Adam Bonica is a Political Science professor at Stanford, and he had a hell of a time getting his essay about Democratic Spam PACS published. The New York Times, a well-known conservative media outlet, refused to publish it even though it was fact-checked, because the Elias Law Group, representing the DSCC and DCCC, sent a cease-and-desist. Similarly, the Republicans at the Bulwark refused to publish it unless it underwent a substantial re-write which removed much of the findings of the piece. So, Bonica published it himself, and it’s damning.

Bonica begins by using a couple of terrible examples of old people making an incredible amount of donations — in one case, a 91 year-old woman in senior living donated 25,000 times for a total of $250,000 in donations:

❝

The most visible players in this ecosystem are what I call “spam PACs” — organizations that use high-volume digital fundraising firms to raise small-dollar contributions, only to sink a disproportionate share of those funds right back into fundraising.2 They are built on a common financial model: outsized spending on aggressive digital messaging that repeatedly extracts donations from a disproportionately elderly group of donors. But these tactics have spread throughout the party. Even the party’s own congressional campaign committees and some of its most senior leaders have embraced the spam.

Republicans went all-in on these tactics first and offer a cautionary tale. After flooding supporters’ phones with fundraising spam in recent election cycles, their grassroots donor base — the party supporters who occasionally give when something moves them, until the spam drives them off — has been hollowed out. Republicans raised less from small- and mid-sized donors in 2024, a presidential year, than in the 2022 midterms.

One of the key players is a group called Mothership Strategies. They’ve been “shunned” according to Politico, but they’ve re-formed as “End Citizens United.” Here are the bros in charge:

Bonica zeroes in on a another group of PACs connected to longtime Democratic fundraiser Harry Pascal. Here’s what he found:

The graph is kind of weird, but the net of it is that $70 million of $390 million raised went to doing anything other than fundraising, and it’s questionable what, exactly, the “organizing and turnout efforts” accomplished.

The spam PACs raise far more money from donors 65 and over than overall Democratic fundraising.

Bonica’s piece enumerates the many different (shitty) ways that these PACs use scare tactics to prey on older people. And they are definitely a tool of the Democratic institutionalists, as the example of Hakeem Jeffries shows:

❝

In the 2018 election cycle, Jeffries had one of the youngest donor bases of any House Democrat, with an average donor age of 54 and only 21 percent of his donors 65 or older. When he became caucus chair in 2019, those numbers began to shift. By the 2026 election cycle, his average donor was 73, and 86 percent were 65 or older. Jeffries didn’t change his political positions in ways that would account for this shift; it was his role in the party that changed — and his fundraising strategy.

The whole thing is worth a read, and Jeffries has the power to blacklist these fundraisers. He just needs to use it, because they’re predatory and they’re killing the Democrats’ brand.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

Scamming seniors! (I posted the Bonica article here yesterday thanks to Will Bunch of the Inky.)

Scamming seniors! No consequences! Woo hoo! (Almost no one will get this news in order to do anything about it. How can we let those hiring these fucks know we're on to 'em?)

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 months ago

Thanks I was doing eldercare yesterday and pre-wrote this post...

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

My heart is with you, M.M. as a fellow (former) eldercare giver. It ain't easy! Good thoughts your way!

Avatar

Prairie Logic3 months ago

We are all vulnerable and if we are honest with ourselves, this seems sadly familiar, this race to accumulate more wealth. It seems as if money is viral since accumulating more breeds the need for more, and more. And more yet. How much is enough? It is almost as if money was the root of all evil…..

Avatar

Kay W.3 months ago

LOVE of money is the root of all evil 🙂 But I agree with your basic point.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

I've had to do a bunch of adulting today (all morning) regarding finances and I have to meet with financial advisor this week and I'm certainly agreeing with you! What a fucking mood killer - we were supposed to meet AFTER Labor Day so I could enjoy these last summer days! GAH

Avatar

Kay W.3 months ago

The problem is, a lot of campaign/pundit people ARE grifters - that’s just the truth, their orgs don’t add any value, but new entrants to the space are savaged by the entrenched grifters do it gets twisted. So you get a situation where gross, ancient Islamophobic hawk grifter James Carville protects his territory by taking out newer entrants like Hasan Piker. They’re all grifters. If you object to one you should object to all. James Carville has not won a US election since 1997, yet has been leeching off the D base for 30 years. He hates Piker because Piker cuts into his territory. If we’re smart we’ll choose the 2028 candidate based upon his or her ability to stand up an entire campaign without any of these people.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

Kat-echism

Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 months ago

A.L.E.C. getting lazy hahahaha! I can only laugh because I'm having a bit of cynicism for breakfast today (my defense mechanism which I try to fight, normally).

