I’m sitting here in a forest service campground at 9,500 feet somewhere in Wyoming and I’m glad that Joe isn’t the only one who’s Wypoxic. I hope I’m altitude acclimated, but this piece from Brian Beutler seems to get a lot right. Here are the nut graphs:

❝

[…] To me, big tent politics entail making more people feel like they want to squeeze in, using ideological diversity as a major draw. But that would require taking real pride in the diversity, wielding it in explicit contrast to Republicans: their viciousness, their bad faith, and their expectation of total fealty to Donald Trump.

You’d want people across the party to brag about the good faith disagreements they have with their colleagues: We all think health care should be a right in America, we have some disagreements about what that looks like in practice, but if you want health care to be a privilege, the GOP might be for you. We all agree that every person should be treated with dignity, we have some disagreements about how to adjudicate disputes when rights come into conflict, but if you want to be abusive to trans people, or slap chains onto grandmothers and drag them to El Salvador, you should check out the Republican party. We are all serious about making everyone in America safe from crime, we have different ideas about which approaches maximize justice for all, but if you want police in your community to be more violent and less accountable, that’s the other party’s thing. We all feel free to disagree with our leaders, but if you want to stop thinking for yourself, you know where to find Donald Trump.

Beutler’s piece begins by noting that Barack Obama likes Mamdani and called to congratulate him on his win. Then he transitions to a discussion of two pollsters’ view of WAR (Wins Above Replacement), which those pollsters call WARP (Wins Above Replacement Probability). WARP differs from WAR by looking at winning rather than margin of win.

It shouldn’t surprise anyone that the top WARP Democrats are folks like Golden in Maine, Glusenkamp Perez in Washington and Marci Kaptur in Kay’s part of Ohio.

The point of WARP is to correct the notion that ideological moderation is the be-all and end-all of winning. Taken as a whole (not just focusing on the unicorns like Golden and MGP), WARP shows that moderation doesn’t really yield a lot more wins for Democrats. In Beutler’s view, this is the ugly truth:

“You can campaign comfortably along almost any part of the Democratic ideological spectrum, while developing a moderate image, by, e.g.:

  • Describing your agenda as “common sense” rather than revolutionary;

  • Being white and/or male rather than black and/or female;

  • Being “folksy”;

  • Having good propaganda, and good responses to oppositional propaganda;

  • And, yes, emphasizing heterodoxy on an issue or a small number of issues.

Voters perceived Joe Biden to be more moderate than Donald Trump, whom they perceived to be more moderate than Hillary Clinton, even though Biden ran to Clinton’s left, and Trump is a fascist […]”

I think Tim Walz is an example of the kind of candidate Beutler is envisioning.

Anyway, I’m not in love with the white / male vs black / female part of this, but the point is that ideology means less than candidate quality. I think that’s a basic truth in politics, and the freakout over ideology is driven by donors who don’t want more liberal policies, not by the base.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 1 year ago

This was a slow but important revelation for me, especially during 2024:

“You can campaign comfortably along almost any part of the Democratic ideological spectrum, while developing a moderate image ..."

The reason for this, I believe, is that most voters just do not decide on candidates based on policy, and some voters don't pay attention to policy at all. It's how much they trust or like candidates, and that depends a bit on what candidates say, but also how they say it, and how they look and behave.

The rest of voter support for a candidate is like physics: inflation up, incumbent support down—employment down, support down—external threats up, support up. I do not believe the centrist idea that being too "woke" (whatever that is!) reduces support; it just enrages right-wingers and ensures their turnout.

Our side could make use of an excited base, if centrists weren't so averse. And I seriously doubt it would alienate normies, if the center could just leave it the fuck alone

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Marcy Kaptur is a Toledo native and just loved. That’s how she’s managed to stay in that seat. She’s also very hardworking and squeaky clean - she’s just a good representative. My sense is she would like to retire - she has a huge extended family - but she knows if she does Dems lose the seat.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Pretty spot, mm. Definitely stay there a while. I envy that view.

