This is The Way:

First, let’s step back and take a look at how we got here.

The Department of Homeland Security is a relatively new federal government agency. It was created in 2002 after the 9/11 attacks.

The creation of DHS consolidated sone or all of 22 agencies that performed a range of functions, including FEMA, TSA, the Coast Guard, Customs, Secret Service, INS (Immigration and Naturalization Service), Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS), Federal Protective Service, General Law enforcement Training Center, Office for Domestics Preparedness, Federal Computer Incident Response Center, National Communications System and others.

Although the memory of 9/11 was fresh, and the public was clamoring for protection from foreign terrorists, there was still significant congressional opposition to the creation of DHS. Concerns centered around consolidations of power in the Executive branch, increased bureaucracy, labor laws, rights for federal employees and, of course, how to best oversee national security. Ultimately, the political atmosphere following the September 11 attacks - with both parties facing pressure to demonstrate their commitment to protecting the country - resulted in a bipartisan bill passing the House and the Senate.

______________________________________

In my opinion, the word “Homeland” is a loaded word. And it was not a word that previously had, really, in any way been associated with residents’ views of the United States in which they lived.

Simply put, “Homeland” has been used in the past to evoke nationalism, exclusion, militarization, and authoritarian government. While not inherently part of the formal definition of the Homeland, previous repressive regimes have used the term to stir up fear, hatred and maintain control over its people (yes, Nazi Germany, among others).

_________________________________________

With that context, let’s go back to the opening link of my post.

Rep. Delia Ramirze of Illinois has proposed “reforming” DHS:

Rep. Delia C. Ramirez (D-Illinois) has introduced a bill that would abolish not just ICE, but the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) altogether, repealing the 2002 law establishing the agency and replacing it with one focused on protecting civil and human rights.

The wide-ranging legislation, dubbed the Reimagining Safety Act, would repeal the Homeland Security Act. Signed by President George W. Bush as part of his administration’s post-9/11 “war on terror,” the transformational bill created DHS and led to the establishment of Customs and Border Protection (CBP) and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

The bill would abolish DHS, CBP, and ICE — going further than the progressive call to abolish ICE. Other offices currently housed within the department, like Transportation Security Administration (TSA), the Coast Guard, Citizenship and Immigration Services, and the customs functions of CBP would be broken off into different authorities.

“We know that DHS was intentionally established with an overbroad mission and unchecked power. The last two years have made it visible what so many communities have actually been saying for decades: That DHS, frankly, is the single greatest threat to our public safety today,” Ramirez said in a press conference previewing the legislation last month. “We must strip away every single tool they are using to terrorize us.”

But “reform “through abolishing DHS and ICE is not enough. Most Americans still favor borders that are, in their view, “secure”, and simply saying one wants to abolish DHS doesn’t fully address the concersn surrounding immigration and national security..

Don’t worry. Rep. Ramirez is on it:

In DHS’s place, Ramirez’s bill would create a cabinet-level “Department of Community Safety,” which would address community concerns ranging from gun violence to disaster relief, using a public health-based approach. All immigration detention centers would be shuttered.

DHS (and ICE) have become tools of repression by the Trump regime. Democrats challenge is not just to help people understand this (it is getting through), but also to reframe the debate (and wording) around national security and immigration.

Rep. Ramirez’ bill is a good start. No, it won’t become law right away (even if Dems win both the House and Senate, Trump still have veto power). It is the first attack in the war to redefine patriotism and nationalism in America.

The Democratic establishment needs to get on board…

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

David J3 weeks ago

If the Democrats win the Senate and get rid of the filibuster that will being to restore some of my faith in the Congressional leadership. Keeping the filibuster will be a flashing red light they are unserious.

Get rid of the filibuster and start passing legislation. Let Trump veto it. It's just more ammunition for 2028.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic3 weeks ago

Bingo!

Avatar

Scott H3 weeks ago

And yet, listen to sooooo many Senate Dems who are still saying they won't do it, too radical, yada, yada, yada.

If we retake the Senate, the fillybuster ain't going away.

Avatar

David J3 weeks ago

I live in MA so both of my Senators are outspoken critics of the filibuster. It would behoove us to begin organizing a campaign now to persuade other Democrats to get on board.

Avatar

Scott H3 weeks ago

Amazingly here in Ostensibly Democrat CO, our two are split.

Good ole Hick tries to parse his continued support of it and of course he's fulla shit.

Bennet came out for total elimination back in 21.

A quick google check shows that if the Dems retake the Senate, they won't find 51 Senators to eliminate the filibuster. It's the usual "I support reforming it" crapola from the usual suspects.

What's funny is that support/opposition doesn't necessarily break down along "liberal" and "centrist" lines. For example, centrist hacks like Booker and Schatz, support killing it entirely.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 weeks ago(edited)

Relatedly, we now have only 3/5 of our Due Process clause rights remaining.

https://newrepublic.com/post/217076/federal-court-donald-trump-ice-detain-people-indefinitely

This cannot be allowed to stand. If one loses rights, we all lose them. Getting them back will be much harder when you're in solitary. No phone calls.

The Constitution is supposed to apply to everyone in the U.S. regardless of documentation.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 weeks ago(edited)

I remember this motto all the time, it used to make me guffaw (under my breath!) in the law office representing the po po:

To serve and protect

We all know what they're protecting and it ain't us.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 weeks ago(edited)

For his birthday, I gave my boss a special ceramic plate by a local artist during this time period:

It was a cop named Sergeant Fear with a bullhorn pointing to a threat level chart & urging us to purchase plenty of duct tape (in case of anthrax attacks). I was surprised when he proudly displayed it on the bookshelves in his office!

Avatar

Joe M3 weeks ago

I remember thinking when they announced DHS: What? Couldn't come up with a more Nazi sounding name?

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 weeks ago(edited)

Me also

My threat level was in the red zone.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 weeks ago(edited)

Plus I was victim of civil rights violation on my first flight to Texas (too close to GWB I guess).

Homeland created this

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Fly_List

Avatar

Scott H3 weeks ago

Me three.

But then it was entirely predictable given the Bushies and their fundamental nature.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor3 weeks ago

I guess Department of Fatherland Security was a bridge too far.

Avatar

C P3 weeks ago

The one and only thing I like about the word "homeland" is that it's not gendered.

Avatar

C P3 weeks ago

DHS needs to be broken up and its constituent parts sent back to the departments who originally had them. Secret Service back to Treasury, TSA to transportation, etc.

Having a Department Of All The Nation's Cops where they all come together even though the only thing they have in common is their job as enforcers is fundamentally less healthy than having them under civilian departments whose primary purpose isn't cracking skulls and taking names.

(Of course, some like ICE just need to be dissolved in an acid bath, not sent anywhere).

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur3 weeks ago