Someone’s been feeling the heat.

In the case of United States v. Illinois, SCOTUS just ruled that the federal government cannot currently deploy the National Guard to Chicago. That in itself is a major, and hopefully not temporary, victory for the forces of good over evil.

But Ryan Goodman caught an interesting side note:

In a footnote that is seemingly totally unrelated to the actual case being decided, Justice Kavanaugh seemed to be trying to erase the term “Kavanagh stop” from common lingo by writing the following:

It seems as if at least one SCOTUS justice pays attention to societal chatter. Maybe the guy just doesn’t want his name associated with government fascist abuse. Maybe he wants everyone to know he’s a nice guy who’s simply misunderstood. Maybe he actually saw the light (nahhh - that’s a bridge too far).

Whatever it is, this footnote clearly signals - in a very small way - that Kavanaugh knows they went too far previously (the original case which set the stage was a seemingly innocuous case called Kansas v. Glover, but it was ultimately Kavanaugh’s concurrence in Noem v. Vasquez Perdomo, where he stated that race and ethnicity could be a “relevant factor” in ICE detaining someone, that led to the term). I’m spit balling here, but, again, it does seem as if Kavanaugh was okay with their prior decision in Glover until his name became synonymous with government overreach and abuse.

However, I won’t hold my breath that this will change anything in the real world where people don’t wear black robes…

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Busted Knee11 months ago

Hot take on this. Kavanaugh lives in Chevy Chase MD. It's very rich, and thus of course very blue. The DC area is very rich and thus very blue in general. Kavanaugh has caught flak from his neighbors, his country club, and was chased out of Morton's. The DC Morton's is where the federalists hangout and Leo has his own wine locker there.

So bullying works. Alito on the other hand is just a straight up theocrat so you can't bully him. Kavanaugh and ACB are vulnerable to social pressure. Roberts is slightly vulnerable on trying to retain some respect for the legal system. Gorsuch is a scum bag but he does have a clear code of ethics. Alito and Thomas are all in.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor11 months ago

The Supreme Court is a political body but they’re very bad at politics because they’re a bunch of out of touch DC lawyers.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic11 months ago

True. But maybe something got through? Even in a very minor and meaningless way?

Avatar

mister mixAuthor11 months ago

I think it’s slowly dawning on them that what they’re doing is very unpopular. Their bubble is pierced.

Avatar

C P11 months ago

Yeah, but the entire point of them is that they're not supposed to just do what's popular.

I don't mean that in an institutional sense of "the founding fathers in their wisdom created a court where philosopher-kings could render rulings without ceding to the pressure of the plebeian rabble." (Although that, too, is an idea that needs reexamining, like "the Supreme Court is as bad an idea as the Senate and the Electoral College" reexamining).

I mean it in the sense of "the entire point of the Federalist Society and decades of work turning the judiciary into a wingnut Guardian Council was supposed to be to make the Republican political machine legally immune from anything."

If you're going to get that far, it's fucking weird that you'd suddenly realize "OMG, we're unpopular you guys." Yes! That's the point! That's what you're there for!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur11 months ago

Also because their ideology of white national fascist corporatism is stupid.

Avatar

C P11 months ago

The heck of it is, the Supreme Court is practically designed to be out of touch. By definition, it's made up of politicians handpicked by the last three or four presidents. It's basically the hand of earlier governments reaching out from beyond the grave to strangle current policies in the crib, never mind that the whole point of representative government is that when an administration turns out to be full of idiots, you're supposed to be able to elect a new one to fix the damage.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur11 months ago

The phrase Kavanaugh Stop is irreversibly part of our lexicon now. No one is going to let that go, no matter what weak sauce he throws on the fire he started.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur11 months ago

In a footnote, no less

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic11 months ago

I'm certainly not. Same with the "Epstein Class"

Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur11 months ago

a favorite reply:

"I propose that any Kavanaugh opinion here forward be called "Kavanaugh Slop."

Avatar

Busted Knee11 months ago

Who's lexicon? A bunch of educated liberals? Doesn't matter then.

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 11 months ago

You just said above that it did matter.