Reader S sent in this piece about MAGAts cheering the firing of their relatives.

❝

“I’ve been treated as a public enemy by the government and now it’s bleeding into my own family,” says 24-year-old Luke Tobin, who was fired last month from his job as a technician with the U.S. Forest Service in Idaho’s Nez Perce National Forest.

Tobin’s job loss sent him scurrying to fill prescriptions before he lost his health insurance and filling out dozens of applications to find whatever work he can, even if it’s at a fast-food restaurant. But some relatives reacting to his firing as “what has to happen to make the government great again” has been one of the worst parts of the entire ordeal. […]

Kristin Jenn got a similar response from members of her family after she learned the National Park Service ranger job she was due to start had been put on hold by the DOGE hiring freeze. She thinks it’s likely the job will be eliminated altogether.

As she has expressed her disappointment over potentially losing her dream job, some members of her mostly conservative family have unfriended her on social media. Others are giving her the silent treatment. Nearly all favor such cuts even if she’s a victim of them.

There’s a picture of Kristin Jenn in the piece, and she looks like a lot of the fresh-faced, eager, National Park Service Rangers that I’ve encountered in our travels. They are the best of us — they love the parks, they love helping people, and their excitement is infectious.

There is nothing wrong with noting that her relatives are the worst of us. The National Park Service is underfunded and, if her relatives pay taxes (an open question), only pennies of their tax dollars go to pay for rangers and upkeep of the Parks. This summer is going to suck at the National Parks — understaffed parks will have dirty campgrounds and tourons will probably do damage. Those MAGAts might even have the gall to complain about it, as long as Fox stuffs the right information into their willing ears.

Let’s turn to the FAFO crowd. One person who I correspond with on BlueSky, handle keynesaddiction, got into it with Marci Wheeler yesterday over a story about a West Virginia woman who voted for Trump and got fired from her federal job. Here’s that woman, Jennifer Piggott’s, story:

❝

"Nobody that I've talked to understood the devastation that having this administration in office would do to our lives," Piggott, 47, told Reuters in an interview, saying she would not have supported Trump if she knew then what she knows now.

"As much as I think that President Trump is doing wonderful things for the country in some regards, I don't understand this at all," she said.

The renunciation of allegiance to Trump by Piggott, a church-going conservative and three-time Trump voter, comes as political analysts are parsing early signs of a possible backlash in Republican strongholds where the government-slashing efforts of the president and his cost-cutting czar Elon Musk are beginning to be felt.

Wheeler’s response is that she hopes that someone tells this person that they’re a victim of their media diet, and when my correspondent clapped back, this was her response:

Let’s get my view of Marci Wheeler out of the way: she’s not a lawyer, she writes extremely long pieces about court cases that try to construct a narrative that may or may not reflect an understanding of the law, and she also is a big Merrick Garland defender. I can’t say I read her much or get much out of her pieces when I read them. So, that said, I think she’s wrong here, and its worth considering a couple of points:

  • Piggott not a good prospect. There’s big pressure on the part of the media and so-called “centrists” to spend an inordinate amount of time understanding, and then catering to, any hard-core Trumper who shows a bit of regret. Piggott is a three-time Trump voter who only cares about what Trump has done because she was harmed. She flew a Trump flag until she got fired. Then, she got a ton of media attention for her supposed renunciation of Trump. What’s going to stop her from voting Republican again on the flimsiest premise? Politically, I think time spent on more persuadable voters is a far better investment.

  • These stories ignore Democrats. Piggott was one of a few Republicans at a demonstration with at least 100 Democrats. Every person interviewed by Reuters was a Republican, as far as I can tell. There’s an immense amount of attention to be had if you appear to be a Trumpy victim of face eating leopards, which increase my skepticism about whether these people are persuadable or just like attention.

  • BlueSky isn’t the real world. We aren’t all knocking on doors in West Virginia when we post on BlueSky. I’m not a big FAFO poster, but this woman FA and now she’s FO. It’s not enabling fascism for someone with no political office to point that out, get a grip.

  • We should care more about alienating Democrats than flattering Republicans. If we are going to talk about the risks of alienating this woman with FAFO rhetoric, let’s at least acknowledge the risk of alienating the solid base of the Democratic Party by pretending that she’s some kind of completely innocent victim. She knew what she was voting for: sexism, racism and homophobia. MAGA isn’t shy about that, and it’s extremely unlikely that a flag-waving Trumper would have been crying about federal job cuts if she hadn’t been personally affected. Unfortunately, a lot of big names in the party are still gathering around a false narrative of the Harris campaign as being too “woke”. Those Democrats (like Gavin Newsom) are falling all over themselves trying to rectify the wokeness by embracing garbage like anti-trans narratives on women in sports. There’s a tiny audience for that bullshit: they all live in DC and they all write for the DC rags or DC bureaus of big media. There are a lot of Democrats who have been harmed by MAGA. When they look at their flags and their “Fuck Your Feelings” t-shirts, they think of women dying in hospital parking lots, trans kids being harassed to the point of suicide, and black and brown people being told that their achievements are all DEI, not hard work and ability. We cater to MAGA at risk of alienating these solid supporters.

