I went to “senior stretch” at the Methodist church this morning so I’m now officially a retiree. My friend Kyle winked at me when I sat down, like it’s a secret club.

Attended an organizing event for El-Sayed on debate night, which meant I missed the debate between El Sayed and Stevens, but I watched on You Tube later.

First, some bio on each candidate. Stevens is 43, divorced and currently in the US House. She flipped a red seat blue in 2018. El-Sayed is 41, married, with two daughters. He’s an MD – an epidemiologist - and was health director for the City of Detroit and then Wayne County health director.

DC endorsements are as follows – Stevens has Schumer, Stabenow, Cortez Mastro, Gallego, Coons, Pelosi and Lauren Underwood. El- Sayed has Sanders, AOC, Van Hollen, Rho Khanna, Rashida Talb, Pramila Jayapal, Summer Lee, Delia Ramirez, Anilia Mejia, Maxwell Frost and Chris Raab.

There are clear differences between these two candidates. El-Sayed supports Medicare for All. Stevens wants to “fix” Obamacare, add a public option and allow Medicare buy-in for 55- to 65-year-olds. El-Sayed believes ICE is fundamentally broken, a rogue Right wing federal police force that sucks up huge resources and provides very little value to the public. Stevens wants more oversight of ICE. El - Sayed wants to halt military aid to Israel (and Egypt, interesting because he is Egyptian) and Stevens wants to maintain current US policy re: Israel.

The debate was probably a draw. Stevens was quite strong, but so was El-Sayed. The debate questions from the moderators were surprisingly good – cost of living, health care, immigration, and data centers. Both candidates followed the debate rules on both time and talking in turn, which I appreciated. Both candidates seemed smart and well prepared. Sadly, the “questions from the public” portion was terrible, as it almost always is, it’s 90% “statement disguised as question” bullshit.

Stevens has an oddly immature presentation – almost girlish- which I think is a problem  but I wouldn’t know how to fix it without turning her into phony Margaret Thatcher. That’s always a problem for women to a greater or lesser extent – our voices and visual presentation are perceived as less authoritative than men’s voices – so I won’t hold it against her but if my experience as a lawyer is any guide, others will.

Worse than the presentation to me was a hesitancy to embrace her own moderate positions. She dodged the ICE question with “more oversight”, she dodged the military aid to Israel question with a single throwaway line about “humanitarian aid to Gaza” – I always love that crazy answer, btw. So the plan is to retain the blank check US funding for Israeli bombs and bulldozers but provide prosthetic limbs to the 4000 child amputees Israel and the US have created? It’s appalling and WTF does it even mean?

I see this hesitancy of moderates to support their own moderate positions as a chronic problem. I get that she’s running in a primary and the Democratic base will be voting, not the swingy middle or Right, but it’s disingenuous for moderates to insist they’re progressives when they’re just not. I also think it leads moderates to attack people further Left than them not on policy, but by using accusations on character – the challenger from the Left isn’t wrong on Medicare for all, he’s an antisemite, or racist, or a misogynist. In Stevens’ case, she’s not actually launching these smears against El- Sayed, but the various PACS who are supporting her are, so she can claim (as she did in the debate) to be running a positive campaign while distancing herself from the lobbyist attack dogs who are supporting her. Again, disingenuous. Just be an out and proud moderate and attack him on abolishing ICE or Medicare for All. Then you won’t need 5 PACs.

I realized about midway thru the debate that Stevens sounds exactly like any moderate Democrat in 2006, focused not on pushing for liberal ideas or values but instead on reducing the harm from Republican policy. I don’t think the harm reduction approach has worked for us, and worse, to me it means we aren’t confident and solid in our own liberal ideology. I think people pick that up and it reads as weakness, and it should. It IS weak. A Party that sees itself as existing to buffer GOP policy and preferences so fewer people get hurt is not a Party anyone will want to join.

Right now my sense is it’s a toss-up. Stevens is a strong candidate who has all the establishment support and much, much more money than El- Sayed. Stevens also has the disadvantage of being a woman in the most sexist country in the non-Muslim West and the disadvantage of supporting the status quo on Israel and Iran. El- Sayed has in laws who are well off and donating to him, he has the hugely popular AOC backing him, and he has positions that are quite popular with the base – ending military aid to Israel, getting out of Iran and Medicare for all. El -Sayed has the disadvantage of being a brown Muslim in the very Islamophobic US and supporting policy positions that are opposed by all US monied interests. I love a good fight,, so I’m all in on this one, win or lose. I’m volunteering for the campaign, and I have a lot more to add. I’ll keep you updated going forward.  

 

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

r po4 months ago

Really good post, thank you for putting boots on the ground and reporting back.

I can't tell from your report, did El- Sayed explicitly campaign/argue against Schumer, Pelosi, and their entrenched DLCC crowd? Because the "hesitancy of moderates to support their own moderate positions" seems like a tell, and a big opportunity in a primary race. IMHO, a person who knows nothing.