I feel like the “moderate/Leftist” divide would be less nasty if moderates would admit that they’re further Right than Leftists and that’s what they object to - which is fine! - instead of accusing the Left of racism or anti semitism. Just have the ideological disagreement. My local Democratic group and my local “resistance” group are both further Right than me, but we don’t hate one another because I don’t attack their character and they don’t attack mine. I think a lot of Democrats cannot handle conflict, so avoid it in an unhealthy, passive aggressive (and chickenshit) way. I would respect Jeffries more if he would just say “Mamdani is too far Left for me” rather than this kind of underhanded hinting that Mamdani is somehow dangerous. That’s gross and dishonest.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

At this point, I’ve seen too much from Jeffries to ever respect him. But I don't have the same loathing for him that I do for Chuck Schumer — especially after seeing John Oliver’s piece last week about Schumer and his bizarre obsession with the fictional family that lives in his head called ‘The Baileys’.

Any decent Democrat should be able to win in New York. It’s unconscionable that they are saddled with the likes of Schumer, Gillibrand and Jeffries. The only Democratic congressional delegation shittier than NY is NH.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Why can’t they just say “public grocery stores make me nervous” instead of this weird dancing around, hinting that Mamdani is somehow “not one of us” ? It’s gross. I mean, my God if you’re THAT conflict averse that you can’t pick apart his proposals (instead of attacking him as a person) maybe you’re not cut out for politics.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Left Coast update

"Wilson, like Mamdani, is a big public transit nerd who’s made “affordable and abundant housing” a key plank of her campaign. She was a leader in the 2020 JumpStart Seattle initiative, which taxed corporations with high salaries to create a fund that would invest in long-term affordable housing. (Her campaign site rips Harrell for instead using much of the funding to eliminate a city budget shortfall, rather than raising more revenue through conventional means. Bummer, people needing affordable housing.)"

Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

As always, my snippet doesn't do justice to the entirety. It's not a long read unless you follow the link to her essay.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Yeah… I’m not so sure about Katie Wilson. Her profile is quite different than Mamdani.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

This is my first introduction to her

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Keep reading. 😊

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

What sets both of them apart is neither is pimping the trickle-down, Reaganomic "abundance" "build your way to affordability" crapola that the yimby stormtroopers™ have been doing on behalf of blue urban city electeds and developers for almost a decade now with disastrous results.

One of the reasons the comments at the other blog went off the rails was when several yimby stormtroopers™ arrived in 2016 and started to turn every thread into pushing their agenda. Glibertarians in Trench Coats.

Those same people decry "disorder" in the urban core they've carpetbagged into which means they love them their "law and order" candidates, you just can't put it that way to a pale-blue, entitled white voter like that. The homeless mess up their Exclusively White, Urban Living Theme Park experience.

Seattle and Denver are basically the same in terms of the economic issues we face but we'd never get somebody like her into the second round of voting, particularly given her views on housing.

Avatar
Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

If the root of homelessness is commodified housing

is one of many key takeaways from that piece and yeah, she pretty much nails every point and opinion on homelessness from my work here. And yeah, I work with neighbors and businesses in groups trying to contend with what's seen as an intractable problem.

Reading that was basically a reply of many meetings I've had with a day shelter right along Colfax, another business with long-time mentally ill people in and out of housing and a group expanding their 20% AMI, perm wrap around services building in my 'hood (with no neighborhood opposition).

One reason for the latter is that they talk with us in good faith. We've got some developers trying to build something similar, or they present it as something similar, when it's nothing more than market rate, ie., commodified.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

My old DelCo suburb Middletown Twp. just put the kibosh on a long planned for warehouse project because of bad faith by the developers AND people are coming put to municipal meetings all over DelCo to object to gentrification by developers who promise nothing but high rents and even higher sales prices. It's slightly encouraging. People have not objected to halfway houses and low income housing there with that kind of vehemence.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

"Good faith" is the key thing here. Before we moved back into an urban environment, I wasn't nearly as axe grindey about the center/center-right than I am now.

What drove me to that? Lack total lack of "good faith" from those people as represented by the mass of entitled white urbanists here and as I discovered, nationally. It's been eye opening to see a "movement" using methodology straight out of Big Tobacco with a large dose of forced-birther messaging techniques. Lee Atwater would love these fauxgressives.

