We live in strange times, but this was very strange:

❝

A 21-year-old recent college graduate was behind an anonymous website that put out widely shared fake election polling in Wisconsin, Nevada and California, the Guardian can reveal.

The website, Median Strategies, abruptly shut down and withdrew its polling earlier this week following questions from a reporter from the Los Angeles Times. In an unsigned statement, it described a “short-term social experiment” to examine how fake polling “could enter and spread through the political information ecosystem without independent verification”.

“I wanted to see if fake polls could really penetrate the ecosystem that easily,” Rahil Prakash told the Guardian on Thursday when reached by phone. “And as it turned out, it could.”

Meridian polls showed Karen Bass up in the LA mayoral race, Hong up 20 in Wisconsin and Republican Governor Joe Lombardo up 5 in Nevada. All of those “results” were apparently pulled straight out of Prakash’s ass.

Since we’re all political junkies here, I’m not going to pretend that I don’t read polls. But I have a few things to say about them.

First, it’s not odd that over the years we’ve spent more time concentrating on polls. National polling and state polling were pretty good for a while, especially when almost nobody had a cell phone. Actual reporting on the ground is expensive, and ultimately anecdata, so political reporters are relying on polls, to their detriment. Here’s a story on Aisha Wahab, the woman who won the special election for Eric Swalwell’s seat:

❝

While Wahab held a major lead throughout the race, Hernandez’s campaign received a significant boost as Super Pacs connected to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (Aipac) poured money into the race. With 92% of votes counted on Thursday afternoon, Wahab led Hernandez by just over six points – a much closer race than expected.

The Guardian (emphasis mine)

How did the Guardian judge that Wahab had a “major lead” — presumably a poll. This is a D+20 district, so not a hotbed that needed regular polling to figure out the winner in the general election. So how in the hell would pollsters know which 500 or 750 voters to sample, and whether to trust that they’re going to actually turn out? Still, the Guardian reports the outcome versus expectations by using polling as the expectation, as if it were some kind of fact rather than a sample in time.

Josh Marshall has recently written a couple of good pieces on polling. One piece is about the Republican pollster Patrick Ruffini’s post detailing how Senate polling has a Democratic bias which is larger in earlier polls but still exists in later polls. Here’s Marshall’s guess why:

❝

[…] My best guess is differential response: more social trust-oriented and engaged voters respond to polls more. And demographically those tend to be Democrats. It’s not an overwhelming difference but enough to show up as a small but at least broadly predictable bias. There’s also another more mundane explanation of the growing accuracy in the final months of the campaign. In the early months of a campaign, pollsters tend to poll “adults” or “registered voters.” They apply “likely voter” screens more aggressively in the final months and weeks as the contours of the electorate (who is going to vote) becomes more clear. You’d expect them to get more accurate, if we judge accuracy as the result on Election Day. Historically, “likely voter” filters favor Republicans, though that’s become less the case over the last decade as coalitions have shifted. This year, it seems to be the opposite.

TPM (gift link)

I agree with the first part of this assessment — MAGA is a movement that considers polling part of the “fake news” ecosystem. The second part is true, but also points out how problematic the whole polling enterprise is.

Marshall’s second piece is an overall take on polling, and here’s what I think is a gift link to let you read the whole thing.

My fundamental take is that polls are an insight into the race that shouldn’t be trusted or used as a solid prediction, but if your candidate is polling over 50%, that’s a good sign. Also, issue polling showing 60/40 or better is worth a solid look. Other than that, they’re not to be taken as seriously as they often are, including by idiots like Trump (when they’re in his favor).

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

Today's Bad Faith Times by Denny Carter is all about polling. Intro:

"I don’t remember the last time polling left me quite so disoriented.

To see progressive congressional candidates tapping into a boiling well of voter fury and shocking establishment Democratic Party candidates week after week ahead of the 2026 midterms, and then to pore over numbers saying Democratic voters are neither ready nor willing to take extreme democracy-saving measures makes no sense. And it fills me with dread that this moment of anti-fascist resurgence – call it Woke 2.0 if you’d like – will be for naught, just like its ultimately tragic predecessor."

https://badfaithtimes.com/the-numbers-say-democrats-arent-ready-to-play-hardball/

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

"...Two-thirds of Democratic respondents to a Marquette University poll from June said the Court's majority is motivated primarily by politics (64 percent of Republicans said the law was the Court's main motivation). So two in three Democratic Party backers see the land's highest court as a deeply compromised political actor – you might just call it a captured institution – but aren't willing to do the only thing there is to do to fix the problem.