Avatar

r po4 months ago

Christ I'm sitting here muttering so I'll just spit it out. Why the fuck does Pelosi, of all people, after the last decade, where her "leadership" has led in fundamentally material ways to the disaster we currently find ourselves in, have any right to weigh in at all? What defines failure in this country? What could she have done worse? She apparently was masterful at running the House in "normal" times, awesome, but that's been a long time now. Of course I'm using her as a proxy for all the rest of Schumerite fail-blob.

This is what I mean by an opportunity. These people who capitulated, and they literally did in the days after Jan 6th, should be the people who get tarred and feathered in a Michigan primary.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic4 months ago

Great post Kay! Love the insight…

Especially the part about moderates not being willing to defend their issues or values. I think it’s been one of the biggest problems in the Democratic Party for ages. Just freaking stand up for what you believe in and people will get that.

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

Stevens is a strong candidate, jfc, no. She's running to the right of Slotkin and we need another one of her ilk in the Senate like we need a hole in our head.

Anybody who's been as critical of Israel as you have can't possibly be a supporter of Stevens who "dreams of Israel" and would continue the Dem Party's obeisance to Bibi.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Haley Stevens has been one the worst money beggars in my inbox, for months and months. Multiple daily emails. I know who I'd choose and it's not her wishy washy ass. I just asked my cousin in Michigan who she's going to choose, but no answer yet.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

El - Sayed wants to halt military aid to Israel (and Egypt, interesting because he is Egyptian) and Stevens wants to maintain current US policy re: Israel.

Fuck current policy.

Way I see it: there are allies with which we share values (though admittedly with Trump warping the U.S. government beyond recognition, it's less and less clear if that applies), and there are allies that are purely about convenience. Our closest allies in Europe and the Pacific (NATO in the first case, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and the Anzacs in the second case) are the former. All of our close allies in the Middle East are the latter. Israel's an apartheid state, Egypt's a military dictatorship, Jordan's a monarchy, and Saudi Arabia is a monarchy, a theocracy, and the modern version of an 1850s slave state all rolled into one. And in Israel's case, the ratio of "how much good do they do us" versus "how much trouble do they cause us" has long since hit the point where we should've cut them loose.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

I'm not surprised incidentally that a man with recent Egyptian heritage wouldn't be a fan of the Egyptian regime we're supplying. Like I said, it's a military dictatorship. And its ties to the United States have often been ignominious whether you're looking at it as an American or as an Egyptian. For decades it's been a regime that we used the same way we used Argentina or Chile during the Cold War - somebody who does the things for us that are so dirty we don't want even the most classified of paper trails about them in our system.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

El-Sayed believes ICE is fundamentally broken, a rogue Right wing federal police force that sucks up huge resources and provides very little value to the public. Stevens wants more oversight of ICE.

Yeah, Stevens is just wrong about this. I want far more overhaul and cutting in the security state than I'll probably ever see in my lifetime, but ICE specifically is the worst of the worst, whether in terms of competence, willingness to follow the law, or sheer amount of wanton cruelty in the way they choose to do their job. It's America's SS, and the way Trump has supercharged it to the level of third-best-funded security organization in the world, it's pretty clear that he, at least, thinks of it in literally those terms. It has to go, full stop.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

✊

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

Stevens was one of the 75 House Dems who betrayed basic Dem values and voted earlier this year to "express gratitude" to ICE: https://jonathancohn.medium.com/a-tale-of-two-resolutions-75-dems-join-gop-in-resolution-praising-trumps-mass-deportation-regime-15cf590770ea

Also too, AIPAC's soooooper PAC has pitched in $10m to her campaign.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Amazing how much the AIPAC stand and the ICE stand overlap, isn't it?

Avatar

C P4 months ago

*stans

Avatar

C P4 months ago

El-Sayed supports Medicare for All. Stevens wants to “fix” Obamacare, add a public option and allow Medicare buy-in for 55- to 65-year-olds.

Honestly this wouldn't be so bad: the lack of a public option was exactly what made the ACA such a shit-show. As health insurance nerds point out often, most countries with universal health care don't use single-payer. And as much as I distrust American health insurance companies, having a public option is good for the same reason Medicare and Medicaid are - they cut that middleman out.

(By the way, has anyone else been seeing a massive uptick of ads saying "we heath insurance companies are fighting for you, the people, against the evil pharmaceutical cartels?" I've been seeing them everywhere in the last few weeks).

Avatar

Kay W.4 months ago

I was never Medicare for All but now I see how fragile a private insurance based system is with Obamacare and I think that’s unacceptable. We can’t have a system that is at risk of ending completely every time we lose an election. Medicare exists and is solid. People can rely on it.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Yes, but a public option takes care of that problem as well, since it cuts out the private middleman.

