Reader Scott H sent in an on-the-ground report about the primary opponent for Sen John Hickenlooper. Thanks to Scott for sending this in, and this is the kind of thing I love to publish, so commenters or lurkers, feel free to send this stuff my way, anonymously if you’d like.

Can Lightning Strike Twice?

Karen Breslin is certainly hoping so.

I went to a candidate meet & greet hosted by Drinking Liberally, something I’ve never done outside of Denver mayoral and city council races.  Around 20 people attended.

The candidate: Karen Breslin, is running to unseat Senator John Hickenlooper.  She is 64 with a law degree and teaches poli sci courses at CU-Boulder.  Her IRL political experience to date was primarying Michael Bennett in 22 with just her and one campaign volunteer.  In 24, she lost a DA’s race in a conservative district by 38 pts.  Go way back and she campaigned for Carter in WY in 1980.

Ole’ Hick will be 74 when he runs for a second term in 2026.  He’s promised not to seek a 3rd term but Ms Breslin would like to send him packing early.  

Hick’s not well liked by anybody outside of the extreme center of the Dem Party here in CO…which makes up a lot of the Dem Party in CO.  Despite this article, there’s no indication of any groundswell of support for anybody to primary him.  And recall that Sepideh reported meeting campaign consultants for another race for statewide office saying that nobody was interested because Hick’s ability to raise gobs of money scares off any of the more inside-the-party challengers.

Ms Breslin didn’t have a stump speech, instead she engaged in a Q&A.  I knew from her web presence that one of her lines is:

“We don’t beat Trump by moving to the middle”

And her Q&A showed that plenty.  In tone and broad policy statements, it wasn’t very different than the recent AOC/Sanders rallies except that she took dead aim at Hick, Bennett and our DINO glibertarian, techbro governor, Polis, as being representative of the problem in Democratic politics.  She outlined how money and entrenched centrism result in party that has no vision, is responsive to big donors and corporations and waters down any remaining message about the Party standing for marginalized people and economic equality.

She highlighted how the Democrats as they are built now try to have it both ways in doing just enough to deflect attacks they don’t do much for anything other than the generic big donor/corporate class but ultimately, it’s nothing but half-measures that show no vision.  In no way is the Democratic Party of the last 40 years anything remotely close to a “left” party in her view.  They don’t fight, they react.

She used the ACA as an example.  It’s a halfway measure that doesn’t really solve the overarching problem of how health care is delivered in this country and provides Republicans with something to constantly bitch about.

She’s a big supporter of some kind of ‘Medicaire For All” program and that Democrats should be out actually fighting and advocating for programs like that, not trying to continually tinker and work the margins, again, it doesn’t convey vision to the average voter.

She related a perspective pushed by the Party in that elections consist of 85% money and 15% grassroots.  The idea is to disempower candidates in advance because of lack of money.  She indicated that the head of the CO Democratic Party has made some noises lately about a change in direction but feels that’s nothing more than a reflection of how the state Party actually is getting a bit nervous about liberal grassroots activities that might throw a wrench into continually rolling out milquetoast centrists, at best, like Hick and Bennett or at worst, DINOs like Polis.

She’s also big on a significant corporate tax overall, a guaranteed minimum income and an increase in the Federal minimum wage.  Lastly, she’s stated in previous interviews that if elected, she’ll only serve one term.

She’s saying virtually everything we say here and certainly it’s a message that’s been resonating nationally in the AOC/Sanders rallies.  But how she’ll be able to translate that into a campaign that gets out that message is still uncertain.  She sure as hell won’t get any support from the state party.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I just saw this back and forth on twitter vis a vis Mandami:

"Wasn’t the campaign win extremely well organized? With a huge amount of grassroots work.

I think the lesson is that left wing messages, at least in urban centers, can resonate well. Provided people are organized enough to get the message out."

It was in response to something particularly dumb posted by Hogg about "not needing a massive and well organized campaign bureaucracy". Well, actually, you do need good organization, plenty of people and a good campaigner leading them on.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

After Scott sent this in, I wanted to read her bio, and there's no bio on the campaign site. I think this is an indicator of a weak campaigner. Maybe I'm wrong, but it's so basic.

Here's the thing about "primary everyone" -- some of the challengers won't be good campaigners. For every AOC or Kat Abu, there are hundreds of well-meaning folks who lack political skills.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I agree. People look at Mandami's success and focus on what he campaigned on but tend to overlook how he campaigned, not to mention the crapton of volunteers he enlisted.

Grassroots success is, like it or not, still very dependent on the person leading the charge.

It's early in this process so it'll be interesting to see how, or if, she builds such a structure or following. I do know the message resonates although as I (poorly) said in the piece, there's far more "Hick Dems" in this state than there are "AOC Dems".

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Another thing that the campaign person said was that Hickenlooper promised to run for only ONE term. I don't remember this, so I am looking through some of the news stories from that period. They are all so delightful.

HIckenlooper was running for President and said he definitely did not want to be Senator until Chuck Schumer convinced him. https://www.cpr.org/2020/11/03/colorado-election-results-john-hicknelooper-senate/

The DSCC went for Hickenlooper early on, and a lot of candidates felt shut out of the race because the national party people were in for their one true white bro. https://www.politico.com/story/2019/08/30/dscc-endorse-hickenlooper-colorado-senate-1478765

All this stuff is why everyone is so done with the Democratic Party.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I would be great with Medicare for all but remember who fought Obamacare the hardest - middle and upper middle class people who were afraid to lose private health insurance. That’s a powerful voting bloc. They almost killed Obamacare. They’ll go crazy again.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

I thought they were playing it as unions not wanting to be forced out of their insurance policy and everyone else saying "WTF, we are forced out of our insurance policy every time we get a new job."

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Polling says most people like their health insurance - it’s because they don’t know anything better but they’re going to be afraid to switch. I’d put Medicare in as an option at 50 - start there

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I wouldn't fixate on "Medicare for All" although if she's a good campaigner (and who really knows at this early stage) she'll make sure opponents don't try to distill a populist voice down to one thing.

Plus, what you're saying smacks of "surrendering in advance". Her point is Dems need to be out strongly and decisively advocating for things we believe in, not some watered down, (R) Lite approach which, jfc, we've been fighting against since the Aughts.

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 1 year ago

Max Baucus. Just what the heck did he get out of obstructing Obamacare—for himself or his constituents? I assume his donors really wanted obstruction, maybe set him up later?