Ok people. Let’s talk about “common culture”, Christian Nationalism and the link between the two.

If you haven’t seen/read it yet, our benevolent-tech bro-overlord-in-his-mind-only Elon Musk has some ideas.

Here is a screenshot from X (won’t link to that site):

And if that’s not enough, well, how about this?

It goes without saying that the Afrikaner apartheid “superior race” force is strong with this one.

First, I’ll let historian Kevin M. Kruse dispense with Musk’s view that no one fights for multiculturism at this link: Diversity Is Our Strength.

Second, the Americas encompasses North, Central and South America, so the Musketeer needs to broaden his scope and try to find “English-Scotts-Irish origin” in El Salvador and Paraguay.

But let’s set the pedantry aside. In all seriousness, I would argue that, if you want to search for a common American culture, its foundation is in the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution. Imperfect as the men writing these docs were - and they were time-period culturally appropriate in their racism, sexism and “wealthism” (belief that male landed gentry were the people to run the country), they provided foundational cultural touchstones": “All Men are Created Equal” and “Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness” from the Declaration, and “establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty…” from the Constitution.

Over the years, the United States became known as a virtual “Melting pot”, willing to take on all comers. For those who don’t remember the words on the Statue of Liberty, gifted from France in 1884, they read, "Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!". Pretty clear cultural tone setter, no?

As our country’s “culture” has changed with the times, IMHO, there has been one constant that, to me, is/was the definition of a common American culture (although, just not the one Musk and Christian Nationalists are promoting): the opportunity and freedom in our country to be who you want and build/live the life you want, regardless of one’s origin. Sadly, for Musk, several members of the “Pay Pal Mafia”, and the religious extremists, that culture is blind to race, color, gender and religion.

Enough for now on “common culture”. On to the perversion of religion that goes by the moniker of Christian Nationalism. So, what is Christian Nationalism? This definition is a good start:

“U.S. Christian nationalism is a fusion of American and Christian identity, principles and symbols that typically seeks a privileged place for Christian people and ideas…

American Christian nationalism involves overlapping movements. Among them are evangelicals who view Trump, a Republican, as a champion, some of whom are influenced by Christian Reconstructionist ideas; a charismatic movement that sees politics as part of a larger spiritual war; and a Catholic postliberal movement envisioning a muscular government promoting traditional morality.”

Christian Nationalism, as Stephen Colbert pointed out, is a purely political movement. One that promotes political right-wing ideology from the pulpit and instructs its followers to vote for a specific party and specific candidates (against the rules, of course). I simply refer to it as “pseudo-religious extremism” because it certainly does not follow Biblical Christian precepts

As US Senate candidate in Texas James Talarico - who is a Presbyterian Seminarian studying to be a pastor - said in his interview with Stephen Colbert (link: Rep. James Talarico On Confronting Christian Nationalism, And Strange Days In The Texas Legislature),

“The [Christian Nationalist] political right … convinced a lot of our fellow Christians that the most important issues were abortion and gay marriage, two issues that aren’t mentioned in the Bible. Two issues that Jesus never talked about. Jesus, in Matthew 25, tells us exactly… how we’re going to be judged and how we’re going to be saved. By feeding the hungry, by healing the sick, by welcoming the stranger. Nothing about going to church, nothing about voting Republican; it was all about how you treat other people. I’ve said before, ‘don’t tell me what you believe; tell me how you treat other people and I’ll tell you what you believe’…

Love thy neighbor regardless of race, or gender, or sexual orientation, or immigrations status, or religious affiliation. And it’s why I have fought so hard for separation of church and state in the State Capitol in Texas…

We are called to love all of our neighbors, including our Muslim, Jewish, Buddhist, Hindu, Sikh, agnostic, atheist neighbors. And forcing our religion down their throats is not love.”

Well said James. And a pretty strong retort to the gun-toting, lib-hating, immigrant bashing, revenge-seeking, prosperity-gospel-touting, race-baiting, my-way-or-the highway “religious beliefs” of Christian Nationalists. These are not really religious beliefs - they are political/policy views wrapped inside of a warped interpretation of their supposed Christian religion.

Now, what do these two views - desiring a common “European” culture, and a desire to be governed by a pseudo-Christian-religious regime and laws - have in common?

They are both fundamentally incompatible with democracy, and the “consent of the governed” mentioned in the Declaration.

The word God, while mentioned in the Declaration, is not found anywhere in the United States Constitution. In my view, this is because theocratic government by religious fiat and the “heavenly laws” (as decided and interpreted by very real earthly people) of an infallible God - by definition - leaves absolutely zero room for democratic decision making by the “consent of the governed”. If God’s law is THE law, then no other conflicting law can be valid, and decisions by the majority of the governed don’t matter if they are deemed to conflict with God’s law by whoever is determining what God’s law means.