It's actually a decent way to strangle private health insurance to death: some people will drop their private insurer now that there's an alternative, which means private insurers will hike up costs to make up for the loss, which means more people will have to drop out and go public, which means private insurers will hike up costs, which means more people will have to drop out and go public...

At the end, private insurers are basically reduced to what they should always have been, a luxury option for people who can afford it and don't want to wait in line. And most people are on public insurance.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor4 months ago

she’s not actually launching these smears against El- Sayed, but the various PACS who are supporting her are, so she can claim (as she did in the debate) to be running a positive campaign while distancing herself from the lobbyist attack dogs who are supporting her.

I wonder if this works. I know that deep blue Denver CO-1 isn't the same dynamic as a Michigan statewide race, but Diana DeGette's PAC ads were the opposite of effective against Melat Kiros. People aren't stupid. They understand that going very negative means that there's no positive agenda from the candidate. And they certainly don't care that it's a PAC vs the campaign. That's way too much inside baseball, plus those who know anything about PACs know that they coordinate with the candidates.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Get a load of these two jagoffs reaching across the aisle

https://www.thecentersquare.com/pennsylvania/article_ea6e5313-4a45-4c9d-b856-a7a6f7284cb6.html

Fettermanchinema has officially teamed up with McCormick on fundraising because he knows he's toast.

"Last Monday, the two made a rare joint appearance in Philadelphia to encourage Pennsylvania families to enroll their children into Trump accounts."

GTFOH

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

“This is a donor driven effort,” Mike DeVanney, a McCormick campaign spokesman, said to The Center Square. “This group of donors value the collaboration exhibited by Senators McCormick and Fetterman for Pennsylvania and want to support both of them.”

Fetterman’s campaign did not respond to a request for comment."

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

I've seen some online commentary outlining that same thing. With McSorrow bailing, it's as if Stevens doesn't know what the next messaging step is and certainly her conventional consultants are probably behind this.

Not that she needs any shove in that direction.

She comes across a lot like Porter in CA: a centrist in a district theorectically suited for what passes for her skillset...but that doesn't translate into a statewide audience.

Avatar

tam1MI 4 months ago

The thing that makes me nervous about El-Sayed Is that the same clowns who foisted Graham Platner on Maine are working for his campaign, and God only knows what they will do to screw up his campaign. He should probably get rid of those people ASAP and distance himself as much as possible.

Avatar

tam1MI 4 months ago

I think the thing to watch in the near term is where Mallory McMorrow's voters go now that she has dropped out. The consensus among the Gongwer Reports" people is that, because El-Sayed's rise in the polls came directly at the expense of McMorrow that he has gotten all of her voters that he is going to get, and the remainder are going to go to Stevens.

  • Gongwer Reports is a newsletter that follows politics and governance in Michigan. I get a free subscription to it through my job, if you have not already subscribed to it, Kay, I highly recommend that you do.
  • Avatar

    Kay W.4 months ago

    Thanks I will. A poll came out immediately after the debate that had them tied up, so maybe you’re right. I don’t know why Right and Center Democrats are sticking with “blank check for Israel”. I think it’s a huge mistake. When Right wing Democrat (and big Israel supporter) Rahm Emanuel says it’s time to reevaluate that relationship it’s probably time. What can the Democratic Party possibly have in common with far Right Israel? Mamdani now polls better with Jewish Democrats than Netanyahu does.

    Avatar

    C P4 months ago

    I suspect it's so ingrained they can't conceive of a different world.

    It's been observed a few times that our oldest pols tend to be people who grew up in the old-school Democratic coalition, heavy on the "white ethnics" Biden - Irish, Pelosi - Italian, and Schumer - Jewish, make a nice personification). And every group had sacred cows that you had to honor. If you wanted the Polish vote, you better be a Cold War hawk; likewise, if you wanted the Jewish vote, you better be an Israel hawk.

    Opportunistic politicians understood this, but there's a lot more to politics than opportunists. A lot of people who rose up through that kind of Democratic Party would be people who very much believed in the sacred cows (and in time embraced each other's sacred cows). I fully believe that there are plenty of Dems for whom America without Israel is as inconceivable as America without Britain or Canada: an ally so close that even if it's currently doing something immoral, you can't just let go.

    Avatar

    mister mixAuthor4 months ago

    Melat Kiros had basically a one-sentence answer when asked about her position on military aid to Israel: her position, opposing it, is the position of a large majority of the Democratic Party.

    You can have a different answer for the general, but for the primary, any answer that's different from hers needs to be defended. It's not the other way around anymore.

    Avatar

    C P4 months ago

    Oh, sure. And I agree with her position. I just think the old-timers (and the people they've trained) can't bring themselves to understand that it's not the other way around anymore, and that's at least partly because they believe it should be the other way around.

    (I mean, forget the Democratic public; most of the Jewish public doesn't like the Israeli government anymore).

    Avatar

    mister mixAuthor4 months ago

    Just to be clear: agree with you C P.