The last couple of years I fell into a kind of denial state about current events and the Democratic Party, where things seemed too grim to face and I had this sort of vague idea that if I just went along with the Power of Positive Thinking I could…manifest a reality where we weren’t losing. It went like this: Joe Biden wasn’t showing signs of age-related decline, he simply has “a stutter”. War crimes aren’t really war crimes if they’re supported and advanced by a Democratic administration. Closing public schools for covid didn’t damage 50 million children. All polls and newspapers are wrong. People saying over and over they couldn’t afford housing or food really just hated Democrats and/or are sexist, racist and homophobic and should be ignored or actively shunned. You get the general picture.

I’m not a particularly good cheerleader. It was never natural to me and it became like a straitjacket I could no longer wear. When I “snapped out of” whatever spell I was under and looked around at the wreckage of the liberal order I told myself I would never play cheerleader again.

So. While I am as thrilled as all of you that giant douchebag Donald Trump is tanking in the polls, the reality is that he still outpolls Democrats. We need to grapple with this problem. Trump’s losses aren’t turning into Dem gains. That’s where we are.

Open thread to tell me how wrong I am (feel free)

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

The reality is that we are trying to deal with a decades long systematic disassembly of government. The Republicans and Libertarians have been so successful at vilifying the belief in the common good and the social contract that we are fighting constantly even the idea that government can be a force for good. Japan didn’t close their schools during COVID because they didn’t act like whiny babies about masking AND they installed state of the art HVAC and air exchange systems to keep air inside the classrooms moving and clean. We didn’t even try to make the case for those measures. Instead we got stuck arguing for the relative safety of closing schools even though we knew it would be detrimental because we correctly assumed Republicans wouldn’t agree to upgrade systems. So we took it off the table before even making the case. We do this all the time. But even if we had made the case we suck at implementing. 5 years later we would just be starting to install the new systems.

Avatar

Spanish Moss1 year ago

I have four kids in their early thirties and they keep it real for me. I don't see how things improve until we get more of the old farts out of party leadership (says this old fart).

My kids vote Democratic because that is the only reasonable option, but you should hear them talk about the party. Our leaders are old and don't communicate effectively. They don't understand new technology in a personal way and they prioritize the wrong issues. Their identities are defined by their offices so they are afraid to take risks or face the personal loss of stepping back.

Talk of comity and bipartisanship is a huge turnoff -- that disappeared before my kids were old enough to follow politics. We need more AOCs and fewer Connollys (we really shot ourselves in the foot there). They were so excited when Kamala Harris became the nominee!

My kids vote, but they are not ENGAGED. They go to protests but don't participate in party activities because the Democratic party isn't speaking to them.

Avatar

Betty Cracker1 year ago

That tracks precisely with what I hear from my mid-20s kiddo & friends.

Avatar

Al N1 year ago

You aren't wrong, but you're asking the wrong question. The problem is not "Trump’s losses aren’t turning into Dem gains," the problem is "what kind of a social order, what kind of governance model, do we want and who can we recruit to help us get it?" You're right that the Democratic Party is part and parcel of the wreckage of the liberal order, so to imagine a strategy that involves them riding to our rescue makes no sense. It's up to us.

People on the liberal end of the political spectrum like to hate on The Bulwark and I get why: they're right-wingers, but they see some things with a clarity that's lost on the left because they never were Democrats. For example: https://www.thebulwark.com/p/how-to-think-and-act-like-a-dissident-in-trumps-america. Simple language, 2 pages long. It doesn't answer the "what kind of social order" question, but the steps to build the fight back are there. It's a strategy, if not a program, for a resistance.

Avatar

Betty Cracker1 year ago

I blame myself for over-valuing incumbency. I wrongly figured that in a rematch between two old farts, the sitting president would win. Then came the debate.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Gov. Janet Mills stood up early and often.

PORTLAND, Maine — President Donald Trump’s administration on Friday agreed to halt all efforts to freeze funds intended for a Maine child nutrition program after initially suspending those dollars due to a disagreement between the state and Trump over transgender athletes.

