Mrs. Wypoxic loves classical music (I’m more of a Grateful Dead guy myself 😬). So yesterday evening, we went to see an outdoor symphony performance of patriotic American songs celebrating the 4th.

Yesterday’s Patriotic Symphony Somewhere in the Inter-Mountain West

As the Color Guard of elderly veterans marched out for the National Anthem, and the symphony began to play, it got me thinking about what America means. What defines true American patriotism.

Side Note Hot Take: America the Beautiful would be a much better National Anthem than the Star Spangled Banner.

In essence, what do I think about when I stand for the national anthem to “honor America”?

Allow me to turn that question around and start with what I don’t think about. I don’t think about people. I don’t think about white people. Or brown people. Or any other people of color. I don’t think about religion. I don’t think about Christians. Or Jews. Or Muslims. Or any other of the thousands of religions on planet earth.

As I stand and look around me, my thoughts reflexively got to two ideas: opportunity and, yes, freedom. I’m thankful that I grew up in a country that allowed me the opportunity to choose the life I wanted. To work hard towards goals I desire to achieve.

But opportunity becomes problematic without freedom. Freedom to think and say what I want. Freedom to live the lifestyle I choose. Freedom to associate with the people I want to associate with. Freedom to choose my religion, or no religion at all. Freedom to pursue “life, liberty and happiness”. All free from government interference or “guidance”

Disclaimer: Let me be very clear. I understand that our country was founded with the original sins of native conquest and slavery and that we have never truly rid ourselves of those twin scourges. I understand that we have never lived up to the founding ideals. I understand that certain “classes” of people are still strongly discriminated against - simply for the color of their skin, their gender identification, their culture. I understand that, as a white male, I had a head start and certain privileges that others in our country don’t. We are human and therefore imperfect in so many ways. We are not a “perfect union” and never will be. But we should never stop striving towards that goal. It’s why I chose to run for federal office in deep red territory. It’s why I still strive to this day.

Yet - America has historically succeeded because on balance we have continued to strive - and make progress (but not necessarily linearly) to those ideals. That striving led to a period when America was the envy of most of the world. Not because we were white or Protestant or male-dominated; because we stood for opportunity and freedom.

Opportunity + Freedom = America.

Neither of those values are associated with, or have anything to do with, blood and soil. Nor with skin color, religion or ethnicity. These are the things that never enter my mind while standing during the National Anthem.

Because opportunity and freedom know no color or race or religion or gender.

Believing that somehow - because one’s ancestors came here earlier than others - one’s citizenship status is higher than other more recent immigrants turned citizens is perhaps the most un-American view one could possibly hold based on the ideas and ideals that form the foundation of our country.

Take Vice President JD Vance for instance (formerly James Donald Hamel formerly James Donald Bowman). I’ll let Greg Sargent point out Vance’s views:

“Indeed, in delivering these lines, Obama likely had in mind not just Trump but also recent claims from JD Vance. The vice president—a self-imagined MAGA philosopher-king—has declared that “America is not just an idea.” Citing his own ancestors’ burial on a “mountainside in Eastern Kentucky,” Vance suggests that the “source of America’s greatness” is the “ancestral” bond Americans feel with the “homeland.” Vance mocks the “creedal nation” by insisting that its logic leads to an unacceptable conclusion: that all foreigners, everywhere, might instantly have a claim to U.S. citizenship merely by mouthing agreement with our founding ideals.

Few if any prominent Democrats or liberals believe anything like that last bit. The idea, rather, is that immigrants do have a claim to becoming Americans—they are “Americans in waiting”—provided they clear certain civic hurdles, including adherence to the nation’s founding ideals. Their rates of admission, and the conditions that shape their arrival and assimilation, are agreed upon democratically by our elected representatives in Congress and subject to revision over time. But yes, in the liberal vision, the idea that immigrants do have a conditional claim to belonging is fundamental to American identity.

Vance’s big claim, by contrast, is that fealty to our founding ideals cannot be the basis for American national identity. Blood and hereditary attachment to the soil are, to him, essential ingredients.

True, Vance takes care to praise immigrants and is married to a daughter of them. But he has also mocked immigrant Zohran Mamdani for mildly criticizing the United States, insisting Mamdani should be thankful for his admission here and thus self-censor. As Jamelle Bouie notes, put all this together, and Vance’s vision of citizenship involves “tiers of belonging,” in which those with long ancestry—“heritage Americans”—hold a superior position in an imagined national hierarchy.”

Absolutely. Unequivocally. Un-American.

Seems to me that Democrats and progressives - while not diluting their main message of “It’s the Corruption, Stupid” - should make some noise regarding Vance’s and this administration’s desire to replace the founding American ideals of opportunity and freedom with “those who got here first and who happen to espouse white culture are more American than anyone else”.

