Been out all day at MD appointments (all good) so just a quick note:

I’m sure all of you are familiar with Marc Elias (@marcelias.bsky.social) and his team at Democracy Docket. Marc and gang are one of the few real firewalls between Trumpian authoritarianism and what remains of our representative democracy.

I noticed two key items in his newsletter today:

  1. Judge ‘doubts the lawfulness’ of Trump’s voter purge database, but won’t block it. So, DHS is trying to get voter database information form the states (especially blue states) to stitch together with other information for “immigration” purposes - but clearly also other unknow nefarious purposes. The judge doubts the legality of this, but doesn’t yet see “irreparable harm”, so no restraining order. IANAL (or a judge), but it seems to me that once this info is handed over to the government’s it can’t really be un-handed over. Plus, states run elections unless congress says otherwise. What am I missing??

  2. Trump officials seek custody of convicted election denier Tina Peters. The Trump Admin wants “custody” of Tina Peters, the former election clerk in Colorado convicted on state charges for a voter information data breach during the 202 election.

One more thing.

There is a concept in law called the “presumption of regularity” which basically says that Courts start out assuming that government officials and agencies did their jobs correctly and followed the law - unless someone brings solid evidence showing otherwise.

My takeaway from these two seemingly unrelated issues? While many judges have been doing yeoman’s work in upholding the law, judges will not save us. The system is not set up for litigants acting in bad faith and flooding the system. The system is not set up for a government that breaches the presumption of regularity willingly and regularly. The system is not set up for a government that ignores judicial decisions and that willingly breaks the law.

It’s on us as protestors and voters to effect the change we need.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

C P1 year ago

As long as the Supreme Court sits above all the lower courts, every good decision is basically hanging under a sword of Damocles, and that's not counting the extent to which the Trump administration is happy to just violate the law openly and ignore the courts' ability to do something about it. So yeah, I wouldn't count on the courts, least of all because the supreme one is now, arguably, an even bigger problem than Trump.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

The Scheme was a series of speeches about Leonard Leo's network of treachery

https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a45225442/sheldon-whitehouse-federal-courts-scheme/

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

The number of times Courts have decided in favor of the donors is astounding.

https://www.whitehouse.senate.gov/news/speeches/whitehouse-remarks-on-the-federalist-society-and-leonard-leo/

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

It’s statistically impossible.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

"Now, Leo, 56, is positioned to finance his already sprawling network with one of the largest pools of political capital in American history. Seid has left his legacy to Leo.

“To my knowledge, it is entirely without precedent for a political operative to be given control of such an astonishing amount of money,” said Brendan Fischer, a campaign finance lawyer at the nonpartisan watchdog group Documented. “Leonard Leo is already incredibly powerful, and now he is going to have over a billion dollars at his disposal to continue upending our country’s institutions.”

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

The Supreme Court is the big problem. Lower courts make reasonable rulings but the corrupt Supreme Court reverses them to achieve political goals.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

And they say it was a temporary thing on the shadow docket so it doesn't really count, but it erodes trust.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

My point Sepideh - the shadow docket may ot include final rulings (although sometimes it does), but it delays decisions while allowing the bad stuff to continue happening - that's the whole point.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Also this fucking guy and his ilk

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_Kacsmaryk

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Okay, doomer.

The courts have been having a great time today!

ICE detainees in Chicago are going to go free. https://www.techdirt.com/2025/11/17/federal-judges-frees-more-than-300-chicago-area-detainees-because-ice-violated-a-2018-consent-decree/

A judge told told the Comey prosecutors that they need to get their mess in order. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/justice-department/judge-says-missteps-james-comey-case-result-charges-dismissed-rcna244405

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Boomer the Doomer - that's me 😉

I did say the courts are doing yeoman's work. It's just the system is not agile, adaptive and quick enough to stop the onslaught. I hope I'm wrong - I will eat crow (how many times have I said THAT?!). I am concerned it's like putting one's finger in the dike and seeing a leak pop up somewhere else - times 1,000,000

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Mmm. I admit, the spiteful part of me wouldn't mind so much if Comey got what he deserved good and hard.

For the same reason that, despite the Night of the Long Knives, none of the variations of the "first they came for..." includes a line that says "then they came for the Brownshirts."

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Comey is THE proximate reason Clinton lost. Lots of other factors, but if you look at polling shifts in the last 10 days, it was Comey's "I'm the most righteous person in the room: view and actions that gave us this dipshit.

Nonetheless, political retribution trials are... really, really bad

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Oh yeah. The announcement was made with surgical precision to inflict exactly the maximum amount of damage to the Clinton campaign. Any earlier, and people's attention might have moved on to something else, or they might've started realizing there was no "there" there. Any later, and it might be too last minute to make a difference. He knew exactly what he was doing.

The hell of it is that Comey had the perfect "non partisan" way out; he could have announced that Clinton and Trump were both under investigation, thus the "influence" on the campaign zeroes out, or he could have not announced that either was under investigation until after the election. The fact that he could so incredibly brazenly do what he did and be pretty sure he'd face no consequences is an amazing commentary on both his intentions and the political environment he operates in.