I’m currently residing in a Lake Michigan resort town that goes from 30,000 people in the summer to 3000 people in the winter. We have a house here and although I have been coming up here summers for the last 25 years, the winter scene is very different. So far I love it. A group of us have been getting together in the community room at the public library where we watch yoga videos and do the workouts together. It’s between 3 and 6 women most days, no one takes it too seriously but it’s fun and I can walk there (my route is pictured above) so I’ve been going just about daily, hence, I haven’t been posting in the AM as much.

Democrats, liberals, Leftists and assorted others had some big public school election wins the other night, so I thought I’d check in with my favorite education-focused Leftist, Jennifer Berkshire.

❝

While the rebuke of conservative school board candidates was the big local election story, the attempted comeback by education reform candidates–pro charter school, anti teachers union, pro accountability–deserves some attention too. Take Denver, for example, where 11 candidates were vying for four seats on the seven-member school board. The contest had a decided throwback air to it, with the same dark money groups that have devoted millions to the cause of ‘portfolioizing’ urban school districts, making another run. But as voters seemed to have noticed, it’s not 2015 anymore, or even 2023. Dark money, particularly the kind linked to billionaires, is a growing turn off for voters, and at a time when the Trump Administration is gunning for public schools, including those in Denver, the sales pitch for education reform is falling flat. As one of the winning candidates explained to Chalkbeat, the election results reflected the ‘state of the world.’ “People don’t have food right now. They’ve seen so much on a global and federal level and they’re worried about their kids. They know they can trust teachers.”

And what will be music to the ears of this blog’s readership, Berkshire goes hard after the centrist punditry:

❝

As for the smart kid chorus that Dems must embrace school choice in order to be competitive at the polls, we got a real-life test of that claim too, as GOP candidates in both Virginia and New Jersey ran as supporters of vouchers. Jack Ciatterelli’s plan to fix New Jersey’s education system included making it more like Mississippi and Florida. In fact, all sorts of claims that we’ve heard repeatedly over the last few years came up short at the polls. Barely had Ezra Klein put the finishing touches on his latest 25K word column for the NYT, pronouncing that Democrats had moved left on education and lost ground with Asian American voters as a result when Asian American voters turned out to be Mamdani’s single largest block of voters.

Moms for Liberty keep losing races but it may not matter - they’re supposedly “evolving” and will now focus exclusively on suing school boards and districts, so we’ll have to squander tens of millions of dollars on lawyers instead of spending it on kids.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

K-12 education is where my activism in generally more focused. Colorado has "school choice" so your kid can go to any school in the district. Now, with the demographics getting older, we are also poaching students from neighboring districts.

The charters that have attempted to come in recently, with one succeeding in Douglas County (again) are weird religious charters where they want to be mean to LGBTQ students and celebrate Christmas. They are also exploiting the language wars saying that they support a good phonics-based education, which can appeal to the parents of dyslexic kids.

However, with the number of kids declining in a lot of places, it doesn't make sense to add charters in an environment where we have to make tough choices about funding cuts.

The other day, I showed mistermix, the TRACER tool that Colorado has to follow candidate donations. I use that to follow school board candidates.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Thanks. Ohio has “open enrollment” for public schools too, which I support.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

One of the two Registered Neighborhood Orgs I'm a board member of here in Denver hosted a school board candidate forum 3 weeks before the election.

The charter school candidates were decidedly mum about their association all the while the neighborhoods were being swamped with glossy mailers we've come to recognize as originating with dark money funneled out-of-state to have things done in order to evade any campaign finance scrutiny here.

Denver, and CO in general, have been the bleeding edge poster children for the conservative and neolib school charter grift, it's really ingrained here and the entitled white transplants who don't leave when they reproduce (most do cuz Gentrification Stops at the School House Door) love them their charter schools mainly because there's a dearth of melanin-clad children attending.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

But, people are fed up with the results, ooops, lack of results from the charter school grift. The anti-charter candidates couldn't come out loud and proud and talk about how charters suck but wove a narrative of supporting actual Denver public schools into their campaign narrative.

It might finally be dawning on those who've come here and can't afford the "school choice" bullshit that surrounds charter schools are finally waking up to the fact that they are publicly funded private schools that are siphoning money away from public schools and produce no better results.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I would be ok with them if they admitted they cherry pick students and they called themselves “magnet” schools or something. Denver is big enough to sustain a magnet school AND have solid public schools. I object to the lying - to pretending they’re equivalent to a Title One public school when they’re not. The whole “school reform movement” is bad faith. They’re liars.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I see this all the time at a tiny level.