In short, let the media worry about the Jennifer Piggotts of the world. She’ll get plenty of attention. If she wants to burn her MAGA flag and start volunteering to elect Democrats in West Virginia, welcome aboard. But we’re not going to start embracing her MAGA hatreds just because she decided to join the party. And, yeah, the better rhetoric here is “Trump lied to you and you didn’t vote for Musk” if we talk to her in person. But she did FAFO and the Leopards feasted.

Also, if we’re going to talk about Jennifer Piggott, let’s also have plenty of stories like the first one above: where the anger and hatred of MAGAts is even directed towards their own kin. One proven way to fight fascism is to show how odious the fascists are, and turn people against them.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Dennis Doubleday1 year ago

On the subject of the heartless relatives of fired Feds, I think innumeracy is a big reason. They think Trump is going to eliminate the Federal deficit this way, and it's all fraud, waste, and abuse anyway.

They have no conception personnel costs are fraction of the deficit, or the magnitude of a trillion, or even a billion. Which is why they also don't mind billionaires--it's just another rich guy, like the car dealer with the biggest house on the outskirts of town. We ought to be to break through to them on the issue that extending the tax cuts will blow a far bigger hole in the dike than anything Elon is doing to plug the existing holes. Unfortunately, I don't see any evidence that they can be made to care about the illegal and unconstitutional things Trump/Musk are doing.

Avatar

Dennis Doubleday1 year ago

Also, the reporter should have asked Piggott what "wonderful things" she thinks Trump is doing for the country. The chances are that the answer would be very revealing. She is the very model of FAFO.

Another thing reporters aren't talking about is that there's a very good chance a lot of the fired will get their jobs back, because Musk fucked up either legally or in a pragmatic sense (those jobs actually were needed.) But there will most certainly be loyalty tests that determine who goes to the front of the rehire queue. Piggott hasn't said anything that would keep her out of there and she'll love Trump again when it happens.

Avatar

Pacem Appellant1 year ago

Two decades ago, I could have been sympathetic. It's 20-fucking-25. Who Republicans are and what they stand for is cemented in the body politic. I'm out of sympathy for the rubes.

Wheeler's apologetics for Garland left a bitter taste in my mouth. Regardless of what you think Garland could have done legally, he was inept and incompetent and was so bound by the "rule of law" that he was incapable of doing what was right and necessary with the power and time he had. And here we are. Indisputably, he was Biden's worst pick.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Agree on Garland. Wheeler's political instincts are bad. She's too much of a status quo defender. Right now she's on BlueSky slagging Oliver Willis for pointing out that Jeffries' socials have been quiet for 24 hours, but then saying that the script for attacking Elon is easy and that's the agenda, and apparently we're dumb for not getting it. Just incoherent because she can't stand status quo attackers, but she knows what the message should be.

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

On the other hand, if the new unshakeable narrative the media takes hold of is: "Widespread regret of Trump voters fo voting for him, widespread anger of Trump voters at being lied to", I'm cool with that.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

That would be fine by me.

Avatar

- TPO1 year ago

There's a correlate to the length of Wheeler's pieces -- she can't write.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

LOL - She's a lit crit PhD iirc and I can never understand the stuff those people write.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Oh! I can almost understand it. I just thought that she was working in a complex universe where we can never remember all the characters so Game of Thrones.

Judith Butler's earlier writings were so complex that I could not understand them, and her Ph.D. students were complicated.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

This theme was also featured prominently over the weekend in an opinion piece by Danny Westneat in the Seattle Times.

https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/the-empathy-struggle-when-cuts-hit-was-trump-country/

I have come to enjoy reading him since I moved out here a few years ago.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

That's a good piece.

One of the things that used to happen before Fox took hold in the red areas is that politicians could run on their ability to bring federal dollars to the district, and sometimes Democrats could win because they were better at bringing home the bacon.

Now these MAGA types would rather vote for someone who shares their prejudices rather than their interests. They're like that joke about libertarians being like house cats: they think they're the king of their domain when in reality the owner has to feed, water and change their litter box. If we want to get their votes more than once, they'll need to acknowledge the mistake of ignoring the source of their livelihood when they voted. Otherwise, they'll be at most one protest vote and done.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

For sure. They need to be deprogrammed, and that takes time. That’s what I liked about the approach that farmer took in the viral video responding to the MAGA farmer.

He’s just trying to get the cult member to accept that they were lied to. That’s an important first step, and it doesn’t require them to accept fault or grapple with having been conned. But until these people come to terms with reality, they will continue to vote against their own (and everyone else’s) interests.