Sarah Taber, who has the YouTube channel Farm to Taber, has a really good video discussing a NYT story about some farmers who had to close their farm. Here are the key points:

  • The farmers were wealthy (they had a couple of million dollars worth of land).

  • Their farm was essentially a hobby project.

  • They were trying to make a living selling a bulk commodity (milk) even though they didn’t have the scale to make a profit.

  • The farm closed after the owners had to work the farm themselves (probably because of a shortage of immigrant labor).

  • They were Trump supporters.

Even though the New York Times doesn’t understand it, the “small family farm” is essentially dead. My wife’s family were farmer/ranchers, and my dad grew up on a farm — they were both “small family farmers”. Today, those farms are rented to a grandson (in my wife’s case) and mostly sold to a neighbor (in my dad’s case) because there’s no way to run a profitable farming operation without having a couple of million dollars of equipment and millions of dollars of land in order to have some economy of scale.

The need for scale means that today’s farmers are relatively well-off and, like most other well-off small town businesspeople, they’re going to vote Republican. There’s really no way to convince them to vote for Democrats because they generally believe that Republicans have their best interests in mind, and they aren’t wrong. Trump might have screwed them in the last round of tariffs, but overall their interests are best served by the rich people’s party, the Republicans.

This brings us to Taber’s really smart insights. We can all agree that our food supply is incredibly important to the country. So, why are we trusting it to a group of people who are dumb enough to vote for Trump? Their judgment is too flawed to put that kind of trust in them. And, if their judgment is so poor, why not let them fail so that others can take over their land and maybe do a better job farming it? She thinks that the “sky is falling” farm rhetoric is just a PR campaign to shake money out of city dwellers who are constantly told they’re too ignorant to make a judgment about agriculture. (Where I grew up, it was a constant joke about that farmers are always crying, to the point that my dad would say that he knew a baby he delivered was going to be a farmer because it cried really loudly after it was delivered.)

I think her point can be generalized. Our media and other establishment institutions are inclined to protect the incumbent members of the status quo. Yet these people are often second or third generation people who make bad decisions. Our society is ready, willing and able to penalize poor people who have made bad decisions, but millionaires who screw up expect sympathy. This needs to end.

Or, as Taber says, “We need to be able to look a millionaire dead in the eyes, watch him be sad, and say ‘that’s your problem, not mine.’”

The whole video is very worth watching.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

The Mennonite population here has done very well branching out. They keep their large, picturesque farms & dairies running & producing, and the younger generation now has very many retail businesses selling hardware, home appliances, farm equipment, e-bikes, a bunch of general merchandise stores and a huge grocery outlet store, ice cream restaurants, etc. I just spent some time in my dentist's waiting room with 3 of the most well behaved children I've ever encountered, all reading young adult novels meant for older yute or playing thumb wrestling very quietly while their mother was in the chair. These folks are very smart, patient people but they still vote rethug as far as I know 😞

Avatar

mister mixAuthor4 months ago

They're the source of the measles outbreaks in Texas and Chihuahua Mexico. It came from a Mennonite colony in Alberta, then TX then MX.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago(edited)

Yep, the anti-modern medicine thing is a major problem here too. But it's maybe becoming less widespread as the elders die out and the yute come into heavy regular contact with us they call "the English" when doing so much retail biz.

Avatar

Kay W.4 months ago

Trump and Vance are threatening Greenland again. I don’t think they understand the depth of Nordic nationalism. The US has nothing approaching it. Danes are people who feature the Danish flag at every single birthday party. You’re having a party for your 3 year old? You can buy paper Danish flags at every grocery store. They will absolutely die for Denmark. They would consider it an honor.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

He's such shameful embarrassment on the world stage. GAH

Avatar

Kay W.4 months ago

All true. I did legal work for them. They are all multimillionaires. Land values have gone way up the last 10 years. I just can’t deal with “business people” who are too stupid to figure out that food stamps are an ag subsidy. Any other business where you told owners “we’re going to fund this huge program where we feed poor people on your products”, owners would be celebrating. Instead all they do is whine.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago(edited)

This is a great video showing the shades of treachery surrounding the myths being perpetuated; our media has very dirty hands.

Another great myth buster is the Farming While Beige guy.

https://m.youtube.com/c/sylvanaquafarms

Avatar
Avatar

C P4 months ago

Thank you for this. Sarah Taber is one of the rare ones who doesn't fall for the Wholesome Small-Town Folksy People shtick from farmers and other rural elites. Not surprisingly, she grew up rural herself.

Note that this scam has been around in some form since the foundation of the republic. Thomas Jefferson talked a lot about wanting a nation of independent yeoman farmers in contrast to Adams' vision of industry, banking, and, well ::wrinkles nose:: cities. Except Jefferson's actual business - and that of most elites in his neck of the woods - was large slave plantations, which were a disaster for independent farmers for the same reason WalMarts are a disaster for small businesses two centuries later.

Avatar

Sepideh M4 months ago

If this is the video I think it is, I loved the part where she said they were making passive income from fracking.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor4 months ago

Yeah, they're sitting on a gold mine and they don't want to sell a little bit of it. It's like saying "please help me I have so much money in the bank but I don't want to withdraw any of it."

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

My wife's family on her mother's side were almost all farmers/ranchers in two areas of Kansas, descended from a Swedish immigrant couple who arrived in 1868.

And over our 2-decades back in Missouri, she watched them go from not-batshit-insane conservative farmers/ranchers to RWNJs who, over the last decade, have all sold out not unlike you you describe.

It's been replicated all over Flyover Country farmland and you can see it in the dying-to-almost-dead small towns that now essentially litter the landscape.

Avatar

r po4 months ago

Uh... "My wife's family" ;-) on both sides, until her parents, were western MN farmers. Her parents' generation escaped, became extremely highly educated MDs, PHds, lawyers, you name it. Her grandparents (still farmers) had grown up in the Depression and were quite sane, I got to meet them back in the early '80s. I quite liked her one grandmother, pragmatically Leftist, very small town High School Principal. Her and me, we ganged up on the simple minded narcissists. Parts of her generation hated SS and Guvment healthcare, and she'd tear them a new one.

Fuck me her parent's generation, the aunts and uncles. They are Blue MAGA millionaire rentiers of farmland in the same part of Western MN, "farming" that land, and they can't stand me and likewise, because of all the shit Sarah says.