Tear-gassing a Halloween parade is pretty bad, and Pritzker is making a lot of good noise about it. Here he was last night handing out candy in the Little Village neighborhood of Chicago:

Photo Credit: @humanizingthroughstory on Instagram

Greg Sargent’s podcast yesterday had Dave Karpf, who teaches media and public affairs at GWU. Karpf’s pretty good, and he likes Pritzker:

❝

Karpf: I think of all the Democratic governors, Pritzker is the one who understands the assignment best. And that’s because he’s both telling stories that are true about what’s happening in Chicago, but also painting a picture of what Chicagoans are facing and making clear that this is an attack from Trump’s forces.

Sargent: Yeah. And I think Pritzker makes another interesting move here that I really want people to listen to. Check this out.

Governor JB Pritzker (voiceover): The Department of Homeland Security claims their highest priority is to protect children. So today I have to ask them. Please, live up to those ideals. I’ve sent a letter to Kristi Noem and to the Department of Homeland Security leadership asking them to pause all of their federal agent operations for the entirety of the Halloween weekend. I’m asking for basic human decency. I think their response will be revealing.

[…]

Karpf: Right. What he’s making clear there—I think he’s doing a really crafty job of raising the stakes by making a request that just seems so reasonable. One of the main classes that I teach is strategic political communication. And the trick that I always try to teach people about framing, when you are engaged in a framing battle, is you want to position yourself as being deeply reasonable and your opponent or the status quo as utterly absurd.

Of course, Kristi Noem had some asinine response about never stopping fighting terrorism on the streets of Chicago.

Karpf also has a piece in TNR that takes on one of the many centrist excuse-making, throw-everyone-under-the-bus post-election analysis white papers.

❝

Elections are determined by four broad factors: (1) your message, (2) the messenger, (3) the media environment, and (4) the moment. The only thing that political campaigns have complete control over is the message. We control the words that come out of our own mouths. And so there is a long-standing bad habit among the pundit class of treating those words as though they are the only thing that matters.

The other three factors have increasingly large effects on who wins elections, but also are increasingly hard to influence. The party has some impact on candidate selection (messengers). They don’t get to design the perfect candidate in a hermetically sealed lab, but they can provide resources and support to candidates who seem more likely to win. And sometimes voters choose a candidate that the party leadership doesn’t like.

[…]

If the Democratic Party wants to build power and win elections in the long term, it has to keep all four of those factors in mind—not just the knobs that are easiest to turn. That’s the kind of tunnel-vision thinking—focusing only on those factors that you can most immediately control—that has put the party at an increasing disadvantage over the past few decades.

The report has no answer to the media ownership problem. It doesn’t even raise it as a question. It includes pages upon pages bemoaning the Democratic Party’s messaging woes, without ever considering that the problem might be that its opponents have access to much larger megaphones.

“Deciding to Win” also displays little awareness of what winning elections is for. There is an obvious reason why the Democratic Party ought not abandon its commitment to preventing the climate crisis: a hotter future with more extreme weather events is a future where the moment will often be stacked against incumbents and their broadly democratic values. Climate emergencies and refugee crisis are fodder for authoritarian strongmen, who can seize power by comfortably lying to the electorate while objective reality becomes increasingly unpalatable. You govern well when you are in power, and you hope that your governance decisions led to a more favorable electoral environment over time. (That’s kind of the whole point of democratic elections, actually.)

Read the whole thing, as they say.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

My cats when the clocks are rolled back every year

https://bsky.app/profile/flemtheparrot.bsky.social/post/3m4mx5xnzz22k

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Mikie Sherill finally takes the gloves off! I hope her waiting this long means people with short memories will actually remember this when casting ballots:

https://bsky.app/profile/kevinmkruse.bsky.social/post/3m4m56fm7rc25

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Off topic but too close to home. WTAF Pennsylvania you fucking knuckleheads! How did this pass inspection for entry in a parade?

https://www.pennlive.com/news/2025/11/harrisburgs-catholic-bishop-apologizes-for-nazi-imagery-on-halloween-parade-float.html

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Arbeit Macht Frei from a fucking grade school?

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

"In our middle school, students in grades 6 through 8 experience a dynamic environment where academic rigor meets spiritual growth. Our curriculum, grounded in Christian values, encourages critical thinking and personal development while fostering a strong moral foundation for navigating their formative years and beyond."

