Some observations on where Dems are today, but first, a couple stories from my time on the campaign trail.

Story 1. I was knocking on doors while running for US House in a rural town in my rural state. At one house, a young man answered the door, and after I introduced myself, asked why I was running and what I cared about. I told him our current Rep had been in DC too long and lost touch with people back home, and then - having seen a big wheel in the yard and guessing he had kids - I told him that affordable healthcare for everyone was one of my biggest issues. I obviously touched a nerve. He launched into a long diatribe about how one of his kids had a major illness and the cost was literally bankrupting his family; in fact, he and his wife were about to sell their house to pay their medical bills. After some back and forth, I again reiterated my support for universal access to affordable healthcare. His final response? “I just hope you’re not one of them - I hate socialized medicine”. Ias ked him what he meant by socialized medicine, and he really couldn’t coherently answer.

Story 2. Again with the door knocking in a subsequent campaign for US Senate. The contentious Kavanaugh SCOTUS nomination hearings were taking place. At one house, a middle-aged working-class guy answered the door. We talked for a bit, when suddenly he dropped the bomb on me: “Joe (not my real name), you seem like a nice guy and I remember you from your last campaign. I don’t really like Senator Blowhard (name changed to protect the guilty) but after what I’ve seen on TV with the Kavanaugh thing, I can never vote for a Democrat.” He was not the only person to express that point of view that day and in subsequent days on the campaign trail.

The common thread I took away from those - and other - interactions with voters was that it didn’t matter if we agreed on issues or if voters didn’t like their current electeds. What mattered was whether or not I was able to somehow break into their “Circle of TrustTM”). If I could not find a way to show we had common values, to break into the Circle of TrustTM, nothing I said about a specific issue mattered - they didn’t really hear me.

My second takeaway is something I’ve mentioned in a previous post. too many Dems in DC are playing inside baseball. as Jennifer Rubin wrote this morning in her Substack called The Contrarian:

“Arrogance: Too many political insiders foolishly insist that all voters listen to politicians 24/7 (hence, they mistakenly assume a level of familiarity with political minutiae). Political elites convince themselves that talking points have saliency beyond hyper-political Americans, that ordinary Americans do not care about immigrants snatched off the streets (leading to anything less than full-throated criticism of ICE), that the most important leadership must emanate from Washington, D.C., and that “democracy under attack” is self-explanatory and motivating for average people.

The antidote to arrogance involves listening to voters, speaking plainly, personalizing the results of Trump’s cruel and misguided actions (How many more dollars will tariffs cost you? What happens if Trump can indict or knock off the air any opponent?), and appealing to Americans’ common sense and innate sense of decency (e.g., it’s cruel and stupid to round up and deport grandmothers). Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker is expert at this.”

This “arrogance” is based on Inside Baseball - the wrongheaded assumption that most Americans actually pay attention to politics. The reverse is true - my unscientific door-to-door experience (with a very large population covered from three campaigns) tells me that something on the order of 90% or more of voters have no f^*king clue about politics and complex issues.

This is where national - and many state - elected Dems are today. Due to inside baseball, triangulation, living inside the political bubble, kowtowing to large donors, Dems find themselves outside the Circle of TrustTM, bombarding voters with complex policy prescriptions (which mostly are good) but not being truly heard or trusted.

Dems need to find a way to reenter the Circle of TrustTM on a mass appeal basis. It starts with education, but this must be combines with taking bold, simple to understand stances that show Dems a) understand most people are unhappy with their current life circumstances, b) recognize that most people view the entire “system” as a failure (on both sides), c) accept that the system can do better and the status quo is not acceptable, and d) most importantly, realize they must find a way to connect with voters on a viscera, values-based Circle of TrustTM level.

Not an easy task.

Let’s start with new leadership in both the Senate and the House

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

One of the non-shitty commenters at That Other Blog™ distilled all of this down as follows:

But to win we have to offer — and mean — a better vision.

Everybody gets seemingly hung up on unreachables and loses sight of the fact Dems have been shedding votes they have no business shedding, precisely because such voters are seeing that Dems don't really mean a helluva lot of what they say.

Avatar

green goblin1 year ago

I'm curious as to just what it was about the Kavanaugh thing that got the man so upset in your second story. If it was because a woman was trying to tell her story and hold a man to account for his actions then I don't want to get in his circle of trust.