Likewise, Musk’s “common culture” composed of a northern European ruling class following northern European values (whatever they may be) leaves no room for the values, input, views, beliefs, policy proposals and input of any “others” in determining the norms, rules and laws by which we are governed. By “others”, of course, I mean non-white peoples. This intersects with Christian Nationalism, because any people who have religious or cultural customs deemed “non-northern-European” by the self-appointed arbiters of that class are, by definition, “others” as well.

Both of these views of how society should be run in the United States of America - Musk’s “common culture” and Christian Nationalism - are antithetical to what this country is all about, from its founding on down through to today. They must be resisted at all costs.

PS - ironically, I found this in my email inbox this morning after I finished writing the post above: Undaunted in Denouncing Religious Hypocrites

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 9 months ago

Lemme add that Musk is clearly misunderstanding “Scots-Irish,” an ethnic identity ya don’t have in South Africa. They’re people from the borderlands between England and Scotland, renowned for their pugnacity, who England used as Protestant colonists in Ireland. Lots of them moved to Appalachia; some of them are my illiterate ancestors.

Fucking paragons of civilization they are not. Fucking dumbass billionaire.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur9 months ago

Excellent post, M.M. I'll be ruminating on this all day (I got distracted by the Supremacists Court tariffs decision).

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur9 months ago

Oops, should say J.W.!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur9 months ago

Being half WASP and half Jew, I wish I had the documentation from biological dad's side of the family like I do for my white ancestors (boxes full of handwritten letters going back to before our founding, documents from Massachusetts Bay Colony, deeds for property in Assonet village that mention King George, etc. My ancestors saved every scrap, the documents are fucking amazing and I could tell stories about them all day long).

Unfortunately, there was almost no evidence left by my Jewish ancestors 😞

https://www.jtsa.edu/torah/the-book-smugglers-of-the-vilna-ghetto/

Mom said, regarding the question of religion, we'd make up our own minds when old enough.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur9 months ago

I fucking abhor what the alt right has done via their God Emporer and will froth at the mouth if I say more.

Avatar

C P9 months ago

And as far as my cultural heritage, specifically, goes? As far as I'm concerned, the degree to which the religious right blends "America" and "Christianity" has always been as much a blasphemy against the Christian God as it is a debasing of the American Constitution. There's a word for the way these people elevate America (and not America, the 350 million people in real life, but America, the mystical mythological sacred being that exists in their head): "idolatry." America is their golden calf.

Avatar

C P9 months ago

More seriously, the thing you can't help but notice after you've seen enough nationalists is that the "culture" they believe in is always exactly the same.

Keep your women in the kitchen. Keep your children cowed and obedient. Keep your LGBTs in the closet, or put them in the ground. Keep your ethnic and cultural minorities firmly underfoot, unless you're just going to kill or expel them which is also OK. Don't trust anybody who thinks and writes too much, they're all degenerate traitors. Don't trust cities, which are dens of iniquity. Obey the Boss. And above all, worship the Men With Guns, who are the true lifeblood of our society.

Musk's vision of American or Western culture is the same as a Taliban mullah's vision of Islamic culture, which is the same as an LRA warlord's vision of Acholi culture, and so forth. All these people want is to purge their cultures of anything distinctive and whittle them all down to identical disasters, Oceania = Eurasia = Eastasia style.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic9 months ago

I can feel your emotion on this C P. And you are spot on. I'm constantly confused as to why Dems don't make this point ore often: everyone has the right to believe in their religion, but theocracy (governing by God's law) is fundamentally incompatible with democracy (consent of the governed).

Avatar

Scott H9 months ago

Godless, secular humanist here who, over time, has come to appreciate religion on other people's lives as being important to them as individuals.

But yeah, all this God's Law and Christian Nationalism crap and the Dems refusal to stand up and say not just no but fuck no, is maddening.

The Founders, imperfect as they were, would be horrified at the role religion plays in our society even as more and more people become godless, secular humanists like me. :)

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 9 months ago

Hell yes.

Avatar

C P9 months ago

"American culture, with its English-Scotts-Irish roots, is great and worth fighting for. Some may not realize it, but that's why people come here."

Well, of course it is! That's why all those immigrants moved to England, Scotland, and Ireland, so they could experience the same culture in an even more purely distilled form, and not to the United States, which even at the very beginning was so full of Germans that its founders didn't think they could get away with instituting an official language!

Avatar

Kay W.9 months ago

Well done 🙂

Avatar

Scott H9 months ago

My family roots go back to at least 1650.

Which means it also consists of branches resulting from the massive German emigration waves of both the 18th and 19th centuries.

People don't realize German was the second-most spoke language in the colonies when they declared independence. In fact, it was a German-language newspaper broke the news of the signing and had copies of it, in German, out the next day.

Avatar

Sepideh M9 months ago

In high school, my history teacher told us that America was not so much a melting pot but an all you can eat buffet. There will be places where things are mixed together well, and then there are things that are just different.