I guess I’m supposed to feel comforted by the fact that the Supreme Court decided 5-4 or 6-3 that the Constitution says what it says about birthright citizenship? Sorry if I don’t share the enthusiasm.

What nonsense. He forgot to add “except for guns - we don’t care about that”. Let’s remember the plain text of Section 1 of the 14th Amendment:

❝

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

All the years of venerating these clowns, the endless “balls and strikes” and “stare decisis” confirmation hearings and 3 or 4 of them, however you want to count it, are unable to affirm the plain text of the document they’re hired to interpret.

Also, they took another swipe at trans kids, and they announced that they’re going to look at whether AR-15 bans are constitutional next session. Wonder how that one will come out?

So tell me again why regulating kids on social media is the most important agenda item for 2029?

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

"...we do know this: The president’s maneuvers are not even the worst thing Trump has done this month on the steal-this-election front. Not by a long shot.

The Trump regime has been signaling for months that it sees the U.S. intelligence community — spy agencies like the CIA — not as a tool for finding out what comes next in the Persian Gulf, or if or when China is invading Taiwan, or when Vladimir Putin’s Russian empire will fall. No, Trump wants secret agents who can creatively invent theories of foreign-born election fraud that would demand a strongman response.

We saw this coming back in January, when the regime dispatched Trump 47’s first director of national intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard, to Fulton County, Ga. to oversee an FBI raid of voting materials from the 2020 election that Trump, with no evidence, continues to dispute. That link made clear that the regime is looking to create links to foreign actors..."

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Blurring the lines between domestic police work and foreign intelligence collection was already a terrible idea in its own right, which is how we now have a spymaster running election security...

Honestly though, it's sad just how much this is a continuation of existing trends. The FBI's origin story, after all, is "spent forty years as J. Edgar Hoover's personal secret police," a time during which he assiduously persecuted civil rights and anti-war movements while actual criminal conspiracies like the Mafia and the KKK were ignored until enough kicks in the ass from higher-up had been given. (And collecting blackmail material on politicians, mustn't forget that).

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

Little note:

Gorsuch voted to end birthright citizenship. Anybody remember the Senator who "introduced" him during his confirmation hearings and then bitched about his fellow Dems who filibustered Gorsuch?

If you remember/guessed Michael Bennet, current Dem Senator from CO and gubanatorial candidate, you win!

With "Dems" like him...

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

He's in my email inbox every ten freakin' minutes too 😡

Avatar

Lisa F4 months ago

Fingers crossed that he doesn't pass the post this primary election day.

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

If one of the latest awful things in this country, Kalshi, is to be believed, the betting odds (or wtf they call it) give Bennet only a 24% chance which is down from 81% at the beginning of June.

Same bizzaro swing with Kiros: she had a 41% chance on 1 June, now it's up to 78%.

I have no clue of dumbass gambling like that (John Oliver has a great piece on this) actually has any predictive value. I remain skeptical about Kiros winning (hope I'm wrong) but more confident that Bennet will be returned to DC where he belongs. Well, better there than here for now.

Avatar

green goblin4 months ago

IANL but I think this ruling opens an avenue of inquiry into this SCOTUS. At least 3 justices violated their oath by ruling against the 14th Amendment. Kavanaugh can be brought before Congress to explain why the 14th can be changed by Congressional law but not the 2nd and what other amendments he thinks can be changed outside the specific constitution amendment process.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

I'm genuinely not sure what the answer would look like, but a part of me's increasingly pissed off every time it sees a politician do something like this and get away with no punishment at all.

Like, when a politician introduces vote suppression measures, and even in the happy scenario where the Court says it's illegal, nothing happens to the politician. He's free to just go on as before. And it's like... are you fucking shitting me? This guy violated the Constitution in order to deprive thousands of his voters of their most important right! No, it's not enough that a court restored those rights and eventually reversed his violation - that guy belongs in a fucking prison for the rest of his life, far more than if he were just some random low-level political operator who stole a ballot box!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

THIS!

