Reader J sent me an email yesterday noting that he’s gotten two texts recently from groups trying to kill a proposed tax on vacation rentals, and opposing an increase in corporate taxes. Democrats don’t do this: what we get is endless begging for money, not calls to action. Perhaps if you’re a member of a more activist group (DSA, Indivisible, etc.), you might get action texts, but you certainly won’t get any mass texts about issues from our party or the big boogeyman donors that the right is so scared of (like Soros). As usual, with the right wing, every accusation is a confession, and that includes accusations that billionaires are paying for propaganda.

One of the key structural problems with Democrats and media is that nobody with deep pockets wants universal health care financed by taxes on the wealthy. The deep pockets want reduced tax burden, less regulation, the destruction of unions, and workers who are scared and living paycheck to paycheck. That’s essentially the opposite of what Democrats want.

Reader T sent this Instagram reel explaining this Media Matters report. Media Matters did what sounds like a very deep dive into the right-wing social media ecosystem. The reel has all the highlights, but here are the bullet points from the report:

  • We found 320 online shows — 191 right-leaning and 129 left-leaning — that were active in 2024 and covered news and politics and/or had related guests. These shows had at least 584.6 million total followers and subscribers.

  • We found substantial asymmetry in total following across platforms: Right-leaning online shows had at least 480.6 million total followers and subscribers — nearly five times as many as left-leaning.

    • Across platforms — YouTube, Rumble, Twitch, Kick, Spotify, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok — right-leaning online shows accounted for roughly 82% of the total following of the online shows we assessed.

    • Comparatively, left-leaning online shows had nearly 104 million followers and subscribers across the eight platforms — nearly five times less.

  • Nine out of the 10 online shows with the largest followings across platforms were right-leaning, with a total following of more than 197 million. The only left-leaning show among the top 10 was What Now? with Trevor Noah, which had 21.1 million total followers and subscribers across platforms.

  • Our analysis — which looked entirely at shows with an ideological bent — found over a third self-identify as nonpolitical, even though 72% of those shows were determined to be right-leaning. Instead, these shows describe themselves as comedy, entertainment, sports, or put themselves in other supposedly nonpolitical categories.

  • Out of 320 online shows, right-leaning programs categorized as comedy — 15 shows in all — had 117.5 million followers and subscribers, or 20% of the total following of all programs we assessed. This category included The Joe Rogan Experience, This Past Weekend with Theo Von, and Full Send Podcast.

  • Right-leaning shows accounted for two-thirds of the total YouTube views on videos from channels affiliated with the shows we assessed — 65 billion views in total. Comparatively, left-leaning online shows totaled 31.5 billion total views.

  • Right-leaning shows use Rumble to expand their audience — gaining millions of subscribers and billions of views for their content.

So, the way the right wing gets their foot in the door is to brand their shows as non-political, probably because social media networks have traditionally been very uncomfortable with politics. But they often have political guests, and the guests’ politics are right wing.

Looking at the chart from Media Matters, below, I almost have to chuckle about the big debate over whether Harris should have gone on the Joe Rogan show. (My memory is that the reason she didn’t was because he was unreasonable about the length of the interview and the location.) That’s like wondering if pouring a glass of fresh water into the ocean will make it less salty. In his after-campaign reflections, Walz has acknowledged that the Harris campaign should have been “everywhere”. He’s right. Well, this is everywhere in 2025. It’s free media, not millions of dollars of ads on TV, so I’m guessing consultants are against it. Candidates should fire them, and hire people who understand this new ecosystem.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Taylor Lorenz just comes for the online resistance. I hate it, but I love it too for going after all the resistance grifters.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mz3Rf820ozE

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Never watched her before, but that was a pretty good rundown. She got a little holier than thou about progressives towards the end, but she summed things up well by describing things as “performative outrage”.

Bill Burr also touched on this in his most recent special in the most vulgar and hilarious way.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

She is a journalist who is very online. I think she gets in trouble for that sometimes, but her analysis of being very online is quite spot on. I did not know about Lindy Li at all.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

I hadn’t heard of her either. What a brazen turnaround. Kind of like Candace Owens.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I agree with her skepticism about Republican consultants now giving Democrats advice. Very wary of that.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

I have an issue with the sources used and the way some of this stuff is being categorized.

What are Kick and Rumble? Are those mostly male-driven spaces? If so, is that overstating the influence of "stuff dudes like?"

I listened to an entire 4 hour long Lex Fridman podcast (on AI), and he really wasn't putting his thumb on a political scale until the end.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I had to google Rumble and Kick - Rumble is a video platform and Kick is a streaming platform. So they're another version of YouTube and Twitch, probably with more nazis??

I'm open to the possibility that they overstated the rw influencer part of this. But most of the big red bubbles are right wingers, and MMFA is generally pretty credible, so I'm thinking "roughly right".

And, yeah, very male-driven spaces. Young white males have been moving right so they're a big focus of left-leaning orgs trying to figure out how to reach them. As usual, some men are the problem that afflicts the rest of us.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

That infographic from MMFA is outstanding, and a real eye-opener. For all the whining about corporate media and how slanted the environment is against Democrats (which is true), the real problem is the lack of blue content out there that people pay attention to.

These are predominantly podcasts or YouTube channels. They don’t cost much to produce, so the barrier of entry is incredibly low. But what do we get? Gavin Fucking Newsom inviting these red circles to come and boost their profile and expand their audience.

Flood the zone, Democrats!

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

It seems like we on the left have been doing so much complaining about the NYT, WAPO, cable outlets. Don’t get me wrong, they deserve the criticism but we have been so focused on traditional media that we completely failed to position ourselves in the media that are the most influential. I also wonder if the reason we are so wedded to traditional ad buys is because that’s how the consultants earn their money. I seem to recall reading something years ago about how those buys work.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

It's all of a piece. Mainstream media keeps Democratic-learning voters demoralized, misinformed, and low-enthusiasm, while right-wing media keeps Republican-leaning voters energized, angry, and loyal. Social media fit neither category for a while, but is increasingly turning into the latest version of the second category.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

I think that’s right.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

I agree 100% with this assessment. Well said.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

I spent 8 years in advertising. That’s exactly one of the ways consultants make money; they get some commission on ad placements.

I think you just answered my question from Kay’s thread the other day about where did all the money go: lots of traditional media buys that have way less bang for the buck, except for lining the pockets of the political consultants.

Their motivation isn’t to help make the Democratic party better. They’re in it for themselves. And we are trapped in their shitty feedback loop where Democrats do nothing and move further right while losing elections because it makes them rich.

Putting up a fight is free. Going on a podcast is free. Making your voters happy is free. But none of those things will earn the consultant a commission, so we’re not likely to see much of it happen.

Damn, I didn’t used to be so cynical.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I'm no Mr. Brightside, but the good news from that graphic is that Dems have a huge opportunity to get a lot of relatively cheap media attention. If they can get rid of their old consultants.

(And, this is information from a few years back, but supposedly Dem consultants don't get paid a percentage of the total spend on TV, but instead get paid for producing commercials, developing media strategy, etc. Republican consultants get a percentage of the overall TV spend. That was supposedly a big difference back in the day. I don't know if it's still true, and the production costs on a 30 or 60 second spot might are almost certainly a lot more than a social media hit, so it's still an issue.)

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

Right there with you.