There’s been much talk about the filibuster by armchair political pundits, in the blogosphere (we know more than everyone right?!) and even in the Democratic Seante caucus.

Mister Mix wrote about it here: Litmus Test, and here: It’s the Filibuster, Stupid.

For those who don’t pay close attention, the filibuster allows the minority in the Senate to derail most types of legislation that the majority would like to pass but with which the minority disagrees.

Josh Marshall over at Talking Points Memo has written extensively about the filibuster and its importance to success for the Democrats in the near future.

Why make killing the filibuster a litmus test? After all, that would allow a Republican majority to pass legislation that minority Democrats might want to stop.

Well, there is the simple argument that the constitution - except for certain special circumstances (such as veto overrides, impeachment conviction) - was set up for simple majority rule.

Makes sense.

However, in the current post-blue wave election landscape, there is an even more important reason for getting rid of an anachronistic Senate rule.

To wit: obviously, the current iteration of the Republican Party as a cult of personality around a mentally ill, pathologically lying malignant narcissist clearly cannot be relied upon to make the changes demanded by voters and required to restore - if even possible - the idea and reality of the U.S. as a beacon of democracy, freedom and opportunity to the rest of the world. Therefore, it falls to Democrats to do the hard work of political, cultural and societal restoration. They need to pass legislation (even if it’s ultimately vetoed by Trump) and they need to do it stat.

The filibuster stands squarely in the way of Democrats’ ability to pass, well, almost any legislation. It stands as a brick wall that - if not knocked down - will allow Republicans to stymie the Democratic agenda and then blame Democrats for being weak and ineffectual and also for all the bad things that will continue to happen due to Republican mal-intent.

Litmus test? Heck yeah. But not because it is some liberal political totem. Nope. It’s a litmus test because it will destroy both our ability to rescue our country from the grips of authoritarianism and Democrats’ chances of maintaining a governing majority that can actually do good.

In a nutshell, the first step is to make sure Van Hollen > Schumer. I don’t have Democratic Senators to call, but anyone who reads this and does should do it asap in favor of Van Hollen.

The next step is for all of us to push the Overton Window so Senate Dems feel like they have no choice but to change the rules.

Much like the electoral college, some political devices may have had their time and place, but they shouldn’t stay in place simply because our system has become ossified and sclerotic or because “institutionalists” like Schumer refuse to acknowledge that times change.

As I wrote a few days ago, the time is now. It’s now or likely never (and it will leave the window open for Republicans to regain the majority and selectively kill the filibuster as it has in order to appoint SCOTUS justices (and for whatever other reasons they deem important to them).

Kill the fil!!

Bob Dylan and The Band - Too Much of Nothing

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H2 hours ago

I dunno why everybody's worried one way or the other about Ye Olde Filleebuster when there are plenty of Dems to support Hair Furor's initiatives.

What happened you ask? These 21 Dem Senators voted to advance BAAJA:

Blumenthal (CT) Coons (DE) Fetterman (PA) Gallego (AZ) Gillibrand (NY) Heinrich (NM) Hick (CO) Kim (NJ) King (ME) Klobuchar (MN) Ossof (GA) Peters (MI) Reed (RI) Rosen (NM) Schatz (HI) Schumer (NY) Shaheen (NH) Slotkin (MI) Warner (VA) Warnock (GA) Whitehouse (RI)

Lot of overlap there with the Crypto Senators.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor2 hours ago

Disgusting and unnecessary. What a thing to do after the mandate given two weeks ago in the election.

Avatar

Scott H2 hours ago(edited)

A great comment on Ossoff:

Ossoff is anti-m4A, anti-abolishing ICE, voted for the laken riley act and doubled down on it last month, takes israeli lobby money and has refused to call what’s happening in palestine a genocide.

We can’t run a white boy version of kamala harris and expect to win in 2028.

Don't tell that to Ezra/MattY and the rest of the Turd Way/Abundo clowns.

Avatar

Kathy Quinerly2 hours ago

Rosen is not our 2nd senator from NM. Sen Ben Ray Lujan is. He voted against advancing it. I'm furious with Heinrich anyway. Want him primaried If for anything for voting for his "friend"....his word....Markwayne Mullin.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic52 minutes ago

I became friendly with Heinrich when we were both running for Hiuse and were Red-To-Blue. Nice guy. Super disappointed in what he’s become…

Avatar

Scott H1 hour ago

Al Gore on Dems and BAAJA:

I have tremendous respect for the two Democratic Senators who have negotiated the permitting bill with two of their Republican colleagues — a bill that Congress is considering for passage during the lame duck session.

