❝

With just over a year until midterms, one of America’s two main parties is hemorrhaging voters, losing registered voters in all 30 states that track registration by political party. The change has been observed in blue, red, and swing states alike.

In total, some 2.1 million voters ditched the Democrats in favor of alternative politics between 2020 and 2024, The New York Times reported Wednesday. The drop has resulted in more registered independents, but it has also become a boon for the GOP, which gained 2.4 million new voters over the same period.

[…]

The most contentious battleground states have also experienced the liberal erosion. Arizona, Nevada, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania all saw support peel away from Democrats over the last four years.

“In North Carolina, Republicans erased roughly 95 percent of the registration advantage that Democrats held in the fall of 2020, according to state records as of this summer,” reported the Times. “In Nevada, Democrats suffered the steepest percentage-point plunge of any state but West Virginia between 2020 and 2024.”

This is just bad news, period. BooMan at Progress Pond has at least a partial explanation:

❝

The Democratic Party has lost so much ground in voter registration that it has a genuine crisis. But that crisis is compounded by a greater one. The party can no longer do non-partisan registration in a cost-effective way. As an old ACORN hand, I can help explain this a little bit.

When I worked at ACORN it really was funded by George Soros through Project Vote. He wanted to help the Democrats win elections and knew that nonpartisan voter registration would help. Project Vote could not legally run a registration program that was aligned with Democrats, and they had to turn in all registration forms regardless of which party the new voter registered with. But Soros’ investment still made sense.

In fact, it was my job to make it work. I analyzed precinct data and found precincts where the Democrats had won at least 65 percent of the vote in the prior election. Anything less than 65 percent wasn’t considered cost-effective. Think about it. If I pay a worker to register 10 voters and only six of them turn out to be Democrats, then I’ve only netted two votes. In a bad sample, I might have even cost the Democrats two votes or made no difference at all.

As you might expect, the places where Democrats win by 65 percent or more usually have large Black and Latino populations. The only strongly Democratic precincts that lack big minority populations are found in college towns. So, my job was basically to run non-partisan voter registration drives in Black and Latino neighborhoods. We didn’t ask how people would vote or tell them which party to register with, but we reliably got a lot more Democratic registrations and the Republican ones because Black and Latino voters strongly preferred the Democrats.

[…]

The problem the Democrats have now is that their advantage with Latinos and young people has eroded to the point that these tactics won’t work. They’ve lost ground with Blacks too, but it’s still cost effective to do nonpartisan registration in many black neighborhoods.

The Democratic brand is in terrible shape. This blog exists because Democrats have been failing for years. The Schumer/Jeffries plan — 2026 will be like 2018 and we’ll win just on the strength of being not-Trump — relies on there being some fucking Democrats to vote. It’s also a plan that won’t energize potential Democratic registrants because it doesn’t stand for anything, it just stands around waiting for something to happen.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

As I think is clear, I think this Party needs to be stripped down to the studs and rebuilt. This (to me) is just more evidence of that. It's just sheer incompetence. They can't even do the grunt work anymore, and they raise BILLIONS of dollars. I mean, Christ. Where does the billions of dollars go if it doesn't go to "try not to drop 2 million voters".

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Part of the reason the "Biden senile" narrative stuck, true or not, is that the party as a whole has just been completely shell-shocked like a deer in the headlights for this entire decade.

Not during the first Trump term, interestingly enough. They were plenty fired up for that one. But it's as if 1/6 just broke their brains. The system went to a place they never thought it would, and they have no idea what to do about it.

And rightly or wrongly, the image of a senile president just letting the ship drift even as the iceberg rushes closer captured that feeling pretty well.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

I often ask myself the same question. How do you spend $1 billion to lose an election?

I just can’t rationalize that it’s only because Harris is a black woman. There has to be reasons why Democrats failed, as we often discuss here. I hope other people are noticing and discussing as well.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

They failed by saying "well, it is totally cool, everyone gets a second term" and backing Biden in running again. A lot of people should have said "Naah, bro" much sooner.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Eh. I said in 2020 that if we didn't want Biden in 2024 we shouldn't vote for him now, and I stand by that. The stark fact is, everybody does get a second term. There's no way for a president to decline to run again without it being treated as a massive admission of his first term's failure, which would irreparably hobble whoever tried to replace him. It failed both times we tried it before, and sure enough, it failed this time too. Republicans might be able to pull it off - they did it twice in the twenties, though pre-WWII politics are another world - but they can count on having the rich and the media's thumbs on the scale for them. We can't.

Does this mean it's bad and wrong for people to say that Biden's too old or shouldn't have run again - absolutely not. But if it's true, that call needed to be made four years earlier. If he's too old for a second term, he was too old for a first term.

Avatar

Busted Knee1 year ago

The problem is educated upper middle class professionals.

They are a minority. And the party exists to protect their economic status and give that minority social and cultural power over everyone below them. They work in finance, tech, consulting, legal, pharma, and all the other industries that looted the rest of the country blind. The party celebrates the wealth created by this looting.