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic3 months ago

Damn. That's brutal.

Avatar

Kay W.3 months ago

https://floridapolitics.com/archives/814278-four-black-candidates-are-splitting-the-vote-in-cd-20-debbie-wasserman-schultz-is-banking-on-it/

Debbie Wasserman Schultz’s district was made more GOP due to redistributing, so she parachuted over to an adjacent historically Black district, causing intra party resentment, particularly because the Roberts court has targeted Black political power. Imagine if a white progressive had done this. The entire cable news Dem punditry would be up in arms, including both Clintons and odious Right wing Democrat, Andrew Cuomo.
But Wasserman Schultz is on the Right side of the Party, so not a peep out of anyone. The Democratic Party has two standards - a high one for progressive candidates and a low one for Right wing Democrats.

Avatar

Ken In MN3 months ago

I've been claiming for decades that the Democratic Party "Leadership" doesn't care if it wins or loses elections; its only real concern is to feed the DC Consultancy Class beast, which is frankly easier when Democrats are in the minority, because they don't actually have to do the infinitely harder task of governing or face any real accountability for doing nothing but fundraising. This is just one more piece of evidence supporting my thesis. It's also why my email is set up to divert all of their fundraising emails to my Spam box, and why my phone is set up to block all of their calls and text messages. When I feel the need to donate, I donate directly to candidates.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic3 months ago

Ken - I saw it up close and personal. In order to be part of the Red-to-Blue program with the DCCC, I had to initially use their preferred consultants. Turns out they didn't give a hoot about what I thought or what I did well in a previous run or even if I had any thoughts on what would work in my district. I ended up firing most of them.

Avatar

Kay W.3 months ago

Democrats hate their base.

These entenched, well connected orgs are the reasons Obama had to create an entire campaign apparatus from scratch to win- the Dem campaign infrastructure was glutted with grifters and scammers. We saw it locally in Ohio during the Kerry campaign when Ohio was still a swing state. We got no actual help but the national base were donating to tens of orgs supposedly doing “turnout” - one big grift. Looks like it’s time to clean house again. I’ve always had a bad feeling about Marc Elias. I think he’s stood in the way of Dems putting together a national voter protection team. It’s all turf protecting.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 months ago

Good point about Elias. Not shocked to see that his firm is out there defending the DCCC and DSCC.

Avatar

Kay W.3 months ago

Dems did the same thing with David Boies, of Bush v Gore fame. He was the entrenched Dem lawyer and he’s kind of a scumbag. I don’t have any reason to think Elias is a scumbag, but it’s a mistake to let these people get too comfy. Hire 4 or 5 lawyers and let them compete. I would actually hire local - pay Ohio election lawyers in Ohio, etc.

Avatar

Ramalama (ding dong)3 months ago

I admit way long ago when I was still living in America and listening to Rachel Maddow on the daily of starting a PAC to target racists into sending my "Be Strong For America" PAC which would send strongly worded faxes to members of Congress. I would word it differently but that was what I'd be promising in fine print.

And then I'd donate the surplus to liberal/progressives. My uncle wanted to know my thinking about it, and I wanted to take the money that people were throwing away anyway and use it toward me and my politics. Ultimately I never did anything about it. Probably because I'd had numerous conversations with him and other family about it, and thought differently about it.

But yeah, I am guessing if I'd done anything like this, I'd get caught up in rolling in the money.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 months ago

Clearly there aren't a lot of rules about what a PAC must do as long as they do a little bit of it, so I think your racist PAC that contributes to progressives would have been legal.

Avatar

Ramalama (ding dong)3 months ago

I guess I've been spared. Kind of how I was thinking about selling something for bitcoin way back before stable coin was even a term. People yelled at me about it, and I agreed: Yeah, it's made up to allow sneaking around. Why not get some sneaky money? Of course, I didn't do it. And then later read Number Go Up and hoo boy. "Sneaking" is too kind a word for all that. Signed, still poor.