❝

Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s handpicked slate of vaccine advisers voted to no longer recommend a combined shot for measles, mumps, rubella and varicella for children under age 4.

[…]

The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, a key panel under the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, voted 8-3, with one abstention, to no longer recommend MMRV, a combined shot immunizing against measles, mumps, rubella and varicella, also known as chickenpox, for children under 4. Parents would instead be recommended to get their young children one vaccine for varicella and a second known as the MMR vaccine that inoculates against the other three diseases, under the committee’s new guidance.

Seems pretty innocuous, kind of like the “reasonable” restrictions that the Roberts court put on abortion before they had the votes for Dobbs. Well:

❝

Some public health leaders criticized the committee for revisiting the issue. “The only reason they would be reopening this discussion is they want to scare people basically and smear vaccines,” said Dr. Amesh Adalja, a senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.

My old man will be 95 at the end of the month, dios mediante. One of the more interesting sets of stories I’ve heard about his long medical career was when he visited an old friend. Dad and this guy had done their pediatric rotations at an Indian Health Service hospital in Gallup, NM. This was in the late 50’s. Sometimes parents waited to bring their sick children to the hospital until after a “sing”, causing at least a day’s delay, and by the time the kids got to the hospital, they were often severely dehydrated. Not only did they have to start IVs on kids, they had to do their bloods by looking at the colors of flames in metal pieces dipped in the kid’s blood and heated over a bunsen burner. (Today the same tests can be done by machines in moments using only a small amount of blood.)

So, kids died on their service. They died of complications of measles. They died of complications of mumps. They died of regular old gastroenteritis.

Towards the end of his career, Dad made a frustrated comment about a pediatrician who he asked for a consult on a sick child: “It’s like they’ve never seen a child die.” (I think he was talking about timidity and reluctance to offer an opinion about a tough case because they were too scared of being wrong.)

That remark stuck with me — he’s a harsh guy, obviously. Knowing him, I’m sure his frustration was because he had a sick kid on his hands, 100 miles from the closest referral center, and even further from the closest children’s hospital. He expected a specialist with far more training than him to give him some insight on how to save a child’s life.

The bad news here is that more and more healthcare professionals are going to know what it’s like to watch a child die. More parents, who have nothing but the best intentions for their kids, will also have that experience. All because some leather faced testosterone abusing failson thinks he knows better than a group of some of the world’s best scientists.

The good news on the vaccine front is that blue states are banding together to issue and enforce their own vaccination advice. Northeast states: Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania and Rhode Island have started a “public health collaborative.” So have Western states: California, Oregon, Washington and Hawaii.

New Mexico and Colorado should do this, too, but it’s not clear what our libertarian dude bro governor, who thinks RFK has some good ideas, will end up doing. Perhaps he has a taste for dead children, too.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Good lord, Mainers. You all need to get someone better than Jared Golden. He’s literally the only Democrat to have voted for these CR to fund the government today.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Butbutbutbut, he's "talented". I'm told that constantly over at That Other Blog™ which is simply a dog-whistle for "center-right Dems that think Ezra Klein and MattY are important Dem party influencers", or something along those lines.

They always excuse away such klowns like Golden because they win "tough" districts.

Of course they always promote the same kind of "talented" Dems in highly Dem districts so it's all bullshit.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

And of course Fetterman is not to be outdone by being the lone Democrat to vote for a CR that Rand Paul and Lisa Murkowski wouldn’t even vote for.

Avatar

Kathy Quinerly1 year ago

And, MM, thanks for this post.

Avatar

Kathy Quinerly1 year ago

Someone may have mentioned this. Yes, it's great about states banding together and insurance companies saying they will continue to pay. The big problem is with Medicaid and the ACA......government backed, basically advising against, and thus not paying for the shots. Poor children will die probably at a higher rate.

And obviously the other big problem is R&D. If the vaccines are NOT recommended/encouraged/subsidized, what incentive do the pharmaceutical companies have to develop?

