Jean Shaheen joins Tina Smith in the list of Democratic Senators from relatively safe seats that aren’t running in 2026. Shaheen voted to confirm roughly half of Trump’s appointees, putting her in the group of the top 5 Democrats who have voted for Trump nominees. She isn’t on Josh Marshall’s tally of Senators’ positions the CR. Smith, who only voted for two Trump appointees, has not committed to a position per Josh’s tally.

I get that it’s an uncomfortable time to be an elected Democrat. Rank and file Dems are mad, and there’s a lot of talk of primarying Dems. Hakeem Jeffries was able to hold his party together, almost, to vote en bloc against the CR (Jared Golden being the exception). Most of what we’re seeing from the Senate is the sounds of silence. (When even fairly even-keeled Norm Ornstein pushing you to do something, you’re really not doing anything.)

I guess AOC is now the Senate Whip, because she’s urging Democrats to call their Senators and tell them to vote no on cloture and no on the bill. (The “clever” move would be to vote yes for cloture, knowing there are enough votes for the bill to pass, and then no on the bill. That’s if you want to be the Democratic Susan Collins.)

If this is all too much for any elected Democrat, they are welcome, invited and encouraged to quit, and quit now, as far as I’m concerned. As long as their state has a provision that the interim appointee be of the same party, or a quick special election provision, why not replace someone who’s afraid to do the job with someone who might just take a “hard” vote or two? Perhaps that person wouldn’t have as many idiot consultants whispering in their ear, telling them that a stupid justification like the one Jared Golden puked out yesterday will make a difference. Golden actually had the gall to say that “elections have consequences". If that’s the case, why didn’t his constituents just vote for a Republican instead? They would have gotten the same “consequence” — a vote for a poison pill CR. (Note that Golden took that vote after it was announced that the USDA was holding funding for the University of Maine pending an almost certainly spurious Title IX review.)

And I’m not forgetting the Republicans, cowards to the last one. Jamelle Bouie makes a great point about them (and some Dems, I’m sure):

So I guess what I’m left with is disgust aimed everywhere. I don’t know if it’s more worthwhile to call your Senator or just get out and protest at a Tesla dealership. At least the latter is probably going to do something to harm our unelected King. (This is a funny website if you need a chuckle.)

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

AOC apparently sent out emails with a button for people to call their Senators and not a donation button. It looks like someone knows how to communicate well with their constituents in a way that perceives them as something other than bags of money.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Ironic that she is whipping Senate votes. Possibly in the opposite direction of Chuck Schumer (depending on which account you can believe about what’s happening behind closed doors).

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Chuck just announced that he didn't have the votes to support the CR and his caucus is united around a clean CR through April 11. Good.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Presumably they are coalescing around Patty Murray’s clean CR. Good! Chuck should take notes. That’s what real leadership looks like.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

The retirements are kind of alarming too - maybe they are just giving up.

Avatar

Run Goose1 year ago

It gives the impression that they're about to make some incredibly base-enraging votes and don't have it in them for a primary anymore.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

And the thing about slagging on Republicans is… what’s the point?

It’s one thing if you are a constituent of theirs and want to let them know how pissed off you are. That should go for any elected official, regardless of their party affiliation.

But outside of that, Republicans don’t care what Democrats think (they don’t even care about the Republicans who voted for them). So all this hand wringing online about random people not being sufficiently angry at Republicans and only focusing on Democrats is quite pointless and silly. We have no leverage.

They don’t give a shit what any of us want, and it won’t matter how much we rail against them. We vote for Democrats, and that’s who is supposed to be listening to our concerns.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

A reader sent me this

https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-has-wanted-the-government-shut-down/

It posits that Musk wants the shut down so he can permanently fire more people, if true than D senators would be strategically voting for the CR.

I have no idea - read it and see if you find it persuasive.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Not persuasive.

Josh Marshall tackled that and other reasons to vote for the CR this morning, and ultimately concludes it doesn’t make sense. I find his rationale to be far more persuasive for voting no on the CR.

https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/here-are-the-arguments-for-why-senate-ds-should-vote-yes-and-why-theyre-wrong

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

If Dems were making this point publicly then maybe I'd buy it. But they're not. On BlueSky a Hill reporter says that Schumer is whipping for votes for the CR with the plan to vote for cloture, put up amendments that will fail, and then vote against the CR, which is too cute by half.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

If Democrats had better political instincts, they would let a couple actually vulnerable senators vote for the CR while everyone else votes it down. The trouble is that “vibes” seem to be trumping reality yet again.

Sen. Gallego just got elected to a 6 year term. He’s pretty damn safe, but you wouldn’t know that from how he’s been voting. Sen. Schiff can’t make a strong stand against the CR? He also just got elected, and in fucking CA no less. Ditto for one of my own, Sen. Cantwell who just got re-elected in super blue WA.

Yet all of these people are running scared, and the silence from the rest of them is deafening with very few exceptions.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I'm losing faith in Democrats too. Maybe as Bouie says they just don't care that much. I'm still doing my thing locally - events, meetings, etc. But IMO this Party is on life support. The only energy I see is with groups outside the Party - Indivisible, Moveon, the Tesla protestors, the protesters in support of the student who was picked up and disappeared...

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

They pretended to care while fundraising!

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Yeah, I think that's the rub.

As I said a few times in the Biden years: you can't just go back to your constituents with your hair on fire every two years screaming that the world will literally end if the other side is elected, and then as soon as you're in office, act like everything's normal, the other side are just patriotic nice guys that just happen to have a couple of honest disagreements with you, and your fondest wish is to be best buddies with them again. It works in the short run, but only in the short run. Eventually, people are going to conclude that you're either lying about the other side being an existential danger, or you don't care, and in neither case are you a person to be taken seriously.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Even if something resembling the regular cycle of elections continues to exist, I'm at the point where I can very much see 2028 being a 1984 or 1972 style landslide, or as close to one as is possible today, for the Republicans.

These things don't just happen when one side is popular, they happen when the other side's lost all credibility for everyone but the partisan base that never misses an election. There was no shortage of Americans who hated FDR's guts in the thirties and forties or Reagan's in the eighties; it's just that the Republican brand in the first case and the Democratic one in the second had become so utterly toxic that even the haters wouldn't touch it.