A teacher at one of these will get on social media, typically asking for something to be donated (I know for musical gear). They always say something along the lines of:

"I'm a teacher at a DPS high school". If you reply on social media publicly they never answer the question. If you message them, they'll tell you and it's always a charter school.

OTOH, a teacher at a real DPS school always identifies what school they're with.

I've gone down this road repeatedly and when the person asking for something fesses up, I'm not polite in telling them why what I have that they want won't ever go to them because they work for a fucking charter school.

And Denver might be big enough to have solid public schools but neverever has funded them to be solid public schools.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Excellent post Kay! I detest these vexatious twits.

Remember the 2023 Ziegler sex scandal, this county adjoins mine:

The Moms for Liberty chapter in Northumberland County, Pennsylvania separated from the national organization after this news; the chapter chair mentioned being contacted by other Moms for Liberty members for advice on forming independent groups.[72]

I doubt there are pockets deep enough hereabouts for IMO frivolous litigation, but the dark money will prolly flow...

May all teh gawds bless our teachers.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Bridget Ziegler, one of the three founding members, admitted to having had a threesome with her husband and another woman. Allegations of rape and sexual assault were made by the same woman against Ziegler's husband, Christian Ziegler, in late November 2023. Christian had spoken at the organization's summit in Philadelphia that July.[69] Christian was the chairman of the Florida Republican party, though he was suspended by its board on December 17, 2023, which held an emergency meeting regarding the charges. His resignation was demanded at that meeting.[70]

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Newsy! I love gossip about Rightwingers. 🙂

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

They also had (have) a Nazi problem!

"The MfL newsletter, which is called “The Parent Brigade,” was originally posted on Wednesday afternoon. It featured a quote that Hitler used in a 1935 speech with capitalization for emphasis: “He alone, who OWNS the youth, GAINS the future.” The newsletter was updated with Miller’s apology on Thursday morning after condemnation from local leaders and reporting from the IndyStar newspaper.

The Hitler quote in the newsletter appeared on its front page directly above the statement Moms For Liberty’s co-founders, Tiffany Justice and Tina Descovich, issued in response to the SPLC’s report. In that statement, Justice and Descovich described the “extremist group” designation as “name calling.”

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

"In fact, this was not even the first time Moms for Liberty has been linked to this Hitler quote. In 2021, Moms for Liberty member Debra Cannon, who is a school board member in Central Bucks School District in Pennsylvania, posted a comment on Facebook featuring the same quote, alongside a second quote from the Nazi leader."

https://www.vice.com/en/article/moms-for-liberty-hitler-quote/

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Also neoNazis!

"The group also has close links to other extremist groups, notably the Proud Boys."

https://www.vice.com/en/article/moms-for-liberty-proud-boys/

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Had two interesting discussions with a former and current school board member in the small town where I grew up. One's a Democrat, one's a low-key Republican (not MAGA). Both were concerned about teacher's salaries being too low, teachers not being able to afford housing because there are so few rental properties, etc. The Republican also said he thought the "home schooling" trend that was hitting our area a bit was terrible--"Mom gave me an A!" was an example he used. All of the STEM classes are taught via video feed because no STEM-qualified teacher will accept the low salaries.

The Moms for Liberty shit didn't come up in either of these conversations. Even in the blood red town where I grew up, they know they have far bigger problems than a couple of books in the library. A few years ago, some nutter MAGA type moved to town and made noises at the school board meetings. She ran for school board and got crushed.

Still, the education system has crumbled since I learned there.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

My Ohio local district was Right wing but not nuts until about 2010, when it went far Right. Prior to that happening they were willing to appoint me, an actual liberal, to the committee for a new school. They’d never do that now. I really date this not to Trump but instead to the Tea Party. It all went to shit not in 2016 but instead in 2010.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Agree on the Tea Party. Trump is the outcome of the Tea Party "insurgency" -- basically the empowering of the worst of us because media was enamored with their norm busting. They were a tiny group but like the poop ball of a dung beetle, they kept growing.

The Democrat who was on the school board is a respected member of the community and he quit because he had too much on his plate and also he's getting older. I'd bet he'd be re-elected if he ran. Part of that is he's a known quantity having lived in the community for going on 80 years. Part of it is the residual respect for learning and education that the older, non-MAGA but Republican residents have in the town.