Rigor mortis is more like it says I.

https://sjshanover.org/

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

That school needs to be banned from the parade for a few years. WTF.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

In other words, your students grades 6 through 8 experience an environment in which fascist ideals may or may not be promoted but are, either way, treated as being so utterly banal and mainstream that "Arbeit Macht Frei" feels as innocuous as a portrait of the Virgin Mary.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

🎯

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

We had Nazi graffiti spraypainted in the streets here a couple years ago and the response was basically "Oh those rascally kids, what a bunch of scalawags"

Avatar

C P1 year ago

But every kid who so much as draws a hopskotch court in chalk on the sidewalk is vandalism and yet another sign that the Yutes are out of control and our cities are falling apart.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

What the actual fuck?

It’s shit like this which is why I keep telling my relatives that their Islamophobia is misplaced. White Christians are just out there putting the Holocaust on parade (literally) and people are cheering.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Centrism cannot fail, it can only be failed!

Great piece by Karpf, and also the piece TBone posted below. It’s nice to know that other people see what we see. It helps me feel a little less insane.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Who is paying into WelcomePAC to generate long reports signifying nothing is what I wanna know.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

"Our core team is based in Virginia, South Carolina, Massachusetts, Ohio, and Colorado and has worked on a range of Democratic and nonpartisan initiatives across the country."

https://welcomepac.org/about

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Wikipedia:

"According to NYMag, WelcomePAC is funded by billionaires Reid Hoffman, Michael Bloomberg, James Murdoch and his wife Kathryn, Rory Gates, the Walton family, and Joe Manchin and Heather Manchin's centrist Americans Together organization.[5]"

AHA I KNEW IT

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Yup. All the usual suspects. Not a single Democrat in that group. Their money and advice is useless.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

https://x.com/burkehenryt/status/1963596391206273277/photo/1

https://x.com/katewillett/status/1963642887498801457/photo/1

https://x.com/burkehenryt/status/1970517039233003588/photo/2

Another Abundance Liberal funder of "The Argument" is a grant program called Emergent Ventures, headed up by libertarian economist Tyler Cowen and founded with a grant from Peter Thiel at the Mercatus Center libertarian think tank.

Thanks Pete, for supporting liberalism! https://x.com/katewillett/status/1957552865829876160

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 1 year ago

James Murdoch! I had higher hopes for him.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Then you have America's Biggest Dumbass preaching shit like this:

https://x.com/joewrote/status/1984393399794090408

Centrist incrementalism at it's finest!

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Pritzker was definitely dropped on his head as a child because when you look at him compared to the rest of that family, it's the only explanation.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I really really! hope that his values are core and not merely calculated. He's shown himself to be worthy of my respect and he gives me hope when I'm running low.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Oh, no core values and everything being calculated describes Governor GoodHair II.

If I had to choose a Dem nominee now and my only choices were Pritzker or Newsome, the former wins hands down. The latter would murder his own grandmother to be President and it shows.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

I mean, if it's Pritzker versus a guy who can't talk about transgender people without sounding like he's applying for J. K. Rowling's hand in marriage...

"Here, JB, twist my arm. OW, what the fuck?" "Uh... I haven't even touched you yet." "Man, you really are from Chicago. OK, OK, I'll do it! I'll vote for you!" "... Thanks?"

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

As I said the other day, it’s a miracle that anyone coming from his background doesn’t end up a sociopath.

Avatar
Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Great piece.

The "Welcome" group being called 'center-left'? Gimmeafuckingbreak. They exist to make the political spectrum consist of Moderate Republican (who may or may not support abortion rights) to Nazi.

As somebody said here in the last week, in terms of political enemies, the GOP is #1, people like these are #1b. Take their vote when it matters, ignore anything they say in terms of Democratic stategy.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

1,000% well said

Avatar

C P1 year ago

"The "Welcome" group being called 'center-left'? Gimmeafuckingbreak. They exist to make the political spectrum consist of Moderate Republican (who may or may not support abortion rights) to Nazi."

I never realized it at the time (if only because it took me time to realize just exactly what the mainstream media is; like most Americans, I grew up thinking basically "if it's not Fox News, it leans left"), but looking back at the 2000s from later on, it really impressed me how hard and successfully the media acted to limit the range of mainstream Iraq War opinions to a spectrum that went from Colin Powell on the far left to Donald Rumsfeld on the far right. And how long it worked. Not only was the whole "argument" within the same party, it was basically all within the Bush cabinet.

Barack Obama was basically the first politician who actually opposed the war that wasn't treated as a fringe lunatic.

And of course, all politics is like this.