I’ve followed efforts by both the Center and the Right to destroy public schools for decades now. Ohio is a leader in following dumb Right wing dogma on education under the banner of “education reform”, wholly embraced by Republicans and centrist and Right wing Democrats.

We have the entire menu of “school choice” in Ohio - corrupt charters, religious school vouchers that discriminate against students, “virtual schools” that are absolute garbage yet churn through tens of millions in public funding every year, with little or no oversight. How has this policy choice performed over the last 25 years? Ohio went from 11th in the country for quality of public education to 26th. The magic of free markets strikes again.

When “education reform” began, public school advocates said it was a Right wing plot to privatize public schools. Those advocates were jeered at by our learned center Right punditry chorus who insisted they would never, ever privatize schools.

This is the bottom of the slippery slope, where we ended up:

❝
Excluding the school from the state’s charter-school system would amount to “rank discrimination against religion,” Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh said during the oral argument.
❝

The main question in the case is whether the First Amendment permits — or even requires — states to sponsor and finance religious charter schools, which are public schools with substantial autonomy. A decision endorsing such schools would spur their spread, extend religion’s extraordinary winning streak at the Supreme Court and further lower the wall separating church and state.

The Oklahoma school, St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School, is to be operated by the Archdiocese of Oklahoma City and the Diocese of Tulsa, and it aims to incorporate Catholic teachings into every aspect of its activities.

After Oklahoma’s charter school board approved the proposal to open St. Isidore, the state’s attorney general, Gentner Drummond, sued to stop it.

Couple of things: First- Justice Coney Barrett recused. She should have recused- she has a close personal and professional relationship with one of the school’s advisers, still it’s good to see some measure of ethics and honesty in any US institution. Second, this case came out of Oklahoma. Oklahoma, where this just happened:

❝

Beginning in the 2025-26 school year, thousands of high school students in Oklahoma will be required to learn about President Trump's debunked claims that the 2020 election was tainted by fraud. The lesson will not be part of a course on conspiracy theories, but an official component of the new social studies curriculum created by Oklahoma Superintendent of Public Instruction Ryan Walters (R).

Oklahoma is nutty, insanely far Right on education.

Still, the AG of Oklahoma is arguing against this wholly publicly funded effort to force the public to pay for indoctrination into the Catholic religion. We’ve slid so far down the slippery slope on “public” schools this is where we are - with privatization dogma that is too far Right for Oklahoma to swallow.

If we have elections again, we Democrats need a coherent, evidence based public education policy to replace the center Right “ed reform” policy we’ve adopted the last 25 years. Unless the objective was to eradicate public schools, ed reform failed. Time to move on from it.

*photo is (what was) my local elementary school, built in the 1930’s. The school has been demolished and replaced by a new facility, but the two arched doorways you see in the photo were separate entrances for boys and girls.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Dennis Doubleday1 year ago

With so many states racing for the bottom, very impressive for Ohio to jump under 15 of them.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

If anybody wants to see how Dems enact and mostly embrace this bullshit, come to Colorado. It's yet another example of how Dems enable a lot (certainly not all) of the right's trickle-down, market bullshit approach to public education.

And all the pale-blue, white Dem transplants here leave the instant little Liam and Emma reach school age and they can't afford private school or to "choice out" to a "better" (WHITE) school district because one thing I've learned since moving back here is that

Gentrification Stops At The School House Door

The same pale-blue Dems love them this crap and won't stay or vote for any additional funding.

FYI, Colorado ranked 45th in K-12 education in the 22-23 school year. Yeah, we're a blue state alright. :(

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Colorado doesn't fund education.

There is little support for dyslexia until kids get multiple years behind; and at the high school level, our district's union contract says it is okay to stuff many children in a classroom. At the preschool level, no more than ten kids to one adult. At K-1, our district's union contract says there can be 26 kids in a classroom. This increases for second and third and then again for 4th-5th, with 31 kids allowed in those classes.

At the junior high and high school level, teachers will endeavor not have more than 775 students a week, but the language around this is really weak so classes are likely bigger than this.

There is no measure of accountability for the focus and charter schools as Kay is saying.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

In New York they whine all day about taxes, and they have some of the best public schools in the nation in the Rochester suburbs. There's some ugliness about the city schools (which are terrible, reflecting the many problems of poverty in the city) but those schools are well-funded, too.

In Colorado, they cut taxes and shock the schools aren't as good.

There's no substitute for funding education.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Teaching kids in rural districts is really expensive. They don't get the same breaks on ordering their books and curriculum. Their busses have to drive further. They are paying their teachers peanuts. "Come here and ski in your free time and earn $30,000" is how the logic goes; but with $30,000, you are not skiing or affording rent in the ski town.

Some of the rural mountain schools have very few students, and I think the principal is now half at the middle school and half at the high school for one of those rural areas of our district.

The advocates for more school funding like to say that half the school districts in Colorado are down to four-day school weeks. These are tiny districts that teach few students.

The state gives some of these districts shiny buildings.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Colorado doesn't fund education.

Precisely and we have to be asking why is that the case.

I got it more years ago when this place was some western meld of (R) and glibertarian. But now, at least on the surface, that should be changing and yet, in toto, it's not.

I know part of it is still essentially racist although that's such an easy trope to fall back on. If the state funded public education to the extent that it's needed, it would mean having to give districts like mine, a gerrymandered minority district, more funds and people still won't stand for that.

I dunno. It's depressing to see the byzantine nature and fundamental inequity of education funding. And as MM mentioned, our glibertarian techbro of a governor is no help.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

At least Linda McMahon is honest about her intentions. She’s here to destroy education and chew bubble gum, and she’s all out of bubble gum.

Arne Duncan was worse. He pretended to give a shit about education, but wanted to dismantle it in a less obvious way.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I was at an event with him once where a public school advocate asked "aren't you worried that you're helping the Right dismantle public education?" He poo poohed it. Assured us that public schools would thrive. Said we were "status quo" defenders. Arrogant Harvard asshole. Another one.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Another god damned technocrat.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

He’s such a champion of education that he has done so much since he was Secretary of Education.

Oh wait, no he hasn’t.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I followed his career. He went to a think tank funded by the Apple widow and then launched a committee to explore running for mayor of Chicago. Polling !must have been horrible because the mayoral.bid was quietly dropped.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

At least the poor people of Chicago were spared another technocrat douchebag. They suffered enough with Rahm Emanuel.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

A thousand times this.
And yet, we have plenty of New Dem/New Liberalism neoliberal "progressives" who believe in that crap. While first DeVoss and now McMahon are obviously there to do as much overt damage to public education as possible, in some ways school choice/voucher grifters like Duncan during Obama’s administration were worse in that they touted that shit as Progressive! cuz it’s a Progressive! President. I often say that sometimes I’d rather deal with a Klansman than a neoliberal NPR listener and that’s an apt analogy when looking at education policy at the federal level when somebody on “our” side is a school choice/voucher bullshit artist (like Shapiro in PA).