I guess this is my version of Joe’s post about the private equity vultures who took over the youth hockey league. This one involves camping.

I have a political point, but first, some background: There’s a service called Harvest Hosts which basically connects people with RVs with places that would like to host them for free if they buy something from the place. Hosts include vineyards, farms, golf courses, etc. Those places sign up to host, and RVers sign up for Harvest Hosts for around $80/year. The app lets RVers find and communicate with the hosts. Harvest Hosts suggests that you spend at least $30 at the host, and they do some minor vetting of the RVers, too.

There’s more to the Harvest Host platform, but this is the basic service. It’s fairly popular among RVers, van lifers, and skoolie folks (people traveling in a converted school bus) who travel a lot. We subscribed for a while but found we didn’t use it enough to make it worth the subscription. They had another service called “Boondockers Welcome” that connected people who would let others park at their house for a night with campers. The one couple we met who encouraged us to look them up on Boondockers Welcome seemed insane, so we never used that.

At some point, Harvest Hosts was acquired by private equity (or maybe they were a PE play all along). In 2024, Harvest Hosts acquired Escapees, a RV club that plays a significant role in a lot of full-time RVer’s lives. They host events and have a mail forwarding service for full-timers (people with no fixed address). They also have a branch called Xcapees for Gen X RVers, which hosts events and also caters to the full-timers who work remotely. We met a couple who were very active in Escapees a couple of years ago, and the wife had a lot of good things to say about the organization.

Soon after Harvest Hosts acquired Escapees, the complaints came fast and furious. This reddit thread has gripes from Escapees members who say that Escapees is slowly bleeding staff and cancelling events.

A few days ago, Harvest Hosts was acquired by Choice Hotels. Choice, which owns the Quality and Comfort Inn brands among others, is a mediocre hotel chain — they’re my last “choice” chain if I need a hotel. I have no idea why a hotel chain would buy a company that is all about RVers. The kind of people who use Harvest Hosts, Boondockers Welcome and Escapees do it to avoid checking in to a hotel. Even if Choice offered them great rates, the rigs that most of these people own are too big to park in a crowded hotel parking lot. “Synergy,” the justification for a lot of acquisitions, is completely absent here. It’s probably anti-synergy: whatever a hotelier does to encourage use of their RV service will be limited by their desire to sell these folks something they don’t want, a night at a hotel.

There’s a lot of talk of how capitalism “builds” things — this acquisition does the opposite. It will destroy Escapees, a useful club that’s been around for decades, providing a valuable service to people who often don’t have a lot of money to spare. (A lot of full-timers mis-judge their retirements and end up hurting.) Harvest Hosts and Boondockers Welcome — which were always “nice to haves” not “must haves” — will probably also wither on the vine. The $130 million that Choice paid for this amalgamation of camping-related companies will end up with fire sales of Escapees and Harvest Hosts in a few years, at best, and closing of those properties, at worst.

I assume that some other RV club will be formed to take over the spot that Escapees had in the market, just as Escapees took the place of the Good Sam Club (still exists, not as popular as Escapees).

The problem here is that there’s so much dumb money floating around, and so few consequences for making a bad acquisition, that consumers are subject to a constant churn of once-decent services enshittifying themselves for the short-term benefit of some grifter who finds a way to make a quick buck. I don’t think there’s an easy political solution to this problem, but I’d be very interested in seeing a deep forensic audit of the claims that Harvest Hosts made about the acquisition, and I’d also like to see a limit to what Choice Hotels can write off when this acquisition inevitably fails. Our lack of real regulation allows this kind of nonsense to occur far too often.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Kay W.1 month ago

What about Hipcamp? Will they ruin that too? We’re going tent camping at a state park this weekend for our anniversary - my idea! My husband is surreptitiously checking nice hotels in the area. 😂 I worked at several rural post offices and people we called “travelers” or rvers” ”would use general delivery to get mail. So they’d tell us and we’d hold it for them to pick up when they next came thru. They could just call and tell me and I’d expect their name to come thru with general delivery and our zip code. This was a long time ago when “travelers” were a smaller group but they were always such nice people. I feel like I’m ancient when recounting these tales of our formerly civilized society.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 month ago

Hipcamp isn't part of this acquisition. Never used them, I'll be interested to hear your experience. Hope your anniversary trip works out!

Avatar

Scott H1 month ago

Hipcamp is still owned by it's founder:

https://www.createcultivate.com/blog/find-new-roads-alyssa-ravasio-create-cultivate-100

I know several folks who both use it and own property they list on it.

Avatar

Suburban Mom1 month ago

I can't make a case for PE improving anything. I can tell you that many companies try to enter a new market segment (in this case, RVers) that they perceive as a threat to their existing core business (cheap hotels), especially if they believe they can create efficiencies of scale with the new entity . They might also acquire a business to get hands on up-to-date expertise or systems without building their own. Also, sometimes a business will acquire a competitor specifically to kill it. It is the capitalist way.

