I’m going to clear some tabs — all of these stories seem unconnected but they’re related.

First, given the discussion yesterday about housing, here’s an interesting paper from some Berkeley academics. This is from the first section:

❝

[…] U.S. housing markets have faced a secular shortage of housing supply in the past decade. Since 2011, the U.S. on average added 1.1 million new housing units every year, which is 30% lower than the long run equilibrium annual construction units before the Great Recession, and 34% lower than the annual new construction demand estimated by Freddie Mac (Khater et al. 2018). As home prices have continued to diverge from household incomes over the past 10-15 years, why has housing supply remained so persistently low? Although housing underproduction is widely perceived as a key contributor to fast-growing house prices, the extensive academic literature exploring this question has tended to focus on the distortionary effects of excessive housing regulations (i.e. zoning and building codes). These administrative policies are typically viewed as the central factor in limiting housing supply (Glaeser and Gyourko 2018, Molloy 2020). This paper, however, provides novel evidence documenting that labor supply is also an important channel affecting housing supply. We show that negative shocks to a region’s construction workforce are highly persistent, and lead to sharp reductions in overall residential construction activity as well as subsequently higher home prices.

The labor shortage in housing has remained stark over the past decade (Porter 2019, Freddie Mac 2017). Although the association is not causal, Figure 1 shows the U.S. construction sector lost 2.2 million employment (or 29% of its total employment peak at 2006) during the Great Recession, but barely recovered afterwards although the economy has greatly expanded. Even before the pandemic, construction firms ranked work shortage as the biggest hurdle for their businesses, and 78% of them were experiencing difficulty in filling their job positions.1 We use a national shock to construction labor to quantify the sensitivity of housing market outcomes to labor supply.

Our setting exploits an increase in immigration enforcement arising from a Federal program called Secure Communities, which began in 2008 and eventually rolled out to all counties nationwide by 2013.2 According to ICE records, this program was associated with the deportation of more than 400,000 undocumented immigrants during this time period. […]

The paper also points out that the construction industry has not raised wages to attract more workers, unlike other industries affected by Secure Communities.

So, if we want affordable housing, we need to address the labor shortage in the construction market. We also need to stop being “tougher than Republicans” on immigration, and perhaps try to educate voters about the labor shortage and its affect on housing.

Second:

❝

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump announced Friday that he was scrapping U.S. tariffs on beef, coffee, tropical fruits and a broad swath of other commodities — a dramatic move that comes amid mounting pressure on his administration to better combat high consumer prices.

Trump did something, but the real question is whether the importers of beef, coffee and the other commodities will respond in the way he wants. Trump and his minions treat tariffs like a light switch: they turn them off and prices are supposed to magically drop, perhaps overnight. The economy doesn’t work that way, especially after importers have learned that what Trump says one day can be contradicted the next day.

Finally, in the same vein as the other two stories:

❝

The Federal Aviation Administration said Friday it plans to roll back some of the restrictions on commercial flights it implemented at 40 major U.S. airports during the shutdown.

The agency says the current mandatory 6% flight cuts are being downgraded to 3% even though the record 43-day shutdown ended Nov. 12. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has repeatedly said restrictions would remain until staffing at air traffic control facilities stabilizes and safety metrics improve.

Again, there’s no light switch that will immediately let the ATC system bounce back to full capacity after controllers have been overstressed and probably driving Uber or DoorDash to feed their families.

On one hand, we have an incredibly capricious, impulsive President and administration that careens around flipping every switch available to them in hopes of lowering prices. On the other hand, we’ve got academics saying that some actions that started in 2008 are part of the cause of our housing shortage. We’ve also got a staff of Air Traffic Controllers — fewer after Trump and Musk’s erratic staffing cuts — who are overworked and unpaid for 6 weeks. And we have trading partners that don’t want to trade with us anymore. Put all of this together and we’ll have still more shortages in housing, continued higher prices, and an ATC system that is verging on dangerous.

It doesn’t matter what Trump does in the short term — it’s going to take a hell of a lot of time to fix this mess. There’s a lot of political hay to be made here, but it isn’t a simple story, so making the case will require some serious skill.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

👆Making the ultimate case for social democracy and democratic socialists.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

From the book 1929 by Andrew Ross Sorkin, from an excerpt on Hoover's inauguration speech:

"...calling on Congress to help embattled farmers and to enact a modest program of tariffs to protect American industry. There was not a single word about the runaway stock market or the need to rein in speculation."

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I'm reading the latest bio on Laura Ingalls Wilder. When they fled South Dakota during the Panic of 1893, the callousness of pols like Taft ("The military will have to shoot some of the mob in order to make an impression") irt the wildcat Pullman strike or Cleveland's second innuagural where he said it wasn't the government's business to be in the habit of "supporting the people" is telling.

And here we are 130 years later and in some quarters, nothing's changed.

Avatar
Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Yikes.

That's when I would have been in Northern Italy (Vicenza) as the lone US intel officer in the joint command gathering intel in late 93/early 94 in order to bomb the Serbs in the spring.

Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

WSJ:

"Pulte has made an aggressive push for swift public offerings of Fannie and Freddie, a move Trump has said he would consider, and imagined a new entity called the “Great American Mortgage Corporation.” The two mortgage giants facilitate the market by bundling loans to sell to investors with a government guarantee. They have been under government control since the 2008 financial crisis, and IPOs would be complex, high-stakes transactions.

