One thing the Democratic party has going for it over the current version of the Republican Party (which is now less of a party and more of a cult) is it has some really smart people working out ideas for the future.

Effective - and successful - leaders are ones who are open to new ideas regardless of where they originate, are willing to challenge conventional wisdom, and are not afraid to upend the status quo.

“I don’t know how a Democrat can run in 2028 without setting the stage for a massive reform in 2029. And that massive reform is going to affect a lot of formerly sacred cows, including billionaires, the Supreme Court, etc.

…

The winner [in the 2028 Presidential election] will have navigate between the rock of a public looking for quick fixes and the hard place of widespread pre-Trump institutional decay plus Trumpist wreckage.”

With that being said, I’ll throw out a few ideas from others which I believe should be seriously considered in the coming days/months/years.

IDEA #1: Stop running scared on immigration

Greg Sargent - over at The New Republic - has some strong ideas on how Democrats can shed their image as being weak and ineffective by taking the immigration issue head-on. I wrote about this recently myself: Turning ICE and Immigration into a Home-Field Advantage. Sargent has some additional views. He writes in part:

“If all politics is spectacle in the era of Donald Trump, few episodes illustrate this more vividly than that created by Republican governors who bused asylum-seeking immigrants from their states into Northern cities during Joe Biden’s presidency. Greg Abbott of Texas and Ron DeSantis of Florida ensured that in the run-up to Trump’s 2024 reelection effort, the news media—and millions of social media feeds—were flooded with imagery of immigrants camped out in urban areas: desperate mobs swamping blue states and cities and straining their social service systems to the breaking point.

…

Yet now something just as powerful is happening, albeit in the other direction, and, mystifyingly, the savvy media almost never describe it in such terms. A handful of Democratic governors have found an innovative way to leverage the power of spectacle against Trump by relentlessly highlighting his ICE raids, kidnappings, and paramilitary abuses, in part by encouraging countless ordinary people to join in the project of using their phones to, as the old left phrase has it, document the atrocities. And it’s working: It’s done real political damage to Trump, just as those GOP governors damaged Biden. It’s creating a cultural moment around immigration that’s perhaps more powerful than the one created by those GOP governors. And it’s forging a new way for Democrats to go on offense on this issue—if they’ll seize upon it.

Perhaps the deepest innovation from both governors has been at the level of language and politics. Newsom, who as leader of the country’s most populous state is probably the most prominent Democratic 2028 hopeful, is widely assumed to be Trump’s chief antagonist on immigration. But Pritzker has, with less fanfare, challenged Trump in a way that deserves attention. He has repeatedly called on Illinois residents to help document abuses of power toward immigrants. “People of Illinois, we need your help,” he posted on X last fall. “Get your cell phones out—record what you see.... We need to let the world know this is happening—and that we won’t stand for it.” At a presser around the same time, Pritzker added: “Look out for your communities and your neighbors. Know your rights. Film things you see happening in your neighborhoods and your streets and share them with the news media. Authoritarians thrive on your silence.”

It turns out there’s a deeper theory of the case behind these directives, as Anne Caprara, Pritzker’s chief of staff, told me. Countless Illinois residents were horrified by what they were seeing but felt deeply lacking in agency. “People needed to feel part of the pushback here,” Caprara said, noting that the goal was to “empower them to do something” and “give them something to do.”

…

Finally, Democrats can speak with conviction about what they know to be right, wrong, and true. Rather than haggling over the precise words “abolish ICE,” Democrats can stand for some basic principles: ICE is a catastrophic, irredeemable failure, and interior enforcement must be totally rethought from top to bottom. Enforcement is of course necessary—especially at the border and also inside the country—but armed paramilitary forces should not be patrolling our streets and residential communities. It’s correct to focus on serious criminals, but not on longtime noncriminal undocumented residents, who should not be hunted and deserve a chance to get right with the law.