I sincerely and respectfully urge the Democratic sponsors of the bill to reconsider their decision to move forward with this legislation. There’s no doubt that we need to reform the way that clean energy projects are reviewed and permitted. But as it currently stands, the bill would be an extremely serious mistake, in my opinion, and would do far more harm than good.

Avatar

Scott H1 hour ago

Given how this Administration has run roughshod over the environmental laws and protections that are currently in place, now is not the time to give the Trump administration freer rein to double down on fossil fuels — which is what President Trump would surely do.

And after last week’s historic election, we will have a new Congress in January that can strike a far better balance.

Avatar

Scott H2 hours ago

...the current iteration of the Republican Party as a cult of personality around a mentally ill, pathologically lying malignant narcissist...

For a minute there, I thought blogger Driftglass had entered the blog. :)

Avatar

Kay W.3 hours ago(edited)

When I get discouraged at how firmly the status quo is entrenched in DC (daily!) I think about all the state level elections we won and cheer up. The federal government may be broken, but lots of states are operating and we can do A LOT there. Education, insurance regulation, state level efforts to regulate campaign finance, election protection, state AGs who aren’t afraid to bring cases against bad actors…. The state level wins will pay dividends for at least a decade. DC Democrats can do nothing and we could still make progress state by state. What level of government gave people hope going into the midterms? Mamdani. A mayor. Hinojosa is moving quickly. She’s ready to go. There will be others who will lead - I guarantee Keisha Lance Bottoms in GA won’t be sitting around wringing her hands and asking permission to govern. So we have that going for us. 🙂

Avatar

Scott H1 hour ago

Only on certain issues. Again, here in CO, yeah, there will be "progress" of sorts but it'll be very selective progress and only in tightly confined spaces.

The rest will be standard center-right, neolib Dem crap sold to everybody as a good thing.

Avatar

David J3 hours ago

The answer to your first question is: Once I thought I was wrong, but I was mistaken.

My video response to your video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L9EKqQWPjyo&list=RDL9EKqQWPjyo&start_radio=1

Avatar

Kathy Quinerly3 hours ago

Just came here to say what a big Dylan fan I am. Sure he's an asshole. But I was right on the rail (IYKYK) for him at NOLA Jazz and Heritage Fest in 2003 and 2006. He winked at me both times.

That's my story and I'm sticking to it. I have witnesses.

Related...I used to think Josh Ritter could be the next Dylan. I'm a big Ritter fan. Last saw him here in Santa Fe at The Lensic. Very small, intimate show. But, I think he's losing a step since his first 3 albums. I'm now coming around to Jesse Wells. Maybe not quite Dylanesque....but John Prine certainly is smiling down on Jesse.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 hours ago

I like Josh Ritter, too, but for some reason he fell off my radar. His early stuff was great though.

Avatar

Kathy Quinerly3 hours ago

Oberlin college boy. He went thru a really bad marriage a few years back. Dropped out. Has since remarried. I first saw him several times in St. Louis after his first 3 albums. So late 1990s early 2000s. Was excited to see him again here in 10/23. Good show like I mentioned. Very tight band. But his new, new stuff just doesn't do it for me. He is very popular in Europe. Adored in Ireland. I guess you know about his connection to Tom Ricks. He was still talking about that at the 2023 show. Author Thomas Ricks and Singer Josh Ritter : NPR https://share.google/xPs6jUJ2BwWIhHG4j

Avatar

Kay W.3 hours ago

I like poetry and Bob Dylan really is a good poet. His economy of language to express complex ideas could stand alone easily as top tier poetry. That puts him in a very small sub- group.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor2 hours ago

Ricks/Ritter - never knew it. Thanks!

Avatar

Kathy Quinerly2 hours ago

Linear notes. A real love fest there for awhile. Song dedications. And I think Ricks mentioned Ritter in the forward of a book. Honestly, I didn't reread the NPR piece. Just had remembered it from I started not caring for his new stuff.

Avatar

Sepideh M4 hours ago

I think I posted this in a comment earlier, but I thought it was really well done. https://nomoremister.blogspot.com/2026/11/im-not-anti-filibuster-absolutist.html

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 hours ago

I think Steve M has a point, and even though the fight is labeled as "abolish the filibuster" it will probably end up that some filibustering will be possible. We just can't have a situation where every single piece of legislation is blocked. That's so dysfunctional, and the fact that Schumer is willing to put up with it is the reason he has to go.

Avatar

Ken In MN5 hours ago

Sadly, Schumer and Jeffries are hell-bent on snatching defeat from the jaws of victory, because that's what their paymasters demand. Even worse, 2028 could very well be 2010 all over again, except this time with Nazis...