Wanted to talk about Trump tariffs in the context of auto industry workers and specifically the UAW. My fear is liberals (including me) kid ourselves about how unpopular this stuff is, particularly regarding hourly workers in labor unions. Labor is not as important to Democrats as it once was but private sector unions in the Great Lakes states are still very important. We held onto a good share of labor households in 2024, especially considering how many “labor households” are law enforcement, so any labor household measure is skewed Right by GOP police and corrections officers unions. Part of the reason we are still carrying a majority of UAW rank and file is there are a lot of Black UAW members – 25%.

You all recall how how hard Sean Fain of the UAW worked for Harris, right? Here’s him yesterday:

❝

"Tariffs are a powerful tool in the toolbox for undoing the injustice of anti-worker trade deals," the union said. "We are glad to see an American president take aggressive action on ending the free trade disaster that has dropped like a bomb on the working class."

 My middle son is an IBEW electrician who just went on to a “company job” at Stellantis in Detroit, so although he will still be in the IBEW he will now be working under a UAW contract. He told me UAW rank and file think the Trump tariff threats are a negotiating tactic meant to mitigate some of the losses from trade deals (including the Trump trade deal).

We talked about how nuts this is to me because Stellantis is international, as are all car companies. They all source from all over the world and they all assemble in Mexico and Canada. When he applied for the job at Stellantis he was interviewed by an executive from Fiat who had an Italian accent. So they’re AWARE of the wholly international nature of the industry they’re in. Still, he tells me his coworkers  all support the threats of tariffs and believe it is a tough negotiating tactic. My son, incidentally, is a Democrat who loathes Trump. He even canvassed for Marcy Kaptur with me in 2024. But this is what they’re saying where he works.

I just think it’s really important we not get too far up our own asses and keep talking to people. This plays differently for different groups of people. I know how hard it is to keep all of the wildly disparate parts of our coalition together and how interests can clash but I think the only way to understand what’s going on is to stop talking in broad strokes with assumptions about which groups support what and instead really drill down and embrace the complexity of this coalition. It’s complicated.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Shawn Fain from a week or two ago:

“Trump is president because we have candidates in this party who can’t decide who the fuck they want to represent.”

I just got back from a documentary film festival. A premier film was WTO '99: https://moveablefest.com/ian-bell-wto-99/

I hope it gets picked up so people here can see it. Most will remember but most don't and it's a very prescient event to what's happening today. Money quote from the review:

“WTO ‘99” becomes undeniable in how it illuminates the prescience of what was once dismissed in the mainstream as a radical fringe and the perils of disengaging from political discourse.

Another review: https://www.rogerebert.com/festivals/true-false-2025-wto-99-family-album-land-with-no-rider “WTO/99” is nothing short of a galvanizing historical document that tells us exactly how we arrived on the crumbling ground we’re presently standing on.

Avatar

Grover Gardner1 year ago

Well, it appears now that he's paused them again. He's such a putz.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

I think he is engaged in massive market manipulation.

Avatar

Grover Gardner1 year ago

You're probably right. :-(

Avatar

Betty Cracker1 year ago

Thanks for sharing that perspective, which is not something I'm exposed to regularly since I live in an anti-union state. You're right to describe our coalition as "wildly disparate." I read a quote somewhere recently that said the U.S. is "too big to know itself." It's true.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Thanks - I’m trying to listen more to my sons because they said young men were veering Right and I scoffed. They were right. I think we need new ideas

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

My sons said the same thing and I underestimated the extent of the shift.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

My Promaster van is a Stellantis product. It's a Fiat Ducato from about the driver's seat back, with Fiat embossed in some of the insulation foam. From the driver's seat forward, it is full of domestic Mopar (Chrysler) parts. The engine is the Chrysler Pentastar engine that I believe is made in Michigan. The dash, gauges, electronics and climate control are a mix of Mopar and Fiat. Like all Promasters, it was assembled in Saltillo, Mexico. Just figuring out the tariffs for this thing would make anyone's head spin.

Avatar

Dennis Doubleday1 year ago

Ross Perot was right, back in the 90s, with "NAFTA, We Don't Hafta" that it would be bad for American workers.

That said, now that plants have migrated to Canada and Mexico, they can't be brought back immediately. You'd have to convince automakers that tariffs were going to be in place for years before they'd make a move to repatriate production. And Trump doesn't even have credibility that tariffs will be in place to the end of the week. And it's ignoring that the market is international and production brought back to the USA will be subject to retaliatory tariffs in foreign markets.

So, if they do last 6 months even, it is likely to result in job losses where your son works, since fewer people will buy Stellantis cars at the tariff-plus price.