I called this a couple of months ago, and it’s not because I’m some kind of political genius:

❝

WASHINGTON — U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett withdrew from the race to become the top Democrat on the powerful House Oversight Committee, marking the Dallas Democrat’s second defeat in her attempt to climb the ranks of congressional leadership.

Crockett confirmed her decision to bow out of the race in a text to The Texas Tribune early Tuesday.

House Democrats picked Rep. Robert Garcia as their ranking member on the 47-person panel later Tuesday morning. The California Democrat defeated his remaining rival in the race, Rep. Stephen Lynch, after winning the support of the House Democratic Steering and Policy Committee.

Lynch is a ginormous asshole, so even though the venerated seniority system would make him next in line, it’s not super-surprising that he didn’t get the job. I like Garcia quite a bit, but I’ll note that he has exactly the same seniority as Crockett (both are in their second terms). So why him instead of her?

I think the reason is something similar to the Wickler vs Martin contest at the DNC: Wickler was the fan favorite, but Martin was pretty good and probably more malleable. So we get Martin, who’s shitting the bed.

The sad fact is that my trust in Democratic leadership has fallen so low that Garcia is immediately suspect since he was elevated over Crockett. Garcia is in the California delegation, which makes me think that Pelosi had a hand in it, since I think she’s still wielding a lot of power behind the scenes. She actively lobbied against AOC heading oversight, and instead Gerry Connolly was elevated to the post and held it until he died of throat cancer. Connolly’s appointment was sort of a reductio ad absurdum of the seniority system, so leadership had to do something. To me, Garcia’s appointment says, “See, you wanted us to ignore seniority and elevate youth, so here’s a young, new member.” No, we wanted AOC, and if we couldn’t have AOC, Jasmine Crockett would be great. Garcia is third choice at best.

Jasmine Crockett makes some mistakes. She might rub some people the wrong way. But we all know that she has what it takes, I’ll call it a rebel heart, you call it whatever you want. AOC has it. Maxwell Frost has it. When Kat Abugazaleh flips off protesters at a drag queen story hour, she shows that she has it. And it’s not tolerated.

By the way, Rebel Heart is a reference to this song by First Aid Kit, two young sisters from Sweden who sound like they grew up in Tennessee singing country music. One of their songs is called Emmylou — it’s about Emmylou Harris and Graham Parson’s relationship. When they were 25 and 22, they sang it for Emmylou Harris and left her in tears. Open thread.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

This mullet man is going after Gillibrand. Gillibrand was fanning the flames of Islamophobia about Mamdani.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MWPwWqvcUX4

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Crap! We just lost Bill Moyers.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I posted about nominating Kathy Griffin as our female Rogan mostly in jest the other day. But now watching her comeback and new YouTube shows has become my guilty summer pleasure when it's too hot to go outside. Her new one is great:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=btr3ItGcboU

You have to get through the first moments before it makes sense.

SALON

Avatar

Paul W.1 year ago

2nd all of that. Immediate distrust of any softies getting through the current leadership gauntlet, so really pleased that AOC is building her power base both locally and nationally right now. Pelosi can only exert her influence for so long, and I am hoping that it seriously wanes after the primary season gives voters a chance to speak next year.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Garcia's a tool of a different kind, I don't share your liking of him by a loooooong shot.

Too bad he got the job. But it's yet another sign of who controls the Party and direction and it ain't us.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I've seen him talk a few times and I put him in the "fighter" column, so that's why I like him. No deeper reason than that.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Another good word is cojones.

Avatar

TXG1112 1 year ago

The Democratic Party as an institution must be destroyed. Their brand is in the shitter because they stand for nothing other than collecting money from donors so they can pay consultants to get reelected. I think even moderate “centrists” are starting to understand how useless the Democratic leadership is.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

It says so much that the Simpsons episode where the RNC banners read "we want what's worst for everyone" and "we're just plain evil" while the DNC banners read "we hate life and ourselves" and "we can't govern" aired in 1994, and yet those pictures are just as bitingly spot-on in 2024 as they were thirty years ago.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Oliver Willis' is right that the party still acts like it's 1984, the year Mondale lost, big. They were deep in the grip of triangulation and the defensive crouch in 1994, and it hasn't changed much.

Avatar

TXG1112 1 year ago

This was a big part of the reason I didn’t vote for Bill Clinton in ‘92 or ‘96. I was a dumb college libertarian and voted for Perot, but even then I realized that Democrats were a bunch of phonies.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Thanks - I had forgotten about that -still very funny. They don't hate themselves though - they hate their base. Crockett is too popular with the base so they can't promote her. These are the people who are so terrified of young liberals they endorsed Andrew Cuomo. They hate their base but they especially hate their YOUNG base.

Avatar

Busted Knee1 year ago

The purpose of the Democratic party is to protect educated professionals with six figure incomes who work in the predatory industries that looted and impoverished the rest of the nation and cannot survive without sucking the blood out of everything. Legal, consulting, tech, finance, media, pharma. Those industries and those workers. Breaking up the big banks won't solve racism (HRC), Michelle Obama giving speeches to Deloitte partners, Goldman Sachs being the corporate partner of the Human Rights Campaign.

Social liberalism has come about by allowing the top 20% and these vile industries to bleed the rest of the nation dry while they pat themselves of the back about how socially liberal they are and their zip codes incomes.

The problem is the mask has now slipped from liberalism and everyone but that top 20% sees it for what it is. Liberalism is not coming back. What's next who knows. But all of that stuff is going away.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

This YouTube video on private equity is right up your alley, even though it is long.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRUnsBcHk3E

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Moxie is another good word.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Also a soda. There was a little sandwich place in Rochester (Open Face) that sold Moxie and had a bunch of Moxie advertising art on the walls.