Let’s define them and make them defend the undefendable.

Happy Day After.

America the Beautiful

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

David J4 months ago

I'm a little late to this party but I wanted to add something that I was thinking about on the 4th. Swearing in new citizens on the 4th of July has a long and honored tradition. Back in 2016 I went to a swearing in ceremony with a friend who went to support a colleague from her work. I wasn't ready for the emotions I felt that day. It was very moving and brought home what a great country we live in. I get teary eyed thinking about it. The pride and joy on the faces of those new Americans will remain with me forever.

Generations of immigrants have made this a great nation.

Don't let the bastards in the White House grind you down. We have something that is worth fighting for.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Immigrants were key to saving the nation at least twice.

In the run-up to the Civil War, the North's immigrant-heavy society allowed them to increase its numbers and build a modern industrial economy that dwarfed anything the South could put up, while also giving itself a loyal and fast-growing working class that they could depend on to fight the war in a way that the South, for obvious reasons, couldn't depend on its slaves. (And of course when push came to shove, possibly the biggest source of support for the abolitionist cause, the new Republican Party, and the Union cause were German radical immigrants who fled after the failed 1848 revolutions and brought their politics with them).

And seventy years after that, "white ethnic" immigrants, particularly the Irish, Italians, and Poles in big industrial cities, the very same people that the 1920s racist backlash had targeted so hard, were ground zero for the New Deal politics that saved the country from the Great Depression.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

(I always groan when Republicans whine "liberals only want to bring in more immigrants so they'll vote Democrat!" and liberals hasten to assure than that, no, no, that's not what's happening! Looking for immigrants who're likely to vote D and rolling out the welcome mat for them is exactly what we should be doing. In a country built on immigration from the start, it's a completely legitimate way to win votes, and it's literally saved the Union before).

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Vance mocks the “creedal nation” by insisting that its logic leads to an unacceptable conclusion: that all foreigners, everywhere, might instantly have a claim to U.S. citizenship merely by mouthing agreement with our founding ideals.

It's genuinely insane to remember that until very recently, the idea that the cause of America and the cause of mankind were one and the same was a major part of the national ideology.

But yes, in the liberal vision, the idea that immigrants do have a conditional claim to belonging is fundamental to American identity.

Honestly, I'm not even giving them this one. It's not the liberal vision, it's just the American version. Anti-immigrant advocates have been betraying it for as long as they've been spreading their shit.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Believing that somehow - because one’s ancestors came here earlier than others - one’s citizenship status is higher than other more recent immigrants turned citizens is perhaps the most un-American view one could possibly hold based on the ideas and ideals that form the foundation of our country.

Like I said a few days back, if there's one line that best summarizes the American ideal (especially in its founding context as a democracy standing against the monarchist world order) it's Gettysburg's "here we judge you by what you do, not by who your father was."

So yeah, pretty much any attempt at creating different and purer castes of Americans is indeed not just wrong, but as basic a sin against American civics as I can imagine.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Musing that the watch-sized, Belgian jewel-encrusted tariff relief tribute ring should be confiscated and awarded to E. Jean Carroll to disassemble and/or do with as she sees fit - on top of all the cash and interest she's owed

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Yet - America has historically succeeded because on balance we have continued to strive - and make progress (but not necessarily linearly) to those ideals. That striving led to a period when America was the envy of most of the world. Not because we were white or Protestant or male-dominated; because we stood for opportunity and freedom.

I think "progress" is equally important here.

In the eyes of a lot of people both inside and outside of it, the United States got away with a crazy number of evils because of the notion that no, America wasn't perfect, but it was getting better all the time, and unlike in most countries those improvements didn't require destroying the entire government and starting from scratch - the system was self-correcting.

That's the idea that's essentially gone from the public square now. The symbolism that we haven't had a constitutional amendment since right before Republicans took Congress in 1994 (for the first time in forty years) hammers it in.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic4 months ago

Agree C P. Was going to write about that but wanted to keep this focused. Blatant political and financial corruption reduces opportunity to those with access/connections and obviously reduces freedoms to those favored by the government. Perhaps this is a blip in ML King's non-linear "arc of justice", but we can't rely on that in the moment. We are in times that require extraordinary actions...

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Fair. There isn't enough time to summarize everything, and Opportunity + Freedom is indeed a topic in itself.

Avatar

C P4 months ago

Of course, the other side of that is that it's a lot easier to be viewed as "progressive" back when so few other countries were even trying.

