I’m back in the town where I grew up, a town all of my siblings and I, and most of our friends, left after high school. One of the things that helped us leave town was the education we got, which I always felt was pretty good. The Dakotas used to have relatively good ACT scores (that’s the college admission test we take out here), and I had a number of teachers who I respected, and knew their subjects. The German and Scandinavian immigrants that settled here used to value education.

Yesterday, I went to a charity fundraiser and ran into the father of one of my high school friends. He’s a smart guy, lifelong Democrat, and active in the community. We talked about the current state of the local schools, and it’s bad. Teacher salaries are low, but housing is actually fairly expensive. It’s a desirable place to retire if you can stand the winters, so there’s not a lot of housing inventory on the market. And the apartments are nothing to write home about. So, the invisible hand dictates that it’s hard to hire teachers, especially for science and math.

This means that the science and math classes are taught via “e-learning” — a “master teacher” teaches them via video conference. A e-learning facilitator is in the room with the students. Another friend who’s a teacher was at the event, and he told me that the quality of education received in the e-learning sessions was variable. If the facilitator is paying attention, after one year of seeing the material taught, they basically learn it and can help the students in one-on-one sessions. If the facilitator doesn’t give a shit, well, then it’s like watching a YouTube video.

My friend’s father also told me about an incident where a Lakota teacher was a guest at the school and said something controversial. (One of the political dynamics of my home town is that it borders a reservation.) Some community members made a stink, so a principal was fired and the superintendent’s job is in danger. This is in a town where there’s an increasing number of Lakota students, because tribe members move off of the reservation to the town because there are jobs here. When I was a kid, the town was lily white. Now, it’s probably half Native American, and school enrollment reflects that. As with many “economically insecure” whites, they want the labor of the brown people, they just don't want to be around them, or have them partake in the economy.

The net of all of this is that a school that was a point of pride for the community two generations ago, a school that graduated kids who became doctors, lawyers and engineers — a school that punched way above its weight — is now, at best, mediocre. This is what happens when you don’t want to fund education.

I’m using Kay’s picture of her childhood school for this post, because back when we were younger, they all looked the same. Obviously, Kay got a good education at her school. I did, too. There are still some kids who get good educations at the local schools in my home town, but those kids have highly motivated parents and good home environments. The rest, well, they get to watch videos.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Written in 2018 but obviously just as pertinent today: https://unidosus.org/progress-report/latino-education-roundup-022218/

One of the sub-sections is entitled:

The incredible whiteness of gifted education

Which goes right along with another quote I use often:

Gentrification stops at the school house door

Obviously I talk about this from an urban public edumacation perspective but as Sepideh points out, the rural/urban angle is often overlooked. And when I say "urban" that includes suburban which as James pointed out, is where the public edumacation dollars go.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Noliwe Rooks wrote a book called "Cutting School," and I think you would really like it.

It made me think hard about gifted education. In Denver, there are instances where multiple schools are physically co-located in the same building. In this book, she discusses that gifted education led to tracking that made it so kids had very different educational experiences in the same school, and the gifted track was mostly white.

I grew up in rural schools. They were okay, at the time, but I would not have made it in colleges out of the rural state had I not gone to a magnet school. Both my normal high school and the magnet high school were more diverse than you would expect, but none of the schools I was in had an arts program before high school.

Today, I was looking at the art supplies in the hardware store, and I asked "What are these blocks?" My husband said that linoleum blocks were used for carving, and then he realized I wouldn't know because I grew up in schools without art.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Just ordered.

Avatar

James Powell1 year ago

Even here in the very blue state of California, my anecdotal experience is that people care about the quality of schools in their suburb, but nowhere else. They don't care whether "those people's" children are educated, they want them trained for low wage work. If everything was left to them, they'd shut the whole system down.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

New York had some of that -- there was no way in hell that the suburban schools around Rochester would have consolidated with the city schools, for example.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Here in "blue" Denver, the public school districts are gerrymandered. Whites move into the one district for their Urban Living Theme Park experience that's drawn to be very black/brown and when they (the white transplants) have kids, they flee back to the suburbs they came from (and profess to hate) because the schools are "better". They never try to establish roots and try to take responsibility for helping make the schools actually better as opposed to whiter.

It's a reason, among many, why we don't fund K-12 education here the way we should and it tracks exactly what you describe in CA.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

They flee back to the suburbs to have more children because most people choose not to stuff their four children into the two bedrooms of their city house. I think I know some people who did, but they were special. There appears to be less bedroom sharing than when I was a kid.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I've been very honest in the past, acknowledging that we moved to the suburb in Rochester that had some of the best schools, because we wanted our child to have a good education. At the time we were making that decision, the city schools were awful. We also knew nothing about city neighborhoods.

I think the following things are easy to say and hard to do: put your kids in a tough urban school, run for office, stand up to your boss to fight racism or sexism. All of them are significant risks. So I respect those who do it.

Avatar

green goblin1 year ago

This is always a hot topic at LGM. The education of "little Connor and Maddie" guarantees 100s of comments.

As mm notes below, it's not easy to put your kids in a failing school with hopes of making it better. It's a tough situation that the feds should address - invest in the schools so all children benefit and the those that can don't have a reason to move for their kids' education. It should not be up to individual families to sacrifice. Very few are interested in sacrifice and even fewer when it comes to their children. It is a decision that could impact their their entire life.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

During the late cold war, education was still valued due to the fumes left over from the space race. With the US as the one remaining super power, the country rested on its laurels, and it has been rich people trying to defund education ever since.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I went on a couple of dates with a woman back in college in the early 80s who was from SD and the virulent, racist comments she made about Native Americans meant there were no more dates.

It was eye opening and this from somebody who was part of the first couple of years of court-ordered busing in Norfolk VA and many of the people around me back there where none to happy about it and said so.

Her comments made them look like woke Dems.

And yes, SD spends less per student on K-12 than CO does, and that's not a compliment.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

There's a lot of that around here. Unfortunately, there's always been issues with alcoholism and some small amount of homelessness with the native population, so that fuels it. What's different from my childhood is Native American educated professionals in teaching and healthcare, and also working in the stores. It's slow integration...

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

My long (for me), on topic comment was stymied by an application error. Oh well. The gist was that, even in more populous locales, education is in trouble. I'll try to recreate my comment later.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

The Inky and the DelCo Daily Times have articles about the travails in our education system every day now.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

What is happening here in rural Maine is consolidation of school districts because we don’t have enough students to support the infrastructure. The little elementary school behind my house is closing at the end of this school year and the kids will be bussed to a nearby town. About an hour from me the town is consolidating the schools in their town so there will be one k-3rd school and one 4th through 12th school. Now a bunch of parents are angry and deciding to mass homeschool their 4th and 5th graders. I’m from away (as we say here) and my kids are adults so I am not grieving the way my neighbors are. It is painful for them to see businesses and schools close. These small, rural communities are dying. People like me are moving here and fixing up these dilapidated houses which to them feels like an insult.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

The school district in my home town consolidated a few years back with another mostly white community. They would not consolidate with the (SD Public) school on the reservation. So a new public school was built on the rez.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

I moved to a part of Maine that is overwhelmingly white. The town I moved from and the city where I worked were much more diverse. My town even made it to The Daily Fail and Libs of Tik Tok because the state decided to pay for housing for immigrant families in part of one apartment building in a large complex. It didn’t matter that the economy was booming and we had a desperate worker shortage. Just crazy propaganda.