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Being honest, I'm relieved anyway. It's nauseating that 3 or 4 justices voted against it, but in the modern age that's frankly no less than I expected. They've treated the constitution like toilet paper at least as far back as Sandra Day O'Connor's "I ruled for Bush in Bush vs Gore because I really didn't want to wait another four years to retire" moment.

The fact that this could just as easily have been 6-3 against birthright citizenship, and there was plenty of reason to believe it would be, makes the result a big deal to me all the same.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Birthright citizenship is a huge deal to me. It doesn't hurt that I know multiple people who are only citizens because of their birthplace, that I'm myself a dual citizen, and that all those cases of what they see as liminal Americans are MAGA targets.

But beyond that it goes to the core of American identity, more than almost any other part of the Constitution. It's not just that it reiterates our identity as a nation of immigrants. It's also one of the only stopgaps against growing a permanent, multi-generational, underclass of people. As things stand, if you come to America illegally - or what MAGA decide qualifies as "illegally" - you may be fucked your entire life, but if your children are born here, at least they won't be. You're not starting a line of ten generations of indentured servants, unpersons in the eyes of the law. Your children will be able to be citizens, get better jobs than you had, and who knows, one day even be President.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Put simply: birthright citizenship is what prevents us from having a slave race again.

I don't know what the writers intended (the precedent definitely goes back farther than the 14th Amendment itself), but it doesn't seem like a coincidence that they passed it right after winning the Civil War and passing the 13th Amendment.

If the American ideal distilled to its purest essence is (quoth Chamberlain in Gettysburg) "here we judge you by what you do, not by who your father was," then the 14th Amendment is its firmest guarantee. Your father was a drug smuggler for Pablo Escobar and your mother was an illegal immigrant who ran a brothel? We don't give a shit. You are your own person, you were born under American law and by God you will have all the rights of an American citizen to make your own way here.

Is the 14th Amendment enough? No. There should be a hell of a lot more protecting such people. But thus far, it's the best we got. I'm just glad it's still with us for now.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor4 months ago

Nothing wrong with being relieved with this bunch of clowns.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Staring down a heat index of one hundred ten degrees tomorrow (real temp 101+) through Saturday, haven't experienced anything like that since I left PA for Texas, where they siesta through it every afternoon.

Got sumthin' for Boof

https://youtu.be/Sj9OtRWfmtM?si=Pl4ZfJUyzT1E8rMD

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Motherfuckers

"Supreme Court rules 6-3 to strike down limits on how much party committees can spend in coordination with candidates. The latest ruling over the last two decades to unravel campaign finance restrictions. On ideological lines, written by Kavanaugh."

https://bsky.app/profile/muellershewrote.com/post/3mpj7zq6g3c2b

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Kate Riga skeet:

"Kavanaugh says that Constitution is an "enduring document" and that new exceptions to birthright citizenship can be added for "modern situations that were unknown or unanticipated by the Constitution’s Framers"

Dave Draeger:

"Weird how this never applies to the Second Amendment."

Avatar

C P4 months ago

I mean, truthfully, they don't give a shit about any amendment (or article) and will toss them all out when convenient. See also every single case where a cop murdered somebody and justified it as "well gee I just thought they had a gun!"

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

First entry

"My read on the birthright citizenship cert grant was that the court, and particularly Roberts, wanted to use it as a fig leaf—an easy way to buck Trump & distract the public from their cooperation with him. The razor-thin margin of today’s ruling makes me think even that view was too optimistic."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

A favorite meme has a guy selling big trashcans. He's slapping a lid on one and saying "You can fit a whole Supreme Court in here!"

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Well, no. Unless it's a preposterously big trash can, you couldn't actually fit nine justices in there. Especially at their very non-spry age. You'd have to, like, cut off all their limbs and cut up all their body before you could Tetris them all into a trash can...

... Your ideas intrigue me and I would like to subscribe to your newsletter.