Warning and full disclosure: I used AI to create the cover picture.

I was in the middle of writing a post about healthcare and I needed a short break to collect my thoughts. I ate a small pre-bed snack, worked through my nightly going to bed routine and decided to do a few minutes of online catching up before finishing the post.

And then I came across this (click HERE for the entire video of the interview; the whole thing is worth it (regardless of views on his policies, Mamdani is a generational talent), however, the supermarket part starts at the 31:58 mark):

This really pissed me off. So, I put the healthcare post on the shelf to discuss this clip. This is Aaron Ross Sorkin at the New York Times Deal Book Summit asking mayor Mamdani about his plan for subsidized grocery stores in New York City. Specifically, Sorkin is framing the question from an economics perspective of capitalism versus socialism. As if, somehow, public services and public goods are mutually exclusive from existing alongside capitalism and the private sector.

Of course, Mamdani is up to the task and - calmly, efficiently and with a smile on his face - completely disarms and destroys Sorkin’s implicit argument.

To me, this interview gets to the heart of our country’s somewhat unique view that capitalism and free markets will solve all of our problems if we only just don’t get in the way.

First, let’s start with the fact that Mamdani is proposing five grocery stores (one in each borough in New York City), and that there are approximately 1,000 currently existing supermarkets in NYC. So, he wants to add 0.5% more stores. To anyone with any math or economic knowledge, this is pretty darn unlikely to materially impact other stores.

Why is Mamdani proposing this? Because there are what are called “food deserts” in NYC (as there are in many other parties of the country). A “food desert” is somewhere where the private sector is not establishing supermarkets because the major grocery store corporate chains don’t believe it would be profitable to operate in those areas.

Hmmm, I wonder if Sorkin asked any of his other corporate guests in tech and other industries if it made economic sense for them to get income tax breaks, federal subsidies, property tax abatements, etc. that the public is providing to them? I must have missed that part of the Deal Book Summit.

You see, the private sector is not in the business of doing “good” for the public’s sake. The private sector exists, in theory, to incentivize people and companies to provide goods and services by allowing them to make profits by doing so. If a company deems a market or geographic area likely to be unprofitable, they simply won’t establish a business there.

That is why economists talk about “public goods”. Things such as clean air and water, education, healthcare, mail, electricity, and in today’s world, high-speed internet service. These are products/services that we as a society deem necessary to be able to properly function as individuals in our society.

Let’s take the mail, for example. The remit of the U.S. Postal Service is to deliver mail to every single home and business address in the U.S. That means from Key West Florida to Nome Alaska to Navajo Country in the southwest to upcountry Maine to Hana Hawaii. Yes, there are private carriers such as Fed Ex and UPS (and now Amazon) who deliver mail and packages as well. But they choose not to deliver everywhere, because some delivery locations are not profitable for them. So what do they do? They contract with the American people (in the form of the government run and funded USPS) to deliver the “last mile” to an otherwise unprofitable address/location. The key point here is that the USPS is not supposed to make money. It’s supposed to provide universal and affordable mail delivery.

The same goes for high speed internet. I live in the rural intermountain West. Frankly, Internet service at our house sucks. Why? Because the big internet/telecom/cable companies don’t think it’s profitable to bring Fiber to our house. It’s why the government has stepped in to help fund high-speed Internet in America.

It’s why we have public community hospitals and public education. The private sector will never be able or willing to serve every student in America and every patient in America. So publicly funded schools and hospitals coexist with private schools and for-profit hospitals.

We don’t expect the military to make money, or our law enforcement and court systems, or the Border Patrol. We didn’t expect rural electrification to make money, and we didn’t expect our National Park system to be profitable when it was originally created.

Back to the smug, condescending attitude of Aaron Ross Sorkin towards Mamdani’s effort to actually bring affordable food to his constituents. This is truly one of America’s most destructive and damaging blind spots. Most every other developed country has figured out that while the private sector has its place, there are some public goods and societal needs that only the government can universally provide. Those societies are generally less unequal and happier than the good ‘ole USofA.

The big question is this: Can a new and strong congressional Democratic majority start the laying the groundwork now - to be fully implemented when we elect a Democrat as president in 2028 - to ensure government does what the private sector cannot and provides the American people with support for the public goods that we deem necessary to, in the written words in the Declaration of Independence, enjoy, “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” as well as, in the written words of the U.S. Constitution, “establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity,”.

Let’s hope that is our future path…

The Beatles - Come Together