The fast timeline has been a key flashpoint in the feud between Pulte and Bessent, who has stressed a more careful approach to avoid driving up mortgage rates.

Pulte has allowed Fannie and Freddie to ramp up purchases of mortgage-backed securities as it had done before the 2008 crisis, hoping that doing so could help boost earnings ahead of a potential IPO, according to people familiar with the matter.

After the crisis, the government had ordered Fannie and Freddie to back off that strategy."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Finland has had success with reducing homelessness.

"International interest in the Housing First policy is growing, and the model has been trialled across Europe. According to Kaakinen, the difference between many of the trials in other countries and the Finnish policy is that in Finland, Housing First is not a project but a wholesale change to the country’s housing policy. Scotland is now moving towards it becoming a national policy objective, and in Denmark, the model has also been expanded. However, in most countries “statistics show that a temporary shelter is the primary offer. This is combined with the fact that there is no social housing or housing benefit system,” according to Kaakinen."

https://www.equaltimes.org/finland-s-housing-first-policy

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Sobriety is not a requirement.

Avatar

Jeffrey C1 year ago

For which the Finns are grateful..🤣

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Making qualifying for a home contingent upon sobriety would eliminate most of the entire world!

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I watched a video about this a few months ago. The hard-core homeless, who would probably not have a home even if housing were cheap, have co-morbidities, for lack of a better term (substance abuse and mental illness). The Finns are showing what kind of a commitment (huge) is needed to put them in housing. Our efforts just nibble around the edges of this problem.

This is different from the family where the breadwinner lost his or her job and now has to live in a car. These folks would be a lot easier to help and there should be subsiidzed housing for them. There's an effort in Denver to identify and help people who are teetering on the edge of homelessness after some blow (lost job, car broke down, etc.) and just give them money to get them past their hard time. It's soooo much easier than the hard-core homeless.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

For folks interested in an American example of 'Housing First', go to Houston of all places:

https://www.governing.com/housing/how-houston-cut-its-homeless-population-by-nearly-two-thirds

https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/houston/article/Two-cities-tried-to-fix-homelessness-only-one-15825633.php

The Denver effort is implemented thru a non-profit that works with a variety of non-profit partners: https://www.denverbasicincomeproject.org/who-we-are/#cbos

Which in turn maybe gets money from the City: https://www.denverbasicincomeproject.org/media

I've worked closely with one of the non-profit partners, The Gathering Place, as they're in the neighborhood where I'm president of the Registered Neighborhood Organization.

FYI, this program is by no means a guaranteed thing. It was axed by the Mayor and while kinda put back in by City Council (in the link) many on Council (including my idiot council person) voted against it because...austerity!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Thank you for that follow through! I didn't want to inundate as is my (irritating to some) habit.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

This piece from earlier in the year:

https://www.realtor.com/advice/home-improvement/housing-market-hispanic-workforce/

underscores the 2023 paper you quote and link to.

1/3 of the broadly-labeled 'construction workforce' is Hispanic and 700-900K are estimated to be illegals. Thus, according to the article, 10% of the labor pool is subject to deportation.

The ICE goons here in Denver know that and act accordingly. They were sniffing around the construction going on at the Museum of Nature & Science a couple of weeks back asking Park Rangers questions. Said Park Rangers refused to answer them and apparently reported back to their superiors and somebody started spreading the word. Apparently that kind of unofficial, viral alert process is widespread here.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Construction workers need health insurance. Some people who run construction companies cannot afford to offer insurance to them or cannot offer insurance before a person shows that they are going to stick around for a few months.

Their work is dangerous. People fall off of roofs, have nail gun accidents, etc.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/12/14/us/roofing-children-immigrants.html

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Construction companies have run out of workers to refuse health insurance to.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

That’s why labor unions work so beautifully with construction. The contractor can pull 200 trained framers, masons roofers drywall and painters off a shelf (from a local) and the local handles health insurance and retirement. The contractor can then return those workers to the local when the job is complete, for the next contractor to pull off the shelf. My brother in law is a big time painting contractor in LA and he uses only union labor - not because he likes unions, he’s a winger, but because it’s easier (and cheaper, long term) than maintaining a crew.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Making the case is going to be pretty impossible for the current crop of Congressional Democrats. They don’t really have much political skill, as evidenced by 2025.

Next year has to become a referendum on both MAGA and weak Democrats. Voters need to hold everyone accountable for this mess.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I attended a candidate event we hosted yesterday of the 2 running in the primary against our incumbent, DeGette, who's held the seat since...wait for it...1997.

She's probably a poster child for your "weak Democrats" comment, at least that's what her opponents would say. But funny you should say that next year has to be a referendum on 'weak Dems' (and MAGA) because that's exactly what those two said.

They both boiled it down to "Don't get us wrong, Republicans are the root cause but the amount of enabling and complicity by current Dems hasn't helped. And asking current Dems to be the agents of 'fixing' this is stooopid'.

Okay, they didn't say stooopid but you get the idea. We have a lazy incumbent who's all but invisible to her own constituents unless there's a local news camera around and clearly takes this D+56 beyond for granted.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Just posted about this in the next post...