Any attempt to do anything for those below them including unions is met with howls of "that's how racists and sexists" win from the upper middle class. They are as hostile and cruel to the working class and poor as the billionaires.

Everyone knows this now. So either the upper middle class gives up it's cultural and political power voluntarily and argues for higher taxes on itself to the level where those vacations, private music lesson for the kids, organic dinners out are all things of the past and they don't get them anymore or the lower classes are going to deliver fascism.

Avatar

Busted Knee1 year ago

The Democrats have to crush them if they want a chance. If they won't we are going to get fascism and the upper middle class will own it entirely. And the way out of it will not be something that lets the upper middle class back into power but a left wing reversal that will also crush them.

Hey hey ho ho the six figure crowd has got to go! And it will go. The question is if they voluntarily give it all up and sit silent in the corner, the fascists get them, or the left gains power and does it. But they have had power for far too long and are exactly as responsible as the billionaires for the situation we are in. They won't admit it. But if they really want to see what the problem is than they should look in the mirror.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

2020, Covid - no real campaign. 2024 Biden - no real campaign. That's how you lose a 2 million voters.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

That's a great rundown of nonpartisan registration but we can (and have) also done partisan registration as a part of canvassing in Presidential years. So one asks the voter who they support and if they support the Dem you ask "are you registered to vote...?"... We have essentially missed doing that for two cycles - there was the covid cycle (2020) and then the nonexistent Biden campaign of 2024/Harris. We've missed two cycles and 8 years.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Not good: Dotard says he's going on a ride along "on patrol" in the streets of DC tonight. The attackers will put on a big show of force for him.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Just another lie for the rubes, I should have known Dotard is afraid of the dark!

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Democrats (in their current form) are literally on the precipice of losing an entire generation. Gen Z isn’t going to vote against anything. They will only be motivated if they have something to vote for, and right now, they don’t (except for the boys in the manosphere).

If Schumer and Jeffries don’t get punted next year in favor of some fighters, either ‘26 is going to be a bloodbath for Democrats, or they limp into another midterm with the wind at their back. But failure to get blown out will only embolden the consultants and corporate institutionalists, and prolong the inevitable collapse of the party.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Or to put it another way…

If Democrats cannot beat an odious and obviously dangerous authoritarian like Trump with their message of “save democracy and vote against a tyrant”, how the fuck is that strategy going to work on far less obvious scumbags like JD Vance?

Avatar

C P1 year ago

TBF, it's not at all obvious that the "far less obvious scumbags" are harder to defeat than Trump - Trump has a way of not only firing up the base but dragging a whole bunch of otherwise apathetic folks out of the woodwork, there's a reason 2022 was such a weak showing for Republicans. It's entirely possible that if he's gone things revert to an easier playing field for Democrats.

But of course that doesn't help much if Democrats are experiencing the same weakening.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

My point being that the strategy of running against someone is far less potent with a less galvanizing figure than Trump. And frankly, I don’t really see someone emerging that tops Trump anytime in the near future…

But I’m also aware that peak wingnut is a myth, so you never know.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I still can't see how we're gonna vote our way out of fascism.

https://bsky.app/profile/georgetakei.bsky.social/post/3lwuo2qybza23

"Bring me my guillotine - the little one! For these tiny peens."

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Well the courts sure as hell aren’t going to save us. An appeals court in NY just struck down the fine imposed on Trump in his fraud case, so apparently there will never be justice where that asshole is involved.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Must be a coincidence that Ed Martin was caught stalking her at her residence IN A TRENCHCOAT.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Dotard now threatening Colorado if they don't "FREE TINA PETERS!"

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Tell him to knock it off, or we will commission another portrait of him that he will be unhappy with.

Avatar

TXG1112 1 year ago

I honestly think the only way we get out of this is if Schumer and Jeffries are primaried and replaced so new leadership can rebrand or if the Fight faction of the Democratic Party breaks off and takes the majority of Dem voters with it. In any case I’m not particularly optimistic.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

A few more Mamdani-style primary beats might help but there are too many party members who would rather have a job in the minority than fight to be in the majority.

Avatar

TXG1112 1 year ago

Yep. The obvious question is “What do we (collectively) do about this?” Would an external org that funded primary opponents against do-nothing Dems help or hurt? The next election is basically existential for our Democracy and we don’t really have any runway after that. I think comparing Newsom and Cuomo is useful to understand what we’re up against. Newson is a sleazy asshole, but is still at his core a Democrat and plans to go down fighting. Cuomo is just a sleazy asshole who is willing to go down on anyone who can help him get back into power. He is useful to corporations because he stands for nothing and can be bought relatively cheaply and is willing to muddy the waters out of vicious self interest. The concern is that intra party fighting just helps Republicans

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Honestly, I would take some Democrats that act like Democrats in the light blue states and are not all about reaching across the aisle to their sane coworkers that do not seem to exist anymore.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

You've just described Crow. He spent 30 minutes blathering that crap to Heather Cox Richardson:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t0Jlg5fG5w8

Thing is, everybody around you and me who are self-professed progressives lap up that shit.