Reader R wrote in to ask about why a bunch of Democrats are going to vote to table Rep Shri Thanedar’s impeachment resolution. Here’s Axios’ piece:

❝

A rogue Trump impeachment push was criticized as "idiotic" and "horrible" in a closed-door House Democratic meeting Wednesday, Axios has learned.

Why it matters: The comments from Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.) were met with applause from lawmakers and backed up by former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), according to six sources familiar with the matter.

Nadler, the former top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, called Rep. Shri Thanedar's (D-Mich.) efforts "idiotic" and urged Democrats to vote for a Republican motion to kill his articles of impeachment.

House Minority Whip Katherine Clark (D-Mass.) said at the meeting that Democratic leadership will vote for the GOP motion.

Axios makes a couple more points: Thanedar is accused of misrepresenting support and co-sponsors for impeachment, and Nadler is one of the reps who was listed as a co-sponsor for a short time, but later had his name removed. So, Thanedar might have screwed up and pissed off some of his colleagues.

That said, this quote attributed to Nadler is nonsense:

❝

He said that unity against the measure would help protect House Democrats who are politically vulnerable — either to primary challengers who say they need to do more to fight Trump, or general election opponents who would use a vote for impeachment against them.

"People's sense is that it's a total distraction and waste of time given [that there is] no path to victory," a senior House Democrat who was in the room told Axios.

A vote for an impeachment resolution has to be one of the most politically defensible votes of the session. Also, it’s not like the House floor is clogged with meaningful legislation: floor action Wednesday was on a resolution about anti-semitism and a bill to increase the weapons carry permissions for law enforcement officers.

I also think that a vote against impeachment will hurt any Democrat who did it in a primary. I don’t know why that’s not obvious. Perhaps its because they are being told that by Shadow Speaker Nancy Pelosi: “She said that, in the past, the party has always adopted a measured strategy when it comes to impeachment in order to avoid the appearance it being a purely political.”

Well Yahweh fucking forbid that the Democrats appear “political”.

Floor action for Wednesday is over as of this writing, so the motion to table may come up tomorrow, or perhaps some other parliamentary move will be used to keep impeachment from being voted on (though that’s apparently quite hard to do.)

The tl;dr on this is: Thanedar stepped out of line, the hierarchy squashed him, and the hierarchy expects that people are too stupid to see that a vote to table isn’t a vote to not impeach. They want to keep doing very little.

Of course, I believe that they should be voting to impeach Trump pretty regularly. The Democratic leadership thinks that taking a vote where they know they’re going to lose shows weakness. I think it makes a point. I also think that every single Democrat who votes to table an impeachment resolution should be primaried.

(I’ll be traveling until Tuesday, so posting from me will be slim to none.)

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I want all of the ongoing firehose of impeachable criming catalogued in our permanent record for all time. Also it could be useful for future prosecutors. Yes, I am still a sweet, summer child.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Safe travels, mm. I too am going to NY but I’m driving.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I’m all for opposition but impeachment just seems dead to me as a strategy. I’d rather see them go all-in on Medicaid protection and advocacy

Avatar

r po1 year ago

Ok, why is it dead? Why not do both? It's all just noise anyway. That's the point: making noise.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I don’t think it means anything anymore. It won’t break they at all.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

Who is "they", should be "them", I suppose.

Anyway, they are not the target audience? Voters are the target. I have never understood why Democratic people give a goshdarn about what Republican politicians think. I mean, do they ever reciprocate?

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

This man had no support and no game plan. He just threw it out there. This is not a serious endeavor-- especially faking co-sponsors.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

88,000 kidnappings, "nine" deaths in custody belatedly admitted. Sure, Jan.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/05/14/ice-detainee-deaths-custody-spending/83619379007/

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

From what I read, Thanedar is showboating for re-election at a time where everyone is focusing on the budget fight and how the Republican budget cuts the social safety net and harms Medicaid. Thanedar squeezed out a win in a majority black district in an election with many opponents. Tlaib and other members of the squad are very much supporting Thanedar's opponent, Donovan McKinney.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

McKinney is being pushed hard by the Justice Democrats. They describe Thanedar as Detroit’s Elon Musk, and brand him a shameless self-promoter.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Yeah, I don't know much about Thanedar beyond him pushing impeachment. Do you know why they see him that way?

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

There was opinion piece up today by the director of Justice Democrats. She was critical, but didn’t really elaborate.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/may/15/democrats-are-failing-against-trump-we-need-a-new-generation-in-2026

Avatar

r po1 year ago

Why does this political infighting have anything to do with whether voting for impeachment is a good idea? Who cares who brought it up?

What it looks like, regardless of who's winning this inside fight, is establishment D collaboration with Republicans in support of Trump.

I mean, what's the end-game here? We give up?

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

The end game is we focus on Republicans killing Medicaid which has greater impact on the day to day lives of poor folks than the messaging of attempting to impeach Trump.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

You say this as if this need to "focus" is a self evident fact. Has this strategy had a long historical track record of success? I have been moderately paying attention for 30 years now and that's not evident to me.

What I see is a Republican 24x7 hysterical noise machine with no focus at all that controls all branches of government. That's a self evident fact.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Hmm... Maybe it is the political infighting that is a bad idea? Have you seen the stuff from David Hogg and Malcolm Kenyatta?

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Republicans voted to repeal the ACA over seventy times, despite the fact that almost none of these votes had even the slightest chance of passing.

What did they get from it? A voter base that knew where they stood.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Good point.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Traveling mercies to you M.M.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

The time for cautious, measured strategy approaches has long since passed. It's all out war, a fight for survival and so, I say, hit 'em relentlessly with scattershot. Whatever works!

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

My thoughts exactly.

Thanedar must have really ruffled some feathers inside the beltway. It's not often you see sclerotic Dem leadership and DSA types uniting to destroy a fellow Dem.