Tam R mentioned this in the comments of a post and it’s a banger, just a clear-eyed recitation of facts and what Europe needs to do now that Trump has abandoned them.

With Trump’s announcement that he’s delaying Mexican tariffs for a month showing that Claudia Sheinbaum was smart to delay her counter-tariff response until the weekend, this piece that Gloria DryGarden sent in from Facebook is an interesting read. It’s attributed to David Honig who teaches negotiation at Indiana University Law School:

❝

Trump, as most of us know, is the credited author of "The Art of the Deal," a book that was actually ghost written by a man named Tony Schwartz, who was given access to Trump and wrote based upon his observations. If you've read The Art of the Deal, or if you've followed Trump lately, you'll know, even if you didn't know the label, that he sees all dealmaking as what we call "distributive bargaining."

Distributive bargaining always has a winner and a loser. It happens when there is a fixed quantity of something and two sides are fighting over how it gets distributed. Think of it as a pie and you're fighting over who gets how many pieces. In Trump's world, the bargaining was for a building, or for construction work, or subcontractors. He perceives a successful bargain as one in which there is a winner and a loser, so if he pays less than the seller wants, he wins. The more he saves the more he wins.

The other type of bargaining is called integrative bargaining. In integrative bargaining the two sides don't have a complete conflict of interest, and it is possible to reach mutually beneficial agreements. Think of it, not a single pie to be divided by two hungry people, but as a baker and a caterer negotiating over how many pies will be baked at what prices, and the nature of their ongoing relationship after this one gig is over.

The problem with Trump is that he sees only distributive bargaining in an international world that requires integrative bargaining. He can raise tariffs, but so can other countries. He can't demand they not respond. There is no defined end to the negotiation and there is no simple winner and loser. There are always more pies to be baked. Further, negotiations aren't binary. China's choices aren't (a) buy soybeans from US farmers, or (b) don't buy soybeans. They can also (c) buy soybeans from Russia, or Argentina, or Brazil, or Canada, etc. That completely strips the distributive bargainer of his power to win or lose, to control the negotiation.

One of the risks of distributive bargaining is bad will. In a one-time distributive bargain, e.g. negotiating with the cabinet maker in your casino about whether you're going to pay his whole bill or demand a discount, you don't have to worry about your ongoing credibility or the next deal. If you do that to the cabinet maker, you can bet he won't agree to do the cabinets in your next casino, and you're going to have to find another cabinet maker.

There isn't another Canada.

So when you approach international negotiation, in a world as complex as ours, with integrated economies and multiple buyers and sellers, you simply must approach them through integrative bargaining. If you attempt distributive bargaining, success is impossible. And we see that already.

Trump has raised tariffs on China. China responded, in addition to raising tariffs on US goods, by dropping all its soybean orders from the US and buying them from Russia. The effect is not only to cause tremendous harm to US farmers, but also to increase Russian revenue, making Russia less susceptible to sanctions and boycotts, increasing its economic and political power in the world, and reducing ours. Trump saw steel and aluminum and thought it would be an easy win, BECAUSE HE SAW ONLY STEEL AND ALUMINUM - HE SEES EVERY NEGOTIATION AS DISTRIBUTIVE. China saw it as integrative, and integrated Russia and its soybean purchase orders into a far more complex negotiation ecosystem.

Trump has the same weakness politically. For every winner there must be a loser. And that's just not how politics works, not over the long run.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Joyce Harmon1 year ago

Something I've always said about Trump is that the same thing that made him such a lousy businessman makes him a lousy politician. He is simply incapable of making a deal where all parties go away feeling satisfied and looking forward to working with one another again. That's the very bedrock of both business and politics, the win-win. But Trump can't do that - he is psychological incapable of it. To him, in order for him to win, someone else has to lose. And the bigger the other guy's loss and humiliation, the better. The best deals, the ones that make him feel best about himself, like the Biggest Winner, are those that leave the other guy's face ground in the mud, and Trump can spit on him as he struts away celebrating his own greatness. What a way to build a coalition, right?

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

This also speaks to how transactional everything has become thanks to Trump. It’s bad enough that he approaches government this way, but now he has given approval to every person who wants to treat everything in life as transactional.

That destruction to the moral fabric of society is going to be harder to repair than the political damage he causes.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Yep - another example "What have the veterans done for me lately?"

Some Trump chud was on TV saying that vets shouldn't be guaranteed jobs.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

To be fair, he had fertile ground to trod on when it came to "everything is transactional". Urban "progressives" (as I like to say, because they voted for Obama and support abortion rights, they think that makes them "liberal", or something) basically view everything as transactional. It was shocking when I first experienced it.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

"If you attempt distributive bargaining, success is impossible. And we see that already."

What "we" see is somewhat immaterial right now. You can bet the Orange Fart Cloud and his minions don't see any of it other than a success, regardless of the outcome.

One of the better, and very recent pieces, on his mob boss geopolitics: https://www.newstatesman.com/world/europe/ukraine/2025/02/trump-ukraine-mineral-deal-zelensky

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

That piece seems to think that some kind of mineral deal will happen. Probably, but I'm going to guess it will be watered down to almost nothingness. That's another characteristic of Trump's negotiating strategy -- he ends up having to save face at the end and accept "sleeves of a vest" deals. Like what happened with Mexico today (I guess she agreed to having more of our troops on the border, another "sleeve of a vest".)