Let’s close by returning to that Pritzker challenge to Trump: “If you come for my people, you come through me.” Democrats can say: We will defend you and your communities from this absolute madness. They can say: We need more immigrants, not fewer. They can say: ICE is bad and immigration is good. They can speak to voters like adults about these issues. Public opinion is incredibly fluid on these matters. Democrats: You have a rare opportunity. Don’t run from it. Seize upon it, forcefully and enthusiastically.“

IDEA #2: De-Trumpification of our civil service

In a recent column, Asha Rangappa (@asharangappa.bsky.social) wrote about “Excising the Cancer in our Institutions” if/when the Democrats are back in power. She settles on a process akin to the “denazification” process used by Allies after WWII. It entails “sorting” those in the U.S. civil service into categories regarding their connection and participation in Trumpism. Her thoughts are provocative and creative, and certainly bear consideration moving forward. a short excerpt:

“Their answer was to create Allied Control Council Directive 38, a sorting system based on questionnaires (Fragebogen) that assessed an individual’s involvement with the Nazi regime. These questionnaires inquired about personal history; secondary and higher education; professional and trade training; record of full time employment, experience and military service; membership and role in all types of organizations before and after the Hitler regime, especially the Nazi Party and its organizations; writings and speeches since 1923; income and assets since 1 January 1931; and travel and residence abroad.

…

The law also established special German tribunals (Spruchkammern) in the U.S. occupation zone to adjudicate the individuals once their level of culpability was determined from the questionnaire. One thing I found interesting was that the burden was on the individual to prove their innocence, rather than for the tribunal to prove their guilt, which reflected the presumption that everyone was complicit unless they could demonstrate otherwise.

The Frageboden/Spruchkammern system became increasingly ineffective as a sorting mechanism, partly because of the sheer volume of people that had to be processed (approximately 13.7 million Germans over the age of 18 were processed in the U.S. zone alone), and partly because the judges who were adjudicating the system were themselves complicit to some degree in the regime as well.

But cleaning up the federal government — and the civil service more specifically — could be a much more manageable task in this regard, one that might be more amenable to this type of “sorting.” One thing is for sure: There is no way to go back to “business as usual” when this is all over. Some deep surgery will be needed before we can return our governing institutions to a remotely healthy state.”

IDEA #3: Reforming a Media that is not up to the current challenge

Dean Baker has some thoughts on how to reform a media landscape that is currently controlled by billionaire owners. He believes, as I do, that taxing the rich is necessary but not sufficient. He writes (remember, NAker is an economist so his ideas are generally viewed through that lens and can be a tad… wonky):

“The huge gaps in wealth and income create an enormous power imbalance and plausible changes in tax policy will do little to rectify the situation. If Elon Musk’s fortune was cut in half to $200 billion, he would still have a ridiculous amount of political power. The same applies to the rest of the crew of billionaires.

If we want to get responsible media that does its job in reporting on the deeds and misdeeds of the rich and powerful, plausible reductions in inequality (and how do we get those?) will not be sufficient. We need to look to fundamentally restructure the media.

This is not as far-fetched a goal as it may sound. We will not get the current Congress, or even one with a Democratic majority in 2026 to take the lead in pushing for responsible media. But we can have initiatives at the state and local level to build up independent media that is not owned and controlled by the rich and very rich. 

My preferred route is a system of individual tax credits, say $100 per person, to support the person’s favorite news outlet(s). This would be a credit, not a deduction, and fully refundable, so even the poorest person gets the same amount as Elon Musk. There could be different conditions attached to receiving the credit. In my view, the material supported should be freely available outside a paywall; but that’s something that could be decided by the state or local governments implementing the system.

…

I know the standard line is that we counter lies with more speech; but save that for the kindergarten class. When the right owns all the major news outlets and social media platforms, the idea that the truth will magically overcome their lies is not the sort of argument that can be taken seriously.

Anyhow, that is a longer story. But we do need to come up with ways to support independent media and not just complain about right-wing Trump sycophants taking over the media we have. My scheme is on the table. Let’s hear others.”

