Yesterday’s post about Hastert and the raft of pedophiles in the Republican Party, as well as the death of another evangelical Christian Republican abuser and grifter, Jim Bakker, got me thinking about how shy Democrats are about calling out the hypocrisy and bullshit about religion that surrounds MAGA.

Let’s start with Trump, who is about as much a Christian as I am a singer in a rock-and-roll band, which is to say, he ain’t. But when I say that he isn’t a Christian, there’s a lot of people who say “who are you to judge what’s in his heart” etc. Well, James Talarico is really good on this topic, and here’s a short video explaining how he judges:

❝

Christian Nationalists walk around with a mouth full of scripture and a heart full of hate. Don’t tell me what you believe. Show me how you treat other people, and I’ll tell you what you believe. Jesus didn’t tell us to love our churches. He didn’t tell us to love our doctrines and love our creeds. He didn’t even tell us to love our scriptures. He told us to love our neighbors. And there was no exception to that commandment. Love thy neighbor regardless of race, class, gender, sexual orientation or immigration status. One of my favorite theologians, Barbara Brown Taylor, once wrote “The only clear line I draw these days is this: when my religion comes between me and my neighbor, I will choose my neighbor. Jesus never commanded me to love my religion.” You know what’s interesting. Not once in the entire Bible does Jesus ask us to worship him. All he asks is that we follow him. Love like he loved. Love the outcast. Welcome the stranger. Feed the hungry. Heal the sick. Free the oppressed. As the hymn says, “They will know we are Christians by our love.” We have to get back to that.

I’ve also heard Talarico say that your personal relationship with Jesus doesn’t mean much if your politics require cruelty. (I believe this was in his Jimmy Kimmel interview, which is worth watching.)

This is a harsh and divisive message, and I say that not as a judgment against it, but as a statement of fact. There are a lot of MAGA adherents who have bought the message from their grifter ministers: you can be as cruel and ugly as you want to others as long as you mouth the right Jesus words, attend church and tithe. One of the top results when you google “Talarico Christian” is a Fox News story quoting one of those grifters who says that Talarico is “butchering the bible”. Much has been invested in the mission of of separating evangelical Christians from their money while making them feel good about themselves even though they’re bitter haters.

I don’t know if Talarico is going to win, but if there was a candidate grown in a lab who was more of a contrast with Paxton even though both of them are fairly similar (white, Christian, politician, Texan in Talarico’s case, “Texan” in Paxton’s), I don’t know who it could be. Paxton has done so much bad shit that it’s hard to single any of it out, but Steve M found one yesterday that I hadn’t heard — Paxton is investigating pediatricians for vaccinating children. He’s doing this as a sick effort to court, who else, MAGA Christians whose manipulative, grifting pastors spin antivax tales in an effort to get more recruits for their “flock”.

Talarico is showing the way to other Democrats. He has a lot more moral authority on the “what’s a real Christian” discussion, but there’s no reason that you can’t call out MAGA Christians as hypocrites by pointing out how their actions aren’t consistent with the words of their prophet. They will get really, really upset about this, and that’s a good thing if you’re interested in destroying MAGA. If you’re worried about offending them about their religion, well, you don’t understand the moment we’re in.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Kay W.1 month ago

My youngest thinks Hinojosa is attractive. Not said in a gross way, just that he thinks she’s pretty. She’s much older than him, so THAT’S interesting but being attractive among the youths never hurts, right? 🙂

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 month ago

Mexicans are often blessed with great skin. My mom looked much younger than her age for most of her life. Hinojosa has that, too.

Avatar

Kay W.1 month ago

As someone who has spent more time around fundamentalist Christians than I ever wanted to, understand that a lot of their “Christianity” is centered on fearing and hating Muslims. I think that facet is continually undercounted, because Islamophobia in the US is continually undercounted.

Avatar

Scott H1 month ago

I've written a lot (in other circles) about the First Crusade, the conditions that led to it, and the incredibly long-lasting repercussions it had.

Here we are almost a 1000 years later, well...

Avatar

Kay W.1 month ago

Also, keep this quiet, don’t let our centrist friends in the Democratic Party know it, but Talarico is quite far Left economically. He’s a populist. Now, that’s just fine with me but it’s going to rattle some finance, real estate and tech Dems. The people who want both same sex marriage and low, low taxes. But if he wins Texas it won’t matter. Dems will be salivating over 40 electoral votes.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 month ago

I've seen people tryna say "I'm a regular Democrat. 🤣

Nope. We're all lefties, just different flavors. Duh.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 month ago

If Talarico and Hinojosa both win then 40 electoral votes are really in play. Just Talarico winning will be an interesting one.

Also if both win, plus Bobby Pulido, Mexican-Americans need to be courted by the party to be kept as voters.

Avatar

Kay W.1 month ago

Yup. Hinojosa changes it too.

Avatar

Scott H1 month ago

Predictable DC Brained columnist, Perry Bacon, actually channels my "inner peace thru lowered expectations":

https://newrepublic.com/article/216284/blue-wave-polls-2026-skepticism

JFC I need to take a long hot shower. Bacon was one of the WaPo clowns back in the Aughts who did "chat" sessions where DougJ and I would independently troll him because in the early days, they didn't realize people like us were out there and glommed onto the chance to make them look stupid like white on rice.

Not that it ever had any impact. The fact that clown still remains gainfully employed is one reason why I'm always careful when recommending stuff from TNR.

Avatar

Kay W.1 month ago

Talarico is impressive. I had to get over my gut- level “ick” response to preachers though. Everyone understands that if Talarico carries Texas statewide he is immediately the 2028 front runner, right? CA and TX together are 94 electoral votes. This is a big,big deal to both parties. It is by far the most consequential senate race in the country.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 month ago

Not sure he is the 2028 front runner if he wins, but he certainly will hold some serious cards in his hand...

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 month ago(edited)

One of my favorite things to say to these morons is "Who appointed you with any authority to judge others? According to your religion, there is only one Judge!"

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 month ago

I'm going to write about this as well, but it's important to recognize that monotheistic theology - and especially Christina Nationalism - is fundamentally incompatible with democracy. If there is only one way to do things guided by an invisible all-knowing God, then any governance decision made by the will of the people in a democracy that conflicts with that "one way" is, by definition, illegitimate.

Avatar

Scott H1 month ago

Christian Nationalism has long been a topic of writing but it never seems to break thru.

And it should because it's really bad and threatening to just about everything this country claims it was founded on.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 month ago

Follow up question after they sputter:

"Oh...is Jesus hiring?"

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 month ago

My family used to have this discussion periodically around the dinner table. I think I was about 10 when I asked my parents, “Who is a better person? Someone who beats their wife, but goes to confession every week, says some Hail Marys, and goes back home and keeps doing it, or someone who lives by the Golden Rule, but never goes to church or temple?“ I could never understand how bad behavior could be accepted or justified this way. And then there are those you say you need religion to have morals and values. I’m pretty damn sure that they were humans with morals and values before Jesus ever walked this earth.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 month ago(edited)

Adam Hamilton, a senior pastor of a megachurch, just turned Kansas into a toss up state. Can I get an "amen"?

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 month ago

I need to look at this guy, too. I know nothing about him.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 month ago

I don't either, but his Wikipedia said that President's Advisory Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships under Obama.

Avatar

Scott H1 month ago

The best label I've seen attached to megachurches:

Six Flags Over Jesus

Avatar

Sepideh M1 month ago

They seem to do a lot of food drives.

And this was interesting to see on the page of his church.

https://resurrection.church/event/classic-black-literature-book-study-2/