for $10,000.00 or so.

My lawyer cousins hear about this and send the hospital a letter on my behalf saying that they're contesting the charge. Hospital never responded to anyone, but in a matter of days my balance dropped from $10,000.00 to $0.00.

I've never had a better example in my life of "every one of these costs is made up and bears no resemblance to reality, they're literally just throwing the biggest number they think they can get away with at you and hoping you don't object."

Avatar

r po1 year ago

Wife currently working out whether she needs a Plan G or a Plan G High Deductible, and/or Medigap pays K, L, M, and N. Then there is Medicare Advantage, which are (AFAWK) geographically restricted. For instance, the Medigap Plans for Pima Co AZ has 34 different plans, each of which has a website address, which points to an agent.

Also in the mix are some of these are private and (AFAWK) have known lock you in the trunk scammer components. Certainly we could be (likely?) wrong and maybe there is a righteous path that can be threaded through all of this.

But lets just observe that we've both had a lot of professional success in our employment navigating for decent money many different kinds complexity: technical and corporate bureaucratic (I worked on 8 figure SOA NASA research equipment procurements, so well familiar with the regs), and there is a lot of documentation complexity here to wade through that 99% of people are simply unqualified to do. Nor should they have to.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

I was kinda hoping someone would pipe and say but everybody is happy with their Medicare!

Here's what this looks like to people who have had near flawless corporate or federal government health insurance for 40 years. These are the people you need to convince to support federal health insurance as the corporate model gets increasingly infeasible.

It looks like absolute, amazingly, utterly unnecessary bullshit designed to maximize profits for the financial parasites and obfuscate it all by maximizing the underlying complexity. And if you think we're just whiners and should just suck it up, well the bogleheads are where we learned about most of the reality here.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

👍🏻I just got on MCare, had major cancer surgery (I'm fine) and I am very happy with MCare and my supplemental - bills were in the hundreds of thousands' and my out-of-pocket for 2024 was $250. Personal opinion here and not advice, but I avoided Medicare Advantage like the plague. As a "system", it's a scam to transfer our tax dollars to private for-profit insurers, and the insurers' model is to commit fraud by claiming more diagnoses than actually exist, use narrow networks, deny coverage - the usual. JUST MY OPINION.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Replying to Joe:

John Oliver recently did a piece on "Medicare" "Advantage": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ejoi9yfLVCc

Avatar

r po1 year ago

Just to add Joe I'm not mad at you. Every time you write about this area of your expertise I pay very close attention. My wife and I are mad that all sorts of counter-party dark patterns based on information asymmetry that we've spent our lives understanding and learning how to mitigate are implicitly written into the structure of the Medicare ecosystem.

I just spent a half hour with my wife imagining what a cross-vendor "broker" for all these various plans would look like, in terms of data acquisition. The broker would somehow have to persuade competitors in the marketplace to reveal to the aggregate customer base via the broker particulars of their plan they absolutely don't want to share with external domain experts (the broker). We're very much still spectators but nobody we've ever seen in the b2b world would willingly acquiesce to this structure. Instead, the buy side simply maintains internal "buyers". No info sharing across corporations. A buyer is a paid employee.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Also, take the bone away from employers gnawing to depress wages because health insurance "benefits."

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

The stupid, it burns!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

A favorite reply:

"If only being healthy came with some kind of incentive."

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I've come to the conclusion after all these years that the worst word in politics is

"Choice"

"Choice" is used to promote so many awful policies with shitty long term outcomes.

And it's a classic, and applicable, example of "Both Sides Do It."

Whenever I hear an elected Dem yammer on about "choice" on anything, I can automatically tell which part of the Party they come from and how I wanna launch them into the sun.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I just went through the "choice" of re-upping for another year on the ACA and let me tell you it is fuckery of the first order.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Avatar

C P1 year ago

X-wing all the way, although the A-wing is a serious runner-up, and if we're bringing in the expanded universe, might have to go with E-wing, which essentially combines both.

... wait, wrong kind of fighter.

Avatar

Busted Knee1 year ago

Come sit with me. Play STEAM games, I'll learn ya.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Even some of the doctors are all in on a single payer national health plan. Been rooting for these people for years:

https://pnhp.org/

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Excellent takedown! I once received an MLR refund check.

All of this brouhaha created for ages about what should be a simple thing (how to pay when we get sick) is just such an infuriating smokescreen. Take out the profit incentives and create a single payer who treats everyone equally seems like a no brainer to me, but what do I know. Also, dental care is health care just like every other part of the body.

Health insurance is not health care.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Don't even get me started on dental, hearing and vision being treated as somehow not really part of our health...

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I had to see an oral surgeon because a dentist saw something on the roof of my mouth that should have a biopsy. My health insurance would not cover that medical procedure because it was an "oral" surgeon!
🙄🤬

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Cassidy was a medical doctor and also saw it fit to vote for RFK, Jr. He needs to shut up forever and ever and go away.

We are about to uneliminate measles due to the foolishness of this administration. https://www.livescience.com/health/viruses-infections-disease/us-could-lose-its-measles-elimination-status-within-months-experts-say

A mom died of pre-eclampsia in Texas because the doctors in her forced-birth state lied to her as she continued to get sicker. https://www.propublica.org/article/texas-abortion-ban-tierra-walker-preeclampsia

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Butbutbut, we’re being told by certain “progressive” “thought leaders” coughKleincoughTandencough that that’s a small price to pay for a maybe temp-Dem house majority, ie., run forced-birther Dems in red states.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Sepideh - Agree on Cassidy. The examples you give are a symptom of a society (or at least a significant part of society) that puts $$$$ over the value of people's life and health. I'd argue we are sick as a society...

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

That’s a pretty compelling argument based on where things stand.