Today, Speaker of the non-House Mike Johnson was ask about SNAP benefits not being paid out by the federal gov’t.

His answer, of course, was a blatant lie. Yet not one “journalist” asked the easiest and most obvious follow up question, so I’ll phrase it for them.

“Mr. Speaker. That’s just not true. How do you square your purported Christian beliefs with your constant lying?”

At the same press conference, Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins was asked essentially the same question:

Again, no pushback on a blatant lie (not only a blatant lie, but a nonsensical one as well (why would you need contingency funds if the program is already funded?)

As a former candidate for office, nothing frustrated me more than reporters/journalists who a) didn’t do their job by holding power to account with critical questions (including of me as a candidate) and b) unbelievably, were not aware of their protections under the 1st Amendment and why they existed (sadly, more often true than not).

People reading this are by definition more informed than the vast majority of U.S. citizens. It’s the vast politically ignorant masses (sounds elitist, but, again, empirically true based on my 1st person experience) who our current media are shortchanging and, yes, to whom they are doing political injustice.

There’s an old saying that “You don’t pick a fight with someone who buys ink by the barrel.” Nonetheless, I spend a fair amount of time contacting my local and regional media trying to help them understand the importance of holding power to account and the reason they have 1A protections.

My conclusion: we need to do everything we can to support independent news media and to help create, as I alluded to in my post from the other day, a sustainable media ecosystem supportive of progressive policy/people with the ability to reach a broad swath of the public.

A tall order, sure, but as Ben Franklin, said at the close of the Constitutional Convention of 1787 when asked what form of gov’t they had devised, a monarchy or a republic, “A republic, if you can keep it.”

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Knowing not just how bad the media is but how bad it's been for almost all of our history honestly makes me wonder if freedom of the press is something that needs, at the very least, redefinition.

I mean, obviously it's bad for a government to be able to simply determine what reality its people are allowed to see, but if the alternative is simply that the ten or twenty richest people in the country are allowed to simply determine what reality the people are allowed to see, which is de facto how news works, then what even is the point? Nobody even voted for those assholes.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

The Founders obviously never foresaw the modern media environment much less modern propaganda techniques.

Of course much of this goes back to Reagan and the start of deregulating and allowing media to become monopolized. Take all that away, and while we'd still be dealing with the impacts of propaganda and social media, we wouldn't have defacto, corporate propaganda machines operating 24/7/365.

Goebbels would love this.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

That's true, but the media being the mouthpiece of whatever rich guy bought it was also pretty much reality throughout the nineteenth century, and early twentieth. Reagan's deregulation was unfortunately kind of a reversion to the mean; the era in which media even remotely approached professionalism was pretty short, largely fifties through eighties. That's what makes me really start to wonder.

Avatar

Melancholy Jaques1 year ago

It is important to recognize and accept that the media companies and employees do not regard this or any of the similar behavior as failure, mistake, or something to be. changed. On the rare occasions that these things are brought up to the editors or reporters, the behaviors are defended and the people questioning them are attacked or ignored.

Something needs to be done, for sure, but continuing to expect the media or the employees to change is a waste of time.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Epic is a good descriptor.

"A scoop that I’m not happy to report:

CBS News has gutted its climate change reporting team, one of the best in the business, and one of the only ones on cable news that consistently called out fossil fuels as the main source of climate pollution."

https://bsky.app/profile/emorwee.bsky.social/post/3m4itfzghy226

Thanks for nothing David Ellison. Welp, at least we still have Senator Sheldon Whitehouse. And a lot of other fantastic independent people who will report the truth.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Were they all black or brown? Weiss apparently fired anyone with darker skin.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Important update from Cake authored by Marc Elias

https://bsky.app/profile/thebandcake.bsky.social/post/3m4j2agnyk22y

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

There is simply not enough space here for me to say everything I'd like to say about this phenom.

I appreciate your efforts is gonna hafta suffice today!

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

This happens daily. One or another of the Trump liars said no US citizen has been attacked and detained by ICE. Blatant lie. At least 170 citizens are documented to have been picked up by the moronic, violent ICE brutes.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

The latest Josh Marshall podcast had a long discussion of why Isaac Chotiner at the New Yorker is one of the few reporters who makes politicians look bad. The reason is that he will stick to a question and ask it over and over (while noting lies or weak points) rather than asking a question and moving on. Kate Riga added that the WH press would never coordinate and do follow ups — they all had to ask “their own” question. The whole institution has devolved so badly that they can’t deal with liars, and they can’t deal with politicians who filibuster answers…

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Ego and careerism to the detriment of the profession and institution as a whole. Also has happened in the justice system. I am just so, so sick of the “cleverness” - the slick, patronizing tone and snark. The social media they used to promote their own careers ruined them. They can’t perform the basic functions of the job, but they compose a great Tweet!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

"Your mom!"

🤬🖕🤡

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

I knew one of you was going to post about this when I saw the clip of Dana Bash just take notes for MAGA Mike. It’s infuriating.

I honestly don’t see how society survives an environment where lies are not just allowed to flourish, but are actively promoted and repeated by so-called “journalists”. I’ll take liberties with a modern aphorism.

If a liar sits down at a table with 10 journalists and begins having a conversation, you have a table with 11 liars.