There’s been much talk about the filibuster by armchair political pundits, in the blogosphere (we know more than everyone right?!) and even in the Democratic Seante caucus.
Mister Mix wrote about it here: Litmus Test, and here: It’s the Filibuster, Stupid.
Before I go any further, a quick reminder that the filibuster is NOT in the U.S. Constitution. It is solely a rule created by the Senate and was a somewhat accidental creation in the early 1800s. Of course, it became known primarily for stalling civil rights legislation in the 1900s.
For those who don’t pay close attention, the filibuster allows the minority in the Senate to derail most types of legislation that the majority would like to pass but with which the minority disagrees.
Josh Marshall over at Talking Points Memo has written extensively about the filibuster and its importance to success for the Democrats in the near future.
Why make killing the filibuster a litmus test? After all, that would allow a Republican majority to pass legislation that minority Democrats might want to stop.
Well, there is the simple argument that the constitution - except for certain special circumstances (such as veto overrides, impeachment conviction) - was set up for simple majority rule.
Makes sense.
However, in the current post-blue wave election landscape, there is an even more important reason for getting rid of an anachronistic Senate rule.
To wit: obviously, the current iteration of the Republican Party as a cult of personality around a mentally ill, pathologically lying malignant narcissist clearly cannot be relied upon to make the changes demanded by voters and required to restore - if even possible - the idea and reality of the U.S. as a beacon of democracy, freedom and opportunity to the rest of the world. Therefore, it falls to Democrats to do the hard work of political, cultural and societal restoration. They need to pass legislation (even if it’s ultimately vetoed by Trump) and they need to do it stat.
The filibuster stands squarely in the way of Democrats’ ability to pass, well, almost any legislation. It stands as a brick wall that - if not knocked down - will allow Republicans to stymie the Democratic agenda and then blame Democrats for being weak and ineffectual and also for all the bad things that will continue to happen due to Republican mal-intent.
Litmus test? Heck yeah. But not because it is some liberal political totem. Nope. It’s a litmus test because it will destroy both our ability to rescue our country from the grips of authoritarianism and Democrats’ chances of maintaining a governing majority that can actually do good.
In a nutshell, the first step is to make sure Van Hollen > Schumer. I don’t have Democratic Senators to call, but anyone who reads this and does should do it asap in favor of Van Hollen.
The next step is for all of us to push the Overton Window so Senate Dems feel like they have no choice but to change the rules.
Much like the electoral college, some political devices may have had their time and place, but they shouldn’t stay in place simply because our system has become ossified and sclerotic or because “institutionalists” like Schumer refuse to acknowledge that times change.
As I wrote a few days ago, the time is now. It’s now or likely never (and it will leave the window open for Republicans to regain the majority and selectively kill the filibuster as it has in order to appoint SCOTUS justices (and for whatever other reasons they deem important to them).
Kill the fil!!
Bob Dylan and The Band - Too Much of Nothing