Someone – hopefully many someones – in national Democratic politics is going to have to level with the party's supporters and tell them nothing is possible without first undoing Republicans' death grip on the Supreme Court. Why can't we have nice things, they might ask. Because John Roberts is in charge. That's the answer today and that will be the answer tomorrow unless Roberts' supermajority is decimated."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago(edited)

Breaking news:

"The Supreme Court has temporarily allowed President Donald Trump to continue working on a massive new ballroom at the White House, freezing a court ruling that would have required construction to stop at midnight Friday."

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/news/supreme-court-temporarily-allows-construction-of-white-house-ballroom-to-continue/ar-AA2aFDl1

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

Maybe Natalie phoned John Roberts

Avatar

tam1MI 3 months ago

if your candidate is polling over 50%, that’s a good sign.

I would peg 55% or above as the safe zone. 50-51% is just too close to the margin of error, and Republicans have a tendency to overperform their polls.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 months ago

Yep, good point. Francesca Hong never broke the mid-40s, which wasn't a good sign for her.

Avatar

John S.3 months ago

The mainstream press can’t be bothered to reflect reality, so why should polls?

Avatar

tam1MI 3 months ago

So, here in Michigan, Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers has unveiled a group he calls "Democrats for Rogers". And the "Democratic Party" politician helping him kick off the group is.... not a Democrat. It's the odious ex-Democrat turned Trumper Karen Whitsett, who loudly left the party, only the stupid media refuses to note that fact in any article they write with her in it, still identifying her as a "D". This was the only elected "Democrat" Rogers could find to publicly sign on to his fake "grassroots" group...

https://michiganadvance.com/2026/08/20/mike-rogers-touts-democratic-defectors-as-he-seeks-to-exploit-divisions-over-abdul-el-sayed/

Avatar
Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 months ago

Censure isn't a free speech violation, and hydroxychloroquine doesn't cure COVID. What a maroon.

Avatar
Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago(edited)

""I absolutely cannot take the flu shot," she said, explaining that she has chronic Lyme Disease. "And there are people who will literally lose their jobs if they do not take the flu shot. And I just think that has to be a personal choice. So it started with things like that."

As a long Lyme victim myself, I can confidently say that flu shots have nothing but advantages for Lyme patients and this woman is just another loony religious nut under the spell of Donorrhea's MAHA regime, except even stupider.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

She's prolly getting rubles from somewhere.

Avatar

Scott H3 months ago

Yeah, her performance theater has been making the rounds in a lot of places.

And yeah, it's always headlined as her being a Dem in order to shove the "Dems in Disarray" narrative.

Heh heh, sure, people like me help that narrative given our criticism of the party and the center-right/abundo clowns that run it.

Avatar

Pacem Appellant3 months ago

This race is next door to me. And Wahab is my state senator (I don't draw the lines). November is going to be tougher for Wahab because CA-14 is being redrawn and Hernandez has advantages in the redrawn district. I need to get in touch with the Wahab campaign and find out what the strategy is going to be in the general.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 months ago

Redistricting (which I'm for, in CA, don't get me wrong) also makes those districts harder to poll.

Avatar

Pacem Appellant3 months ago

I agree that the redistricting is necessary to counterbalance the SCOTUS's gutting of the VRA. What we do know is that this particular redrawn map drops San Leandro and adds in Dublin. Hernandez has some political support in Dublin, as she's the former mayor.

Avatar

Butch Fries3 months ago

Aside from my problems with polling in general, one issue is that the legacy media treat every major poll as some kind of earth-shattering breaking news when it comes out.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 months ago

It’s an easy story to write and it gets clicks so that’s all it takes in our current media environment.

Avatar

Ken In MN3 months ago

My favorite new compare and contrast is that "polling" had Hong up 20 points in WI and she ended up losing a squeaker, while "reputable" polls had Angie Craig up 2% vs. Peggy Flannagan next door in MN, only to see Flannagan CRUSHING the AIPAC/Crypto/AI-owned Craig by 20 points. For what it's worth, early polls had Flannagan up by double digits before special interests deployed their money cannon into the race to support Craig. And just like Crypto and AI companies do with investor money, they literally set millions of dollars on fire, only to get destroyed...

Avatar

Kay W.3 months ago

True. The most “reputable” MI poll had Haley Stevens up 7.

Avatar

tam1MI 3 months ago

I have gotten to the point where I ignore what the polls are saying, and instead on what the candidates political campaigns are doing. Haley Stevens campaign wasn't acting like they were sitting on a healthy lead, at every step of the way their campaign acted like they were locked in a close and hard-fought battle for the nomination. I have a feeling that their own internal polls were telling them something quite different from the ones that the public were allowed to see.