These are just a few ideas on issues that are pressing in today’s public policy and political environment. They may or may not end up being worthy or practical. They may be too “in the weeds”, however, they may still contain ideas that can be distilled down into simple, understandable messaging. But time is of the essence for Democrats to come up with focused messaging based on solid ideas to win back power. Contrary to what the cult of Trump believes, expertise and experience do matter. Candidates - especially federal candidates - should be willing to listen to our thought leaders in different fields to craft their winning messages.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

John S.9 months ago

Here’s some good ideas that I hope to hear from up and coming candidates:

  • Fix the emoluments clause to eliminate loopholes and end profit for presidency
  • Eliminate the presidential pardon so that it can’t be abused the way Trump has
  • Destroy Citizens United and remove corporate cash from elections
  • Completely reform the Supreme Court to restore jurisprudence and integrity
  • I can accept only one or two of these being out front and center, but anyone who fails to speak out vocally about all of these (like Schumer and Jeffries) is a total loser.

    Avatar

    C P9 months ago

    Thank you for including the presidential pardon one. Frankly, it's insane that this wasn't treated as a five-alarm-fire the minute HW pardoned everyone involved in Iran-contra.

    Avatar

    Kay W.9 months ago

    You are amazingly hopeful in these dark times and I admire it. I confess it’s been difficult for to stay optimistic. Good. We need optimists.

    Avatar

    C P9 months ago

    I know the standard line is that we counter lies with more speech

    Honestly, I feel like liberals need to learn to be okay with a certain amount of dissembling.

    I remember when the "Ghost of Kyiv" legend got off the ground, about one pilot who single-handedly shot down six Russians in a single night. Immediately, I pegged that this story was almost certainly not strictly true. Almost as immediately, I went "but do I care?" Thousands of Ukrainians are performing heroics every day to fight the Russians. That's not a lie. Ukraine as a whole has punched ridiculously above its weight class in holding off a vastly more powerful empire. That's not a lie. The story boosted everyone's morale. Even though it was clearly mythical, I don't care. (Neither did Ukrainians). It did the job.

    And yet I feel like half the Dems in the country, in that situation, couldn't stop themselves from raising a hand and "well actually..." As opposed to the sane reaction: "GO GHOST! Fuck the Russia!"

    Avatar

    Joe is Wypoxic9 months ago

    C P - I think there is a middle ground here. I get what you are saying, but there are ways to say things (or omit things) that can accomplish what you are saying without flat out lying.

    I wholeheartedly agree that Dems are way too pedantic. Many insist that every detail of a story or policy position has to be minutely accurate (and not omitted) to our detriment. If 86,345 people in my district don't have health insurance, I'm fine with saying "nearly" or "roughly" 100,000 people don't have health insurance. I'm fine with saying the Ghost of Kyiv shot down multiple Russian jets in a single night (I assume he actually did? Maybe not 6?).

    Avatar

    C P9 months ago

    Made me look.

    As near as I can tell, it started when the Ukrainian Air Force had an especially good night against the Russians and their propagandists decided to spread the rumor that it had all been accomplished by one guy. A bunch of people jumped on it and next thing you know, Ukraine has its own Zorro-meets-Top-Gun folk hero.

    (Fun fact: apparently, if this person were real, they would have been the first recorded fighter ace of the 21st century).

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_of_Kyiv

    Avatar

    Busted Knee9 months ago

    Without getting into shit I cannot really talk about there is a lot unsaid about what's going on there. For starters Ukraine has a foreign legion that many of us joined. It's light infantry, think Army Rangers level. The pay is good and you wear the flag of Ukraine. Standard tour is six months. It is riddled with troops from all the Americas, Danes, Brits, and various others who are all war on terror veterans. We give them a light SOF force of proven killers and exchange we get a lot of experience with drones and the new way of war. It's a win win for both sides of this arrangement.