Open to a discussion about this. Haven't looked at any links, etc. This just off the top of my head.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I want to comment about your Dad and his experience but I'm verklempt. Can't be tempted to cry anymore right now, so I coped with a bit of sarcasm.

It's like The Enlightenment is public enemy number one these days.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

It’s also just that focusing on vaccines re:children’s health is so weirdly and illogically niche. Get them outside. Feed them ordinary good food. Limit screens. Fund their schools. Support their parents. “The danger of vaccines” is a tiny risk - it’s insane for public health to focus there when there’s so many broad common sense things we could spend time on.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

There are some terrible grandparents where I live who were trying to pass an anti-homeless thing by calling it "Safe Zones 4 Kids." They frequently had people being obnoxious on the PTA lists or showed up to kids soccer games to browbeat parents into signing the petition for their anti-homeless initiative. They failed, and they still do not understand why they failed.

When you show up for parents, you have to show up on funding the schools, giving kids access to food, and all that other stuff. They have made no effort to show up for the kids, and they think we are going to vote for their anti-homeless nonsense because they want to yell.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

The Orwellian doublespeak that comes out of that sector, I axe-grind on that constantly as you know, always irks me. They use the same methodology that Big Tobacco and the Opioid pushers used with heavy doses of language out of the forced birther playbook.

They'll never understand why they failed because, like many of their ilk over at That Other Blog™, they're never wrong.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Didn't that ratfucker use the VAERS reporting system (on which any schmoe can make a report of adverse event) as "evidence" at a congressional hearing? I think I read that. And because it sounds official, the rubes take it as gospel (including some I know IRL).

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Nice to see it in the original German. It's like RatFuKJr. read Swift's A Modest Proposal and thought he could outdo Swift.

My local CVS bent over backwards to make our Monday Covid boosters & flu shots visit pleasant, the tech was ready & waiting for us this time (unusual), and we were given free prizes! Big bags of cheddar or regular popcorn PLUS two coupons for ten dollars off any purchase over twenty bucks, good till December 31.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

(Two weeks ago, it was a vastly different story - they were very rude and excited to refuse Covid boosters.)

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Our libertarian dude bro will be out of power soon, and we will vote for Phil Weiser because he is a sensible dude who has done all the lawsuits about all the mergers that would be bad for consumers. He has taken on crappy landlords like Greystar. He has taken on the nonsense that was trying to merge our two biggest grocery chains.

We will not vote for Michael Bennet, even though he is sending emails asking for money, because he needs to yell at RFK, Jr about vaccines from the seat he is in; and we don't want this libertarian governor propped further into other seats when they become vacant.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Bennett is "best serving" CO (and I used that term very loosely) by staying in DC, being the do-nothing, center-right "progressive" that typifies most white transplants here. Cuz if he's elected governor, yup, the scuttlebutt is he'd appoint our glibertarian, techbro (Polis is no dude bro if you want to get technical) governor to serve our his term or equally bad, Denver's Great White Dope of a mayor.

I've been neutral on Weiser at least knowing he doesn't hold all the center-right MattY "liberal" positions most CO Dems like Crow and Petterson hold. And if he's the best shot at keeping Bennett in DC, he's got my vote.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Your girl Dianne DeGette now has a challenger. It's CU Regent Wanda James.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

James isn't the first. A barista at the coffee shop 2 blocks up the alley from me declared earlier: https://x.com/MelatKirosCO

James strikes me as the type of Dem referenced in this piece: https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/liam-elkind-zohran-mamdani-campaigns/

This article on James is telling: https://coloradosun.com/2025/09/17/wanda-james-congress-primary-diana-degette/

“I know how to raise money”. Then look at her CV and the CO pols she's closely associated and you basically want to puke.

Oh, and if anybody's interested in who takes AIPAC money, both DeGette and Petterson have. They need AIPAC money like they need a hole in their head. It's another "tell".

If my only choice is between DeGette and James, however, I'd vote for the former.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Nobody outside of a Jewish enclave should have AIPAC money thrown at them. That’s how we know it’s just another vector for pushing right wing politics.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

There was also some regents drama that I did not understand that involved James.