Avatar

C P1 month ago

"You see, Mister Valiant, I bought the Red Car so I could dismantle it!"

Avatar

Kay W.1 month ago

Interesting. I bet it’s true in this case that motels get into it as a way to get ahead of a competing market.

Avatar

Scott H1 month ago

Example # Infinity of the rhetorical question

Name one thing PE has ever made better?

Well, other than the enrichment of the rich.

Avatar

r po1 month ago

We probably stayed in Choice "Hotels" places about 25 times from 2010-2022. Basically a mediocre experience but with a quality floor; it never got too bad. Which is fine. If the room is functional, and it's quiet, the parking lot is well lit, ok. The big advantage they had was they had a lot of inventory in the places we went, and their rewards were pretty generous. We probably got 5 free "decent" rooms.

As always, what quality there was steadily eroded and we stopped using them. I have no clue what benefits they would have to offer to RVers. The political point is that this was a useful Capitalist provided "service" that fully eroded over 15 years. We've got nothing to replace it; we're back to where we were. The idea of Capitalist Market Competition is you let a bunch of companies compete to provide useful services and in the end everyone is better off. In practice, the purpose of a useful service is to be acquired, and then bled dry of its operating capital.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 month ago

Speaking of enshittified...

"Trump's AI obsession: US president quizzed Grok for hours before deciding to raid Venezuela - ...during a December meeting in the Oval Office with Musk. During that visit, Trump reportedly spent hours firing questions at Grok about his presidency and what kind of legacy he'd leave behind. ...Trump turned to Grok with a specific question: how would Venezuelans respond if the U.S. captured Maduro? According to the official who witnessed the exchange, Grok's response was that Maduro, described as a repressive and widely disliked dictator, would likely see his downfall celebrated by many Venezuelans."

https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/other/trump-s-ai-obsession-us-president-quizzed-grok-for-hours-before-deciding-to-raid-venezuela/ar-AA2dob0j

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 month ago

What a combo:

Grok AND Natalie Harp!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 month ago

Another need for real regulation.

HuffPo: "Pay-For-Play Part 2: Trump Plans Another Controversial Crypto Dinner - Two Trump Organization affiliates are promoting yet another contest for investors in the president’s meme coin to score an invitation to the most “exclusive dinner in the world.”

The top 185 holders of the $TRUMP meme coin will be invited to “an evening with 3 Legends and President Donald J. Trump” at his private club in Washington, D.C., on Nov. 22."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 month ago

Hopefully, a new club can do away with using any middleman apps and just host a good website with bulletin board type messaging for members.

Apps suck, every time I get around without using an app I have a better experience. Cabin rental in Maine, for instance, accomplished by magazine classified ad & email to owner, was wonderful and low cost.

Just like private health insurance, the private equity vampire squids need to go.

Avatar

C P1 month ago

Yeah, one of my pet themes since the Great Recession days is that capitalism increasingly doesn't even build things, because capitalism doesn't even care if the company succeeds or fails. Which is a way in which it's even worse than Gilded Age capitalism. Say what you want about Old Man Rockefeller, his business model was not "bankrupt Standard Oil so you can go through its pockets for loose change."

Avatar

Busted Knee1 month ago

One of the things with AI is a lot of them went all in on it because their hyper growth had stopped. For the legacy tech companies (Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Apple) this doesn't matter as they have locked monopolies. For newer companies like Meta it's a disaster. For nvidia who's selling shovels and jeans to a gold rush it was the only way to go. They'd already monopolized computer gaming and professional graphics along with scientific GPU compute. So we're all stuck with number must go up stock craze as a result.

Avatar

Ken In MN1 month ago

Oh, there most definitely is a political solution to this problem: Require Private Equity to be liable for the debts taken out in the name of the company whose assets they aim to strip.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 month ago(edited)

Yes, make it so they can't borrow against the business they are acquiring, cannot saddle it with debt and cannot destroy it. And the C suites do not get a pay day just for acquisitions going through.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 month ago(edited)

All good points!

Avatar

Scott H1 month ago

Private equity has become a cancer on capitalism. Most of its strategies should be illegal and most once were.

Avatar

C P1 month ago

Yeah. Is this what people mean by "finance capitalism?" Cause I gotta say, I know this feeling has sometimes come with unfortunate implications, but it really does seem like today's finance is a plague on the real economy. And for once I don't even mean that in a left/liberal kind of way. I mean that in a "y'know, the people in charge of a company are supposed to care whether it does well or not. And the company's supposed to actually make a product or service that's useful to its audience."

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 month ago

Hadn't heard "finance capitalism" before but it fits.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 month ago

This. Plus, remove the tax deductibility of the debt a PE firm takes on in the purchase of the business