Just look at the messaging in a broader sense from the Abundance Coachella electeds earlier this year. They're not debating in good faith, they're pushing an agenda using groups that are staffed full time to propagandize the public, fund and then pressure pols and act no differently than the NRA or the fossil fuel lobby.

And I've seen first hand what that's done to (D) appeal to non-whites and working class people across all ethnic groups.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

I don't think that all of the white urbanists or even most of them are into the abundance nonsense.

There are a number of people into environmentalism, walkability, and bikeability.

Here is a video from some northern Virginia environmental people. It is goofy, but it is on-point too. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOXnynBjYY8

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Every one here, every one, considers themselves a New Democrat or are part of the New Liberalism club, aka "abundance"; I've been battling these clowns (and losing) for the better part of five years--I clash with them in City outreach meetings. They've co-opted both housing justice and environmental justice language (the greenwashing they do is vast) to push the agenda.

They love them their Petterson House members. And per my comment about Seattle, they'd die before they'd vote for somebody outside that center/center-right portion of the party.

Lotsa old libruls like me are into what you said but most of it is done is such a way as to make little sense but make damn sure everybody knows the political demographic in charge of things.

We see this play out in Denver City politics and across the Federal electeds spectrum in Colorado.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Seattle is a bit different. We have a penchant for electing folks pretty far to the left. Part of the reason that Wilson did so well in the primary was that people were not pleased with Mayor Harrell and his brand of centrism. But it’s not that long ago we had hardcore socialists like Kshama Sawant on the Seattle city council.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Today our town is celebrating its second annual Diversity Fest. Local activism group will have a table/booth with games and prizes! Spin the Wheel! Voter registration is the goal as well as recruitment and reminding everyone that we have Municipal Elections this November.

I have a rainbow hued Rolling Stones tongue T-shirt to wear and am contemplating getting some fancy pink and purple temporary hair dye, but it might rain...

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

I think he is right about the white and male thing.

There are a lot of people in this world who are going to go in with a "women can't win" attitude so we are going to have a bunch of pale and male candidates for the next Presidential run. But they have to overcome the whole "white men all look the same" issues that have hampered them in the past. When there are a lot of old white dudes, they have all looked like products of whatever factory creates politicians, and we get confused about which candidate is speaking in a debate.

The link below was the Democratic Primary in 2020. Now tell me the name of all those white dudes. I have no clue who those white dudes are, and at least two of them are my Senators.

https://images.app.goo.gl/GMpcZoG6xHMVH41x6

Those three white dudes near Klobuchar? I have no clue who any of them are.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I don't even know who John Delaney is. And I'd forgotten that the super odious Seth Moulton ran. Beto I remember and unlike most, not a fan. He was just another House (D) from a friendly district who, like every "next greatest thing" that gets fluffed in TX, massively underwhelming outside the confines of that safe House district.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Yeah, Beto is the sum of our electoral worst fears. He seems to appeal to Dems outside of Texas, but once he started running for higher office in Texas, he just couldn’t get the votes.

I hope the same fate doesn’t befall Kat in Illinois.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

She's got to get elected in a D+29 district first and my fear is that the "abundance" bro mayor of Evanston, a guy theoretically suited for a D+1 district (if you buy into that entire "gotta run to the right to win in 'competitive' districts bullshit), will win handily.

I hope not.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Also too, that link shows just how not-all-that-progressive the entire 2020 primary line up looked, I don't think I fully understood just how dominant that crowd was.

Harris and Mayo Pete were easily the most centrist of the lot although in hindsight, the entire Hick/Bennett/Gillebrand contingent fall into that category. Discounting the "flake" factor, the only people with decent liberal bona fides would have been Biden and Warren.

And we see how the Party eventually treated Biden. Heh heh, I don't meant to sound like one noted commenter on the other blog when I say that. ;)

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

Hey! I resemble that remark! ;)

But I do agree with what the article quoted up top says. For the foreseeable future, the Democrats simply cannot afford to nominate anyone for President who isn't a white male. A white straight Christian -coded male, to be even more specific. That is one of the reasons I am not ruling out Gavin Newsom as a potential nominee, despite his unpopularity on the left. He checks all the boxes.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Newsom is saying and doing the right things now so good for him but 2028 is a looong ways away.