I’m free thinking while I write this, so feel free to clap back at me if you disagree or have thoughts.

Yesterday’s primary election in KY-4 where Thomas Massie lost to the MAGA candidate started to solidify my thinking on primaries, voter turnout and party dynamics.

It seemed to me the evil genius of the Tea Party when it first emerged and subsequently morphed into MAGA was/is their willingness to show up in primaries.

While I don’t have the exact 2026 data from yesterday’s primary in KY, the numbers from 2024 voting data and 2026 population data can help tell the tale (note: Presidential election cycles like 2024 generally have higher turnout than “off-year” non-Presidential elections cycles).

Bear with me.

  • The population of KY-4 in January 2026 was approximately 776,000

  • The number of registered voters in KY-4 in January 2026 was approx. 597,000 (or 77% of the total population

  • The total number of votes in the Republican primary in KY-4 yesterday was approx. 106,000, or 18% of registered voters (this is unusually high for an “off-year” election; the total number of votes in the 2024 Republican primary in KY-4 was 54,000, or 9% of all registered voters)

  • The MAGA winner in KY-4, Ed Gallrein, received approx. 58,000 votes, or just under 10% of all registered voters in KY-4 (as an FYI, in 2024, the 50%+1 number needed to win the Republican primary was approx. 27,001 votes, or 4.5% of registered voters)

  • Gallrein’s winning margin over Thomas Massie was approx. 10,000 votes, or about 1.7% of all registered voters in KY-4

  • BTW, turnout for young people is much lower. In KY-4 in 2024, turnout for 17-34-year-olds (for both parties) was 4.5% of registered voters

  • Finally, the people who turnout for primaries tend to - obviously - be the most politically engaged people who skew further out on the Bell Curve

The result is that in non-competitive “red” districts, we can extrapolate that somewhere between 5% and 10% of all registered voters in KY-4 determines the winner of not just the primary election, but also the general election. And those who do vote in the primary tend to skew heavily TP/MAGA.

I’m not sure the Tea Party consciously realized this when it coalesced in the early 2010s, but it was - and is - their “evil genius”: their willingness to primary incumbents, especially in deep red districts. This “willingness to primary” had dual benefits. Either 1) the TP/MAGA candidate wins, or 2) the more “moderate” incumbent must tack further right in order to win the primary.

Now, there are downsides to this “strategy” (I put that in quotes because I’m not sure it’s always a considered strategy - it may just be a result of TP/MAGA being TP/MAGA). In competitive congressional districts (which gerrymandering has reduced considerably) and statewide Senate races (which cannot be gerrymandered), TP/MAGA primary winners - or “moderate” Republican primary winners who have tacked further right - may have more difficulty winning the general election (2010 examples: Christine O’Donnell in DE, Sharron Angle in Nevada and Ken Buck in Colorado). However, R incumbents who do win their primary after tacking further right, and then win the general election, serve to move the “Overton Window” - the accepted mainstream “norm” - much further to the right.

Let me repeat to be clear. In most deep red congressional districts, it only takes a single digit percentage of all registered/eligible voters to determine who goes to DC as a congressperson. And 80% (or more) of eligible voters don’t vote in primaries.

Is there a lesson here for Democrats, or is this just a TP/MAGA phenomenon?

Democrats historically gnash their teeth at primarying incumbents. It’s somehow viewed as disloyalty or a waste of financial resources or unnecessary internecine fighting. Basically, IMHO, Dems historically prefer intra-party civility to moving their candidates and elected officials in the policy direction their base generally prefers. The results over the past 10-20 years have - to put it mildly - not been optimal.

So put me in the camp of encouraging Democratic primaries, especially in today’s world where the “institutionalist” wing of the party seems so out of touch with not just their base, but frankly, the vast majority of voters in the U.S. who are struggling and see a political class that doesn’t seem to care about them.

Let’s rouse our engaged 5-10% in primaries and see what happens.

Thoughts?

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

After watching successful Koch astroturfing morph from the Tea Party into TurningPointUSA and redhat "influencers" paid directly by Russia, I suggest that donors & funding should be very closely watched in this environment. A good candidate is one who divulges that early and often - repeatedly. If a primary candidate passes that test, have at it and interview for the job (depending of course on locale and performance of incumbent).

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Verify, then trust!

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

Part of the reason this doesn't happen in the D primaries is fear. There's nobody more fearful than a lot of the D base, and even if they agree with the positions of a more lefty candidate, they're extremely susceptible to the arguments that the candidate is too radical and will therefore lose this important seat, blah, blah, blah. You see a lot of the fear-based reasoning in places like the comments of Balloon-Juice. The party establishment knows that fearmongering works. One of the (weak) arguments by Ken Martin about the DNC not releasing the autopsy was because he feared that it would cause the base to focus on the autoposy rather than on winning the next election. It's a recipe for never changing the status quo, and never having a fair fight out in the open.