Avatar

James Powell1 year ago

A shocking number of my male acquaintances expressed rage at a woman telling her story. It was like she was totally out of line to speak out. I was very surprised not just at their reaction, but at the intensity.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Remember, most pf the people who's doors I knocked o watch Fox News - or worse. They were told it was a hit job, and if it happened, it was when Kavanaugh was just a young lad. Ia agree with you - but its still demoralizing when one can't even find a way into the Circle of Trust because people have been lied to and brainwashed...

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I can't help seeing DeNiro in the Fockers movies every time I read Circle of Trust™

Avatar
Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Right?

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

J.B. Pritzker should enforce the state Constitution of Illinois immediately.

"Both the fourth amendment of the United States Constitution and article I, section 6, of the Illinois Constitution of 1970 protect individuals from unreasonable searches and seizures. U.S. Const., amend. IV; Ill. Const. 1970, art. I, § 6.

The fundamental purpose of these provisions is to safeguard the privacy and security of individuals from invasions by governmental officials. People v. Dilworth, 169 Ill. 2d 195, 201 (1996)."

By all means necessary.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

An impressive Message from the Director of the Illinois State Police, which agency answers to the Governor. Not merely words on paper?

https://isp.illinois.gov/Home/DirectorMessage

Avatar

James Powell1 year ago

Jennifer Rubin had me right up to the point she said "Americans' common sense and innate sense of decency." I've done a lot of door to door, standing at community events at a table or with a clipboard, phone calls, etc. What I've heard is neither common sense or decency. Anger, bigotry, and a total lack of understanding how the government works. People have told me that they hate Democrats for reasons that have nothing to do with actual Democrats. People have told me that they support Republicans for reasons that the Republicans have consistently and unambiguously opposed. You insist on sticking to facts? Forget you, you're arrogant!

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

That’s exactly right. Ignorance is our biggest enemy. As I repeat ad nauseum, Thomas Jefferson said, “The best defense of democracy is an informed electorate.” After three fed campaigns in a deep red state, it’s pretty clear to me we are soooo far from that right now.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

The decades long assault on public education has ended in victory.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Who woulda thunk slowly strangling public education and turning journalism into horse race porn has consequences?

Avatar

TXG1112 1 year ago

Most Democrats hate the Democratic Party too. I am coming to the conclusion that the party as an institution will need to be torn down so a new narrative can be woven.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

It's really hard to beat the Fox News inculcated mentality of "anybody but a Democrat" which is a very real thing out here in red states.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

It’s amazing. The Democratic brand is in the shitter in large part due to a sustained campaign waged against them for decades. But the Republican brand which should be so toxic that nobody wants to go near it is doing just fine.

It certainly confirms Joe’s point that 90% of the public have no idea what is going on. It’s all about the vibes, man.

Avatar

TXG1112 1 year ago

Fox news has been very effective all these years mostly because the Democratic Party hasn’t had a good durable brand that would resist being distorted for all the reasons that were mentioned in the original post. Triangulation and the constant drumbeat from “moderates” to move right on social issues means that the Democratic party’s brand gets to be set by Fox News, not actual Democrats.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

No lies told.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Which manifests itself in candidates we run. In a D+29 district, we'll run a proverbial D+1 kinda candidate because D+29 candidates like AOC/Crockett aren't what's wanted by the party "centrists".

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Not trying to flog the podcast but Genevieve Gunther pointed out that this is also the case with climate change. Democrats / realist voices are drowned out by fossil fuel propaganda because we can't coalesce on a message and have no message discipline. The message discipline part is hard, because Dems/liberals generally aren't interested in it -- they'd rather let many flowers bloom.

Avatar

TXG1112 1 year ago

This gets back to the problem that the Democratic Party supports and promotes crappy politicians. Not just in their politics, but their ability to communicate. It kills me when I hear that polls are against this or that. The whole idea of politics is persuading people to support your ideas. Polls can be changed and it’s up to leaders to lead people.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

But the Democrats have been complicit in this, not running in rural states, surrendering to the narrative because they can't win the next cycle, etc.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Fox is poison and a big reason for where we are today - maybe the biggest. But feckless Dem leadership lacking any intestinal fortitude doesn’t help.