As late as World War Two and its aftermath, being an Americanophile in Europe was viewed as a progressive position, and for good reason - the American standard of living, middle-class society, and longstanding democracy were looked at with envy, and Roosevelt's New Deal was a model for national reconstruction. Meanwhile most right-wingers until very recently were either pining for monarchy or for straight-up fascism.

Nowadays, a hell of a lot of countries have long outgrown us, built models that are frankly better than ours, and not only aren't we keeping up or learning from them, we've pretty much built an entire national identity around refusing to do so.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Jack Diddly Ding Dong has done it again!

"Dozens of diamonds spell out two giant letter T's next to the Stars and Stripes and "1776" and "2026." Dozens more frame the numbers 45 and 47 in the shape of Superman's logo. A diamond-winged eagle carries a ruby shield and clutches an olive branch of emeralds, below a radiant "250" and atop the phrase "250 YEARS USA" etched in 18-karat gold.

All told, 321 diamonds, 56 sapphires, 13 emeralds and six rubies encrust the watch-sized gold ring presented this week to Bill White, the U.S. ambassador to Belgium, to give to U.S. President Donald Trump."

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/a-belgian-diamond-group-is-gifting-trump-a-lavish-ring-after-that-industry-won-tariff-relief

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago(edited)

🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

"Thankfully Trump and his sons aren't the kind of people who would have paid off a ref to red card Balogun so they could get favorable bets on prediction markets and then call FIFA to have the matter resolved so they could cash in"

https://bsky.app/profile/dominicervolina.com/post/3mpwjjmdhxc2u

Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

Thank you for the lovely symphony huzzah!

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

Maybe you should run for something?

LOLOLOLOLOLOL.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

My Mom pointedly took care to wipe out any possible prejudice or hubris when we were wee. Before we were old enough for school. I'll always remember the Star Bellied Sneetches!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago(edited)

The Dr. Seuss story tells of a group of yellow bird-like creatures, the Sneetches, some of whom have a green star on their bellies. At the beginning of the story, Sneetches with stars discriminate against and shun those without. Then one day, an entrepreneur/con-artist named Sylvester McMonkey McBean (calling himself "the Fix-It-Up Chappie") appears and offers the Sneetches without stars the chance to get them with his Star-On machine, for three dollars.

Maybe you can guess how it ends if you don't already know 😁

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

("The Sneetches" was intended by Seuss as a satire of discrimination between races and cultures, and was specifically inspired by his opposition to antisemitism.)

Avatar

C P4 months ago

The Sneetches is one of those things that's a pretty foundational anti-racist parable, but that I wonder how many anti-racists still accept today, because it condemns the concept of prejudice blankly and shows both sides as easily conned. As opposed to the "punching up good punching down bad" equation of our age.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur4 months ago

It was extremely memorable fun for little kids to see the conjob so I hope it still resonates at least with the littles.

Avatar

tam1MI 4 months ago

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

Train wreck of a campaign. Today it's all been speculation about who she'll endorse, everybody thinking it'll be Slotkin Jr, because the MI Dem establishment (and national "leadership") sure as hell don't want AES in the Senate.

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

Also too, Stevens is repeatedly on tape saying she totally opposes any conditions on military aid to Israel, and that wanting Israel to follow conditions of US federal law is something only "opponents" of Israel want. That stance is only held by 20% of Dems.

And let's not even mention her statements lauding ICE for "protecting the homeland".

JFC, she makes the WelcomeFest Queen and Hot Dog Princess nepo baby from MI look like AOC.

And she's cringey-ass as the candidatin' stuff.

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago

Dana Nessel, the awful MI AG, came out endorsing Stevens.
Same AG that filed felony charges against pro-Palestine students after local prosecutors found no basis to charge then. Then sent the FBI to raid the homes of activists. Several cases were later thrown out because of her personal bias and financial ties.

Yup, the reactionary centrists in the Dem party are closing ranks and attacking. If AES does pull out a primary win, it'll be interesting to see what kind of "support" they give and I think we know the answer to that.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor4 months ago

In addition to whatever else was wrong with McMorrow's campaign, she hired Lis Smith, who managed Cuomo's rapid response for his sexual harassment charges and managed Oppo and Comms for the DNC in 2024.

Avatar

Scott H4 months ago(edited)

Her "downfall" started with a dancing entrance:

https://x.com/ToffeeFever/status/2073870131822748039

In all seriousness, the reaction to that was massive cringe everywhere and yeah, it gained traction.

I didn't really see it as that bad. OTOH, that ginormous cutout of her face was the massive cringe part.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic4 months ago

Of course, the DSCC doesn't get that McMorrow dropping out will likely lead to more support from primary Dems for El- Sayed and not for Stevens...