There's also a lot of fearmongering about primaries because some people believe (wrongly) that the Hillary/Bernie primary lost the Presidency for Hillary.

Avatar

C P6 months ago

That, and the fact that (and for once this isn't even just Democratic voters) normies tend to be wildly off-base when estimating the relationship between what they believe and what the people they vote for believe. People like Bernie and AOC are treated like PFLP commandos when their actual politics are basically "New Deal without the segregation." People at the other end of the party are treated like responsible moderate adults in the room when they're really conservatives who'll throw any progressive cause under the bus the minute someone at the New York Times says they should.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic6 months ago

Right? My post was getting long but I almost - and probably should have - put that in. Most "progressive policy positions" are pretty darn popular, whether on the economy, healthcare, childcare, the environment, inequality, corporatism, etc.

Avatar

Busted Knee6 months ago

Not that. BJ only cares about social issues and not only doesn't care but actively hates working people. What they want is iron clad rule by educated professionals where everyone not only shuts up about their suffering but yells in extatic joy about their decisions. And then they project their own eagerness for power and lying onto the left, the MSM, everyone but themselves.

They are actively evil.

Avatar

C P6 months ago

Well, the other half of the teabagger phenomenon is that their elites were actually on their side. All the superwealthy donors who power movement conservatism were on their side, and assisted them in overthrowing their own "centrists." The "establishment" the teabaggers were rebelling against were basically a gaggle of consultants and professional politicians in Washington who were never the actual top of the pyramid. There wasn't much to rebel against there in the first place. Even the claim that it was a rebellion was largely a whitewash meant to protect the teabaggers from any unfortunate association with the Republicans who'd just spent eight years trashing the country.

None of this is to say that we shouldn't primary centrist Democrats. That's clearly the only way out. I'm just saying we'll have far more of an uphill battle, because both the media and the superwealthy donors, which were key to the teabaggers' success, will be on the opposing side here.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

Yep, the media bought the bullshit about the tea party members being salt of the earth types when they were really ultra-radical right-wingers with ugly views who often threatened violence (implicitly or explicitly). I attended a town hall in my district in NY when the teabaggers were getting started and it was a bunch of loudmouth mostly males who were swaggering around being rude and shitty to everyone.

Compare that to the way that a Demcratic challenger from the left is treated by the media: as a horrible radical with crazy ultra-left views. Mamdani is a good example.

Avatar

Scott H6 months ago

Well, we've got a poster child for what you've described here in CO-01, thus, it'll be one example of how this will play out.

Despite all the shit DeGette's getting this cycle, she will win the primary handily and it won't be like the yimby mayor of Evanston in IL-09 (who some dumbass on twitter is insisting is some kind of Bernie Bro liberal) who benefited from a shitload of primary opponents splitting the vote a gazillion ways.

Avatar

John S.6 months ago

That was the one major mistake Kat made. She should have consolidated the pack and gotten endorsements from all those progressive candidates that didn’t stand a chance of winning, but could split the vote enough to allow the dud to slip through.

Live and learn.

Avatar

Scott H6 months ago(edited)

To be fair, I don't think it was anything she could influence. I followed the general coverage of the primary and if anything, one thing that kept a lot of the others in was resentment that a "carpetbagger" like her could just swoop in and literally suck all the money and oxygen out of the room.

It was definitely an example of "not checking one's ego at the primary door".

One thing was abundantly clear, the district vote was maybe 60-40 against the kind of candidate the yimby mayor was and the AIPAC candidate. His "win" certainly isn't a mandate by any stretch although with the advantage of incumbency (and money raising), it'll be interesting to see if anybody primaries him in 28.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

Certainly in CO-1, Wanda James could drop out because she's not running much of a campaign or gaining any traction, but she won't.

Avatar

Scott H6 months ago

And she just filed a lawsuit against the other CU Regents saying they were stifling her when they censured her: https://denverite.com/2026/05/19/wanda-james-lawsuit-university-of-colorado-regents/

How that helps her unseat DG is mysterious.

The voting bloc she appears to have here are Denver's old school black establishment and I don't see them affecting this. Even if James wasn't in, they view somebody like Kiros much the way so many people saw Kat in IL-09. Okay, maybe not as "carpetbaggy" as what was hurled at Kat but somebody new, somebody young and somebody not part of the Denver black establishment. Yes, they're fed up with DeGette like old-school Denver liberals like me but it doesn't mean extending support to somebody they see as an interloper.

Unlike the yimby mayor who's final vote talley was pretty pathetic, DeGette's gonna pull in over 50%. Hope I'm wrong but I don't see the Brittany Petterson-type voters here going for anybody other than their grandmother.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic6 months ago

John - Easier said than done. In my closest race, there was a third-party libertarian who had no chance. Long story, but I tried to get him to back me by offering him a voice. No go. He told me he thought the race was between him and my Repub opponent. In the end, he got about 2-3% of the vote. I needed about 10% of his 2-3% total to win. Still pisses me off...