In response, the state will drop its lawsuit that had been filed against the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Maine Attorney General Aaron Frey announced.

“It’s unfortunate that my office had to resort to federal court just to get USDA to comply with the law and its own regulations,” Frey said in a statement. “But we are pleased that the lawsuit has now been resolved and that Maine will continue to receive funds as directed by Congress to feed children and vulnerable adults.”

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

She’s a badass! She became a prosecutor because of an abusive partner when she was young. The dumbest thing he could have done was try to bully her.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I was definitely a major cheerleader for the Dems because I was so gung ho on 'fascism must die by any/all means.' Now that I'm seeing so much capitulation and outright bootlicking, I'm sliding further leftward, into my former sort of socialist ideals (social democracy). Big Gretch surprised me, but not my cousin who is her constituent. I fail to see the long term benefit of coddling a demented bully, but my cuz thinks it was the thing to do. I wanted to talk about the success that such appeasement usually 'wins,' but in the interest of staying polite, I just dropped the subject.

I'm with you, Kay. Regardless of the cause of the current bullshit, I'll think twice before I cheerlead for the Dem party in public. The waning sense of urgency in the before and after of this past election is seriously unimpressive (except for a few like J.B. Pritzger).

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Good to see you.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Agree that Pritzker's style of straightforward statement of what he sees as the truth needs to be adopted by a lot of other Dems who are pretty mealy mouthed, even now.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

That's a reason why the AOC/Sanders tour is drawing crowds. People can beat on Sanders and to a lesser extent AOC all they want but their talk and messaging is resonating at some level.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

Self knowledge is rarely good news. Or, you're not wrong! It can feel really lonely being the only Dems in the room not surprised by Trump's 2nd win; really, a coronation. I quit a very wealthy, big, 90% Black gym back last June, where I fit in just fine, because the social atmosphere of the locker room gave off the telltale aromas of Trumper derangement. Or at least, pervasive I-Don't-Care. The same, really.

After the election, was anybody who was watching carefully, surprised by the immediate descent into madness? (Uh, it was already there, if you could see it). It sucks knowing there's no formula to turn things around. Shit happens. We got to stick together and muddle through. I suppose just being a good example. Hasn't worked for our extended family though.

I had a lot of Eastern European friends back in the '80s in grad school. Read a lot of the Polish/Czech literature. Much rhyming going on now. It got better! But... it took a long time.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

EEEEK! I hate LIKE buttons. This one allowed me to click on it. It allowed me to LIKE myself. EWWW that's ghastly.

I have played the LIKE/UP button game once, on HN. Yes I "won" it, had some fun for a bit, but after a while I got disgusted with the way I was tilting my comments. So now I don't comment much on HN, but that's also because the comments there descend pretty rapidly into stuff that looks like LLM generated "content".

Is there a way to turn off LIKES on my comments? I don't want them. I don't care if I drop to the bottom of whatever rank mechanism is going on. I hate that I still look at them. I just want to write what I think is true, without appealing to the audience.

This is why I am a billionaire.

Well, no, I am not.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Trump’s losses aren’t turning into Dem gains

Cuz the Dem Party has spent much of the last 30 years thinking that the so-called "New Economy" and it's urbanist center was the long-term path to electoral dominance. Instead, it's alienated significant chunks of traditional Dem voters (black, labor for example).

Dems took an easy, and essentially white-based approach to assembling a coalition based on cosmopolitan business urbanism which has lead to the marginalization of the working poor and the mostly correct perception that the party is dominated by a coalition of elites.

It's made us vulnerable to a challenge from the popular right and we haven't, and quite frankly won't given the disparate goals within the Party, come up with a populist left stragety that doesn't abandon core civil rights, labor, education and economic values. We can't agree on half of them as it is.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I think we disagree on causes. I’m just not sure what the causes are - but I think we have to look and ask.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I've brought up what I think are some causes.