    The Ukrainians speak nothing but the best of these units as the basic people in them are often former SEAL or Marine. The units speak nothing but the best of the Ukrainian units and the people as whole. The point of wearing the flag is for legal reasons and your rights as a legal combatant rather than a merc. I've done both in the past. But it also allows the locals to take pride in it.

    Avatar

    Busted Knee9 months ago

    For those units if you so choose you can become a Ukrainian after if you so choose.

    Avatar

    Scott H9 months ago

    The problem with "reforming" the civil service (lifetime Club Fed person here) is that Dems will get in and will most likely use the "look forward not backward" mentality they use on everything.

    Why? For starters, it's baked into so much of the Party. Secondly, it's the path of least resistance. Dems typically (but not always, Clinton appointed some idiots) appoint competent people. I might not be a big fan of Mayo Pete's reactionary centrist politics but he knew how to run an Exec agency.

    So, Dems will do that. They'll also wait for the Senior Exec Service people who came into those positions under Trump to cycle out (usually takes 2 years, I've seen this up close and personal), then promote people onboard with the Administration's agenda, part of which will be to play by the old, unwritten, rules.

    Avatar

    C P9 months ago

    We've somehow gone from "you should judge people on their competence, not their political party to "if there enough any Republicans in your department it means you're politicized," to "we should just always put Republicans in important positions because that shows we're bipartisan."

    Especially egregious in some police and national security posts; Democrats constantly promote and support Republican SecDefs, tolerate egregious right-wing bias within places like DOD and CIA, the FBI has literally never had a director who wasn't a Republican. And of course, every blue state police department is essentially a red-state army of occupation that operates completely independent of any outside authority. All this is before you even get to ICE.

    A lot of sections of the government need to be torn down and rebuilt for no better reason than they're full of Republicans who had been allowed to treat the job as their own political lab experiments with zero accountability.

    Avatar

    Scott H9 months ago

    I can talk endlessly about CIA given I was an intel officer for 11 years, first with the Navy, then with DIA.

    Anybody who gets into politics touting their CIA credentials like the "talented" craptastic MI senator, Slotkin, is an automatic "no" vote to me. I knew tons of analysts just like her back in the day and the agenda/bias they brought into everything was unbelievable.

    St Barack appointed Gates as SecDef and at first glance is an example of what you're talking about. Thing is, Gates was a competent pick and no more out of line with St Barack's centrist politics than some of his other, godfuckingawful, picks like Arnie Duncan, Larry Summers, etc.

    Avatar

    C P9 months ago

    Okay, now I'm curious. What were the agendas/biases of the CIA that you noticed, and did you think things were healthier in DIA/ONI, then?

    Full disclosure, my degrees are in IR and I actually spent quite a bit of time trying to get an analyst job in the IC. Gave it up after an application that actually went pretty far was torpedoed by a polygraph that lied about whether I was lying. Googling the machine that I'd never given a thought to before and finding out that its success rate is "same as a coin flip" kind of... made me reassess my entire view of the IC. I still enjoy reading about it whatever chance I get, but have no desire to join up.

    But meanwhile, a ton of my family and friends have had careers where they've crossed paths with the IC - military, State Department, DHS - but only one who was ever in it, and she dropped it for the TradCath Wife life a few years ago. Opinions of the IC, let alone individual components of it... vary quite a bit, it seems.

    Avatar

    Sepideh M9 months ago

    I had coworkers who could not get higher level clearances because they could not pass the polygraph test.

    Avatar

    Joe is Wypoxic9 months ago

    C P - ugh. sorry you had to deal with that...

    Avatar

    Scott H9 months ago

    CIA felt they were there to influence and establish policy no matter what the intel might have said.

    My experience in DOD was that we were there to provide leaders with the best data and analysis so they could make the most-informed policy decisions.

    I had screaming matches with CIA douches many times: once when Clinton was thinking about establishing a naval blockade of North Korea. CIA egged that idea on despite everybody on the DoD side providing analysis (much of it mine using early GIS systems) saying it wouldn't do much.

