While the shitshow known as Trump 2.0 accelerates into chaos (see this post from Mister Mix: Decompensating), I want to turn to healthcare and healthcare adjacent issues.

I made the mistake of being lured in to an editorial from the Wall Street Journal with the headline, “The Truth About Medicare Advantage” (gift link). For some stupid reason, I thought the opinion might be that Medicare Advantage is bad.

Silly, silly me. 🤦🏻‍♂️

Here is a taste. It opens with:

“The Trump Administration is considering automatically enrolling Medicare beneficiaries in private insurance plans—aka Medicare Advantage—as a default. This may be the single most effective way to reduce Medicare waste, fraud and abuse. So why do Democrats oppose it?

Democrats are trying to flip the script by claiming that Medicare Advantage is wasting money. Insurers, Democratic Senators last week wrote to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), “are endangering the solvency of the Medicare Trust Funds.” This misinformation deserves a rebuttal.”

And it closes with:

“Democrats dislike Advantage because they prefer government-run healthcare, though the latter has higher costs. The opposition to Advantage is ideological, no matter the facts.”

Projection much?

While I’ll write more about healthcare in the future, let’s just be really clear: Medicare Advantage is a scam, simply a means to transfer healthcare dollars from taxpayers to private companies like United Healthcare, Aetna and Cigna.

All we need to do is remember why we needed Medicare in the first place. Seniors are bad risks when it comes to health insurance simply because they have more health issues as they age (duh!) and it is simply nearly impossible for health insurers to make a profit on seniors. So, either there was no coverage for seniors, or the coverage premiums were prohibitively expensive. And as a society (back when we were a tad more compassionate than our current leadership), we decided we didn’t want our grandparents dying prematurely. The result? Voila - a government run insurance program that was NOT designed to make a profit, but solely to ensure seniors got the health care they needed (and deserved).

What couldn’t work for profit-driven insurers in the past (affordably insuring seniors) was never going to work now or in the future repackaged as Medicare Advantage - unless - the government paid private for-profit insurers with our tax dollars. And that is exactly how Medicare Advantage is structured today. Just another example of elected officials consciously redistributing wealth upwards.

The WSJ people throw out lots of stats without any links or backup data - and we all know numbers can be cherry-picked. I want to focus on the bigger picture.

Let’s go back to this quote from the Op-Ed: “Democrats dislike Advantage because they prefer government-run healthcare, though the latter has higher costs. The opposition to Advantage is ideological, no matter the facts.”

Traditional Medicare is a government run insurance program, not government-run healthcare. This is a key distinction. None of the medical providers in traditional Medicare are affiliated with the government. NONE. As I previously wrote, however, Medicare Advantage receives ALL of its revenue from… the government. To repeat, Medicare Advantage is simply a mechanism to transfer taxpayer dollars to private - mostly for-profit - healthcare insurers.

And at the highest level, what I previously wrote is still true: “All we need to do is remember why we needed Medicare in the first place. Seniors are bad risks when it comes to health insurance simply because they have more health issues as they age (duh!) and it is simply nearly impossible for health insurers to make a profit on seniors. So, either there was no coverage for seniors, or the coverage premiums were prohibitively expensive… What couldn’t work for profit-driven insurers in the past (affordably insuring seniors) was never going to work now or in the future repackaged as Medicare Advantage - unless - the government paid private for-profit insurers with our tax dollars.”

As we could have guessed - and many pointed out - fraud in Medicare Advantage is running rampant:

There are many more instances, but you get the idea. Because fraud is one of the few ways that Medicare Advantage makes sense for private, for-profit insurers (narrow networks, pre-approval requirements and denial of claims are the other ways). Medicare Advantage is a scam. It has all the hallmarks of our existing healthcare system where mostly private, for-profit insurers act as middleman to syphon off money to line their pockets in pursuit of profits and enriching C-Suite executives and shareholders without really producing much in the way of added value. The Medicare Advantage difference from our existing under-age-65 health insurance model is the money it syphons off comes not just from employers/individuals, but from all of us - the public - in the form of government taxpayer funds.

I ask the WSJ Op-Ed people - What is the difference between using taxpayer dollars to support a government-run health insurance program for seniors (Traditional Medicare) and using taxpayer dollars to support insurance programs run by private companies (Medicare Advantage)?

Who are the real ideological purists here? I think we know…

________________________

And since we are talking about Medicare fraud, there’s this guy:

“If Democrats were in power when Lincoln had allowed Sherman to destroy the South, they would've impeached him. Or when Roosevelt destroyed the infrastructure of Germany, they would've impeached him. Or when Truman used an atomic bomb against Japan. These people are insane.”

Ummm… Democrats were in power during the Roosevelt and Truman Administrations, and in fact, Democrats were in charge when we fought and won WWII. Dumbass.