Thing is, I was oblivious to this when I lived in red, rurl Misery for all those years. And kinda followed along with that train of thought being far removed from it day-to-day.

But moving to one of those hot, "new economy" places and seeing how it's played out opened my eyes. Particularly IRT black and brown people and how these "progressives" view them, basically they are extremely racially tone deaf to those concerns, support policies that actively hurt them, etc.

Sooo, these comments are part of the looking and asking.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I'm not sure about causes either. If we broaden out what Scott is saying, I can agree with the notion that core constituencies (blacks, latinos, unions) have been taken for granted while D's try to fight over the white relatively conservative voters. D's were also far too receptive to megadonors, who are generally white and more conservative.

But I also think that it's about not having any good press. Republicans shit all over the country and their media treats it like glitter and rainbows. Dems passed some good legislation in Biden's term and only the downsides are examined.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

The corporatized media environment is in practice nearly entirely and explicitly anti-anti Trump. While claiming to be agnostic their thumbs push down on the credibility of anti-Trump content and they "balance" that by pushing up on credibility of Trump content.

A for-profit "news" organization maximizes profits by implementing reportage as that which makes balanced opposing teams, mas o menos. "Balanced" is defined by what the news corps decide the main mode of the distribution of viewers' characteristic attention seeking urges require. Roger Ailes is the pioneering genius here, goddam him to hell.

Truth ain't innit.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

The ax grinding you like to do with "progressives" is not really coalition building.

There is a big difference between "I am a life coach for butterflies, and my budget to buy a new house is $2,000,000" and the people who are in your community who seem to be doing well but have to relocate to California because they are not going to be able to make the mortgage with their employer threatening their job if they don't return to office.

It overlooks the fact that people are paying mortgages that cost a little more than preschool for their children under five while also attempting to pay off their student loans.

Some of the white progressivism that you like ax grind against is falling over under its own weight. A group thought that blocking off two more blocks from traffic was going to be their big progressive issue this year, and they were jerks to folks who disagreed. They are not getting their signatures for their ballot initiative.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

One reason I'm so cranky about this is that people like me have been told to keep our concerns to ourselves, all in the name of "coalition building". And we're seeing the fruits of that staying mum in terms of how Dems are seen, are branded and, quite frankly, how a large chunk of this 'coalition' either takes for granted or ignores it's historical core constituencies.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Oh, and email me about the group wanting to block off two more blocks of traffic. :)

They also probably think the suicide squeezes we've talked about are good things. ;)

Avatar

r po1 year ago

Well I think (maybe I'm wrong) the disagreement is that radiating negativity sideways, or perceptively slightly downwards, is not maximizing energy on the sources of the oppression that's causing all of us our major malfunction.

Sure some of them might be on the payroll of the ones I allude to. Always going to be the case. Fight up, to the big money, is what I say.

I'm not saying "shut up". I'm sayin', I don't see this 'saying' amounting to much, in the end, against the fascist forces of control, to quote an Au Pairs tune.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

Could you please define your terms? I thought urbanism was a movement to make cities more walkable, more environmentally sustainable, etc.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

It is, but he is battling everyone under fifty because his city builds bike infrastructure that is both expensive and low quality.

For example, we spend millions of dollars building underpasses for bikes. Then people build their homeless camp there, and the underpass is not used for its original intent because folks don't feel safe.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Heh heh, you forgot to add it's poorly designed and implemented. Many of us voted for the bonding in 2019 for "bike infrastructure" but as usual, the City botched what's been done and it's so awful, we have quite a few people in the cycling community who also speak out about it.

It's also seen as a cultural avatar by many of the black/brown folks here, with good reason.

Alas, if it were just that...

Much of what gets done in the name of all of this is simply to give carte blanche to developers for poorly planned, unlimited development, disguising much of it in banal, progressive-sounding language with a lot of lefty greenwashing that has no basis in fact. The displacement/gentrification issues are significant, the impact on the City's landscape has been awful because no thought was put into how best to do this because, that would have cut into developers profits.