I wanted to write about impeachment because I read two different, good cases for and against. The case against, from David Roberts, who’s usually pretty reasonable:

Here’s the rest of his Bluesky post cut/pasted for clarity:

❝

Impeachment is, legally & procedurally, inert. The Senate won't convict, therefore it won't concretely do anything to impede Trump. I hope at least everyone clearly understands that.

So, you might say, "it's an opportunity to draw attention, to educate voters & diminish Trump's popularity."

If Dems or the left had any control over media -- if media were not heavily structurally biased to shit on Dems & everything Dems do -- that might work. If they had any ability to control or manage narratives, it might work.

But folks: they don't. Look around. Look at the election. They don't.

That's the problem everyone's flailing around, that no one knows how to solve: Dems have very few avenues to reach voters with their preferred messages. RW media utterly dominates rural & exurban areas & in urban areas you get the MSM, which is nearly as bad, nearly as obsessed with Dem bashing.

No one knows how to solve that, so the idea of in impeachment is, explicitly or implicitly, a hail-mary attempt to go around it, to construct some circumstance wherein media has to convey things accurately, to tell the American people what's happening.

But it will not serve that purpose, any more than it did last time. There is no getting around the problem, no cheat code that will make [waves hands] this media environment functional & effective. They'll just tell the story as "Dems flail at Trump rather than working on egg prices."

It's maddening. It's difficult to imagine solutions of any sufficient scale, at least any time soon. It's difficult to know what to do! But just closing our eyes & jumping back in the impeachment pool, hoping it will go differently this time, that they'll tell the story right this time, is futile.

The proximate effect will not be to focus American voters on the details of Trump's crimes, it will be to give commentators an excuse to go back to focusing on (and shitting on) Dems, which is what they desperately want to do anyway. This is not speculation. It has happened! It is happening!

The counterpoint is from Andy Craig:

❝

Obviously laws and budgets are moot with an executive who ignores both, and overriding a veto is even harder than impeachment anyway. Oversight? For what? You can't even enforce subpoenas for one thing. But also who cares about holding hearings to talk to the cameras and otherwise do nothing.

The Jan 6 cmte. was able to do its thing in no small part because it was able to enforce subpoenas with a friendly DOJ. People went to prison over it! Others complied because they otherwise would have. They were also able to stage manage it uniquely w/ no opposition members.

For now, there's nothing "oversight" hearings could do in the next Congress with Dem majorities that they couldn't already do right now w/ unofficial hearings. Flipping back the House and/or Senate doesn't actually get them anything on that, their subpoena power would still be toothless then.

There's this incoherent notion impeachment has to prove its worthiness and efficaciousness over other things they could be doing instead, but it never grapples with how there is nothing else to do. You can't tell a coherent story about why doing something else instead will accomplish anything.

This is why when Schumer tries to pivot to something other than impeachment he has nothing else to pivot to that's compelling or for which he can offer a reality-based account of why it would matter. Every other power Congress once had has already been nullified!

And sure, maybe you don't get the votes, don't flip any or enough Republicans, etc. But at least then you have something consequential to hammer them on, the only thing that'd end the insanity you want to pin on them, not empty whining that they won't play along with your do-nothing kabuki theater.

"Oh but that'd give Republicans a talking point..."

FFS, yes! Let them run around saying "Dems want to impeach Trump!" It's not unpopular! It is in fact more popular, by a lot, than congressional Democrats otherwise are on their own.

If you really want to go A/B testing this, try "Do you want to see Trump impeached?" vs. "Do you want Chuck Schumer to be Senate majority leader?" and see which one fares better. It ain't gonna be the sparkling charismatic popularity of Chuck.

I had my thrice-weekly dose of Fox News at the gym this morning, and they were in full fear-mongering mode about Democrats. First, they criticized the Jeffries / Booker sit in on the Capitol Steps by saying why don’t they do their jobs (it was on the weekend, by the way). Then they made their closing argument: just think of how much worse the Democrats will be if they get into power. So, as usual, my take on the “Republicans will say something bad” argument is that they already do that.

One point that Senate Gabe made a while back was that both impeachment efforts against Trump were pretty half-hearted. He read the impeachment charges and found them poorly written. I think both efforts probably struggled with the fact that many members (including Pelosi, at least the first time) went into it with the knowledge that Trump wouldn’t be convicted, and many have the (reasonable) legislator’s mentality that taking a vote you know you’ll lose makes you look weak.

I guess if I’m going to come down somewhere on impeachment, it’s going to be that if we do it, we go hard and don’t pull punches. It will probably fail (though who knows after another 100 or 200 days of the chaos and fascism that’s accompanied the first 100 days), but we need to do it as part of a signal that this time we’re serious. When Democrats regain power, the people who are breaking the law now will be brought to justice. We won’t have a replay of the Biden/Garland “let’s move on” mentality. Scores will be settled via due process and the rule of law. Impeachment is the lawful remedy for a President who acts like a mad king. If that spirit pervades, then I’ll be for it. If it’s just going through the motions, I’m against.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Robert's sums it up perfectly.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

I think for now we are better off working through the courts to try and protect funding, fight for due process, etc. On the one hand I like things like the sit in but I’m afraid voters will get tired of us doing events and I think a lot of people don’t really understand how little power we have. The NYT did an excellent write up of Gov. Pritzker’s recent speech in New Hampshire. He is calling for absolute obstruction by elected Democrats combined with mass mobilization by volunteers.

Avatar

Cheez Whiz1 year ago

"this time we're serious". That's the catch, isn't it. How serious are they. I'm waiting to see if they're willing to befome a real opposition party, throwing their bodies on the levers of the machine to make it stop. Mitch McConnell has some thought, I understand.

Without new information impeachment is at best a predetermined show that will move no needles. If that's how they choose to grind the House to a halt I have no problem with it, but with the J6 committee and Harris' campaign they tried Talk To A Real Live Republican Who Hates Trump, and at most it pissed off some leftists who wanted public floggings instead. I fear they'd try that again.

Avatar

Pacem Appellant1 year ago

There's a joke I used to tell a lot with the classic setup of three antagonist co-workers: a software programmer, a mechanical engineer, and their boss are driving to a conference in San Francisco when all of a sudden, on Hyde St., the brakes on their rental car fail and they careen out-of-control toward Market. All of the sudden, the car comes to a dead stop in the middle of an intersection. The boss panics and immediately wants to call a meeting to evaluate the situation. The ME has already popped the hood and is looking at the brake lines and engine. Meanwhile, the programmer says: "Let's roll it up the hill and see if it does it again."

Democrats want to roll the car back up the hill and hope that this time the exact same catastrophic tactic yields different results.

Avatar

Pacem Appellant1 year ago

I think the first argument resonates with me more because the second argument presumes that we would be working with Democrats that we don't have. Yes, IF we committed to the bit, I agree impeachment is a good strategy. But it'll be a cold day in hell before Schumer does that. So if it's zero-sum (not saying it is, but for argument's sake), then investing in media is far more value use of precious activist resources than getting Jeffries and Schumer to rally around impeachment.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Yeah, I can't disagree with your thinking -- it's my main barrier to supporting impeachment, too.