But this is also who Rick Scott is:

For the life of me, I cannot understand why, whenever anyone - but especially Democrats - refers to Rick Scott, they do not refer to him as “Rick Scott, who ran the company that perpetrated the largest Medicare Fraud in history and got rich doing it”.

C’mon Democrats. This is easy pickings!

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

mister mixAuthor8 months ago

My old Congresswoman, the late Louise Slaughter, fought Medicare Advantage tooth and nail, but between the Republicans who wanted it, and the Democrats under donor control, it was a losing battle.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur8 months ago

Shocked, I tells ya, just shocked 🙄

"President Donald Trump’s administration this week acknowledged it made a significant error in figures it used to help justify a fraud probe into New York’s Medicaid program, a glaring mistake that undercuts a federal campaign to tackle waste."

https://apnews.com/article/new-york-medicaid-fraud-dr-oz-trump-342285a3c5d5b71f36ce3f3c77ec72c5

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur8 months ago

Someone called my landline yesterday purporting to be "from the Department of Health." When I said "Which one?" she said "THE Department of Health!" I said "Oh, you're with the federal government?" She said "No! I just need you to answer some questions." I said "Look, lady, we both know you're not calling from ANY department of anything anywhere, why don't you just tell me which third party contractor you're with." She gave up immediately.

Sometimes all of the fraud everywhere makes me too mad to say anything except "pbfthhhhh!" Which is what I should have just said to her - a big wet raspberry. It's not easy to shut me up though.

GAH is all I've got right now.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic8 months ago

One of the under recognized negative impacts of life in a hyper capitalist society is the toll that stress from fraud and crappy customer service takes on people on a cumulative basis. I’m so tired of having to fight for getting what I’m owed or do or returning something that doesn’t work or getting coverage for medical procedures that were necessary, but nobody wants to pay for.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur8 months ago

SAME!

Avatar

John S.8 months ago

I wonder how the daily stress of what Trump is doing is going to affect life expectancy. I’m expecting it to go down.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur8 months ago

I want his life expectancy to go down BEFORE he gets a chance to pardon "anyone within 200 feet of the Oval Office."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur8 months ago

I used to want him to suffer first, now I just want him gone and I don't care how.

Avatar

John S.8 months ago

Show me one fucking instance where the private sector does a better job of pretending to be the government than the government. Just one.

This is the ultimate con for the ages.

I grew up as a kid during Reagan, so I heard all the shit talking about the government and how bad it sucks and how the private sector can do better. It was all bullshit.

In my lifetime, I haven’t seen the private sector do a better job at anything the government is supposed to do. All I’ve seen is some epic grifting and a lot of people get rich doing a much shittier job. Yet the legend persists.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic8 months ago

John - tell us how you really feel🤪💪🏻

Avatar

Scott H8 months ago

Neoliberal, Reaganomic crap. "It saves money" when outsourcing services like this always costs the governmental entity more than if they staffed up internally.

Outsourcing thinking in general: “I don’t have to worry about this, vendor X will solve this problem for me”. You then almost certainly get screwed. You need to get every detail into the contract, and spend almost as many hours riding them to deliver on everything to your substantive satisfaction.

Outsourcing firms throw cheap bodies at tasks, they deploy resources stupidly and haphazardly according to their profit motive, and they live in a world where running up the bill, not delivering a working system, is the end goal.

The outsourcing of governmental services is the road to tyranny. Every time you contract away the public good to a for-profit company democracy dies.

It's about blatantly drumming up (creating an environment) of public frustration to push for further cuts and eventual privatization.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic8 months ago

Spot on Scott. Public goods - healthcare, clean air and water, the postal system, safety (i.e., law enforcement, fire protection, etc.), justice system (incl. prisons) - should NEVER be judged on revenues or motivated by profits. and yes, efficiency is a good secondary goal, but it is NOT the prime goal.

And, yeah, in modern times it all began with Reagan. Before Trump, I would argue Reagan did the most damage to our country than any other President (including W Bush who comes in 3rd).

Avatar

John S.8 months ago

You know I agree with that. Fucking Reagan.

Avatar

C P8 months ago

The outsourcing of governmental services is the road to tyranny.

Ayup.

That's what a monarchy (as opposed to a republic) is: a fully privatized society. Instead of being res publica, a public institution (however you define "the public"), the state, and in fact the entire nation, becomes the private property of an individual who can then pass it to his children, sell it to a stranger, or even have it taken apart if that's what he wants, like any old family heirloom.

The GOP's "we're a REPUBLIC not a DEMOCRACY" mantra is almost meaningless: the word "republic" doesn't tell you that much about your system of government, since you can have liberal republics, socialist republics, Islamic republics, and so forth. The one thing it does mean is that you're not a monarchy. Every time Republicans privatize yet another part of the government, they're taking one more step on the road to monarchy.

Avatar

Scott H8 months ago

Neoliberal Dems love to privatize almost as much as Republicans.