    Or screaming at them in 96 when the Chinese were lobbing ballistic missiles around Taiwan and Clinton sent in 2 carrier battle groups. CIA wanted a confrontation, we wanted to provide a balanced view of wtf was going on.

    I'm not doing this justice given the space (and my time) constraints of this reply box.

    Avatar

    C P9 months ago

    @Scott H thanks. For future reference, I am never bored of listening to this kind of stuff, though I won't bug you for it.

    My impression is that big intelligence agencies in general, not just in the U.S, are super-susceptible to a mission creep where, if left to themselves, they'll gradually drift away from their actual purpose of gathering information and towards their fantasy purpose of, well, changing the world from the shadows. (The KGB going from the theoretical servant of the Russian state to its master after the Soviet collapse being an especially nasty version of this).

    And as far as the CIA specifically goes, that they're especially prone to thinking they're all managers deciding the missions rather than workers carrying them out. Probably goes back to their early days being founded by Wall Street lawyers. So what you say tracks with what I've read and heard.

    Avatar

    Joe is Wypoxic9 months ago

    But Scott, there must have been at least one Democrat somewhere in the United States who was as qualified as Gates to be SecDef under Obama, right? Obama only needed to find one person. Instead, he perpetuated the myth thatRrepublicans are better at defense /military than Dems. Madness.

    Avatar

    Scott H9 months ago

    Oh, you're right with that reaction, there were plenty. Don't get me wrong, I'm not arguing in support of that predilection of Dems post-Carter having Reps in their Cabinet...DOT being the exception. There was an unwritten rule on both sides of the aisle that the DOT head would be from the other party. Mainly because transportation spending was considered bipartisan pork (I mean that in a good way).

    My point is that shit people like Duncan and Summers could have just as easily had an (R) after their name. Obama wasn't looking for a qualified Dem per se, for SecDef, he was looking for somebody who meshed with his politics and would give him a bit of an "in" with the (R) national security establishment in DC.

    He knew, at least on the national security side, how much the other side would potentially stonewall him. If only he took that same attitude to the rest of his presidency when dealing with the other side.

    Avatar

    C P9 months ago

    @Scott H

    The fact that Obama felt that he needed an "in" with the national security establishment because it's essentially a Republican frat illustrates the problem.

    Avatar

    Joe is Wypoxic9 months ago

    Yes C P! There has never been a Democratic Director of the FBI. There have been very few Dem SecDefs. This has been a bête noire of mine forever. Dem Presidents want to look bipartisan, but by doing so, they actually make Dems look like they are incapable of filling certain roles. Madness.

    Avatar

    mister mixAuthor9 months ago

    I know the standard line is that we counter lies with more speech; but save that for the kindergarten class. When the right owns all the major news outlets and social media platforms, the idea that the truth will magically overcome their lies is not the sort of argument that can be taken seriously.

    I don't quite understand how his tax credits would work (I'll read the links because it's interesting) but one thing the right does that we can do, too, is to extensively utilize the massive amount of free media available to the President. Trump has slacked off recently, but he was having the press in almost daily to the Oval to blither about whatever he wanted to say. We can do this is a more structured way, but the President needs to lead it. We need a President who's devoted to speaking to the public regularly. This is not kindergarten level thinking. It's "driving the conversation," something Trump is good at.

    Avatar

    Joe is Wypoxic9 months ago

    I admit - as I said - its too wonky. But I think we all agree that the media - especially legacy media - is absolutely failing in performing it's 1st Amendment duties (and they are duties, not optional activities - it's why they have 1st Amendment protections in the first place). I'm in th camp of throwing out ideas because the status quo is unacceptable and as Baker says whining is not an answer. I wish I had the answer...

    Avatar

    C P9 months ago

    Yeah, I have no idea if what the OP suggests is in any way a good idea, but I want to see signs that somebody is at least thinking about how to solve the problem, because the status quo ain't working.

    Avatar

    Sepideh M9 months ago

    For the civil service part, go all the way. Remove the political appointments in there completely.