Went kayaking yesterday on a wetlands river - photo is up top. Going outside (and staying there!) is keeping me sane amid what Betty Cracker at Balloon Juice calls “The Horrors”. I have no idea what I’m going to do when it’s 10 below zero.

On to The Horrors:

❝

Odds are that most business owners have at least one person paying off student loans on their staff — meaning there’s also a pretty good chance those employees are looking particularly stressed these days. Because according to new data, tardiness or failure to reimburse college-era debts are now the biggest driver of rising delinquency rates in all forms of household liabilities.

Wait until the wage garnishments start in 6 months. Hoo boy. A lot of pain ahead for our already struggling young people.

I know a lot about consumer debt because my former clients were all working and middle class and had tons of it, including student loan debt.

Student loan debt is an odd outlier in the world of debt because it is “unsecured” - there is no asset that secures the debt like your car secures your car loan or your house secures your mortgage - but unlike all other unsecured debt (besides taxes and child support) it can’t be discharged in bankruptcy. This is partly (although not wholly) due to Congress, including Democrats in Congress, pushing thru a bankruptcy bill in 2005 that was an absolute gift bag for lenders.

The student loan debt conundrum is complex - it’s partly due to shrinking state subsidies for higher ed, meaning today’s young people have to borrow a lot more than I did - I borrowed only 1500 for all of undergrad and I took a long route to get there - I did a two year technical degree at a community college and then a bachelors - 1500 TOTAL. - amazing right? That was back when we supported public education.

It’s also partly due to colleges and universities using students like pack mules and loading them up with lifetime debt by encouraging them to borrow ridiculous amounts. An easy rule of thumb for how much a student can easily pay back is borrow only what one year of pay from your major is likely to pay. So a person pursuing an education degree should only borrow about 40k, because 40k is one year salary for a first-year teacher. Super expensive degrees - graduate degrees in science or medicine are exempted from this rule and need special analysis.

Although student loan debt can’t be discharged in bankruptcy it absolutely CONTRIBUTES to bankruptcy filings because consumer debt is about a total debt picture. The debtor might not have defaulted on their credit card debt or mortgage if they hadn’t have had 100k in nondischargeable student loan debt that had to be paid.

I am 100% sympathetic to young people who are buried in this debt. I would like their country to help them. I think they got screwed in a way my generation did not get screwed. However - and I say this as a proud Lefty- the Left’s solution to debt forgiveness under Biden was dumb and maybe more importantly - people hated it. They hated it because it was inequitable - unfair. It wasn’t even equitable as between groups of debtors. Why should the class of 2010 have their debt forgiven while the class of 2019 did not? It was essentially like we picked a random group of people, forgave just their debt, and then all celebrated a huge win for the Left. The policy was just incoherent garbage, and it came out of the Left side of the Party. We can do better. We need a comprehensive plan to reduce student debt that includes colleges and universities - they can’t demand tuition increases every fucking year and they can’t trick unsophisticated (many times first generation college students) into signing their life away to keep the money coming in.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Also, interesting that the Admin is offering student loan debt relief to anyone who signs up for ICE.

There's been a nuclear arms race at universities in regards to infrastructure and faculty/admin pay for a while now and one of the results is crushing student loan debt. Agree with the you Kay and the rest of the gang here - if one is going to do relief, it needs to be equitable and fair.

finally, Dems need to own up to mistakes and admit that we get it wrong sometimes. Open, honest and transparent communication will win the day 99% of the time...

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Kay, you and I are about the same age and I had a whopping $1500 student loan debt when I got out of undergrad in 1983. That increased another $5K coming out of grad school two years later and to be honest, in some ways I didn't need to take out that loan.

I saw the beginning of the end start during that time frame as the GOP began it's assault on public education (in this manner) by making it SOP to assume massive debt. You're right, what's been done over the subsequent years has been awful.

I also agree that the Biden plan wasn't great. It's hysterical to see the always-wrong commenters at the other blog yammer on about how they want free stuff, ie., debt forgiveness, free college, etc., but the instant you talk about expanding "free" stuff to groups they don't like, then they're no different than your bog-standard, bigoted rwnj. They just define "those people" differently.

Which is why they could never see why the Biden plan was hated in a general sense.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

There’s a strong tendency by far too many online Democrats to not just desire emulating some of the behavior exhibited by MAGA, but to become some sort of mirror image of MAGA. That shit doesn’t work.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Saying "Abolish ICE" is too shrill.

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

the Biden plan was hated in a general sense.

It was worse than that. The VERY NOTION of student loan forgiveness was seethingly hated in many quarters. I would sit in rooms full of self-identified Democrats and listen to them rant, unprompted, about how "those little Gaza fuckers get college given to them for free and I was trapped in a job I hated for 30 years because I had to pay off my student loan" or "I should get my student loan paid back to me WITH INTEREST if they get theirs written off". In my part of the country, student loan forgiveness was BY FAR the most unpopular part of the Democratic platform.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

When that bankruptcy law change came through way back when, I knew it was a harbinger of a new era (and NOT a good portent). I can't say much more right now without melting down.

Thank you for posting the lovely photo today. I'm suffering a mood disorder caused by (more than) several real life events conspiring to add to my feelings of helplessness (the hits just keep coming and I've decided to double down on getting more adaptively nimble in response). Spending less time online is a goal today since we can't really have much touching grass time because our air quality still sucks from the Canadian wildfires and worsens hubby's & cats' health issues. GAH! sick of being stuck inside this week in such otherwise beautiful weather.

I'm living vicariously through your outdoors adventures today, Kay!

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

I for one am very glad that we can be a small part of your daily routine, and that you have an outlet to explore some of your angst (which most of us have these days).

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Thanks!

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I worked in the financial aid office of a state school in the late 80's and early 90's and saw the beginning of the bad times for students. Back then, he "package" for average lower middle class or poor student then included Pell Grants, often scholarships, and student loans. The cost of attendance was low enough that "free money" did most of the lifting.

What I saw coming was: no increase in Pell Grants, increases in tuition, and a university administration that would use those tuition increases to pay for ever more administration. University expenses are out of control. Presidents and higher admins are paid huge salaries. Much of this is fueled by their absolute certainty that they can get students to pay crazy high tuition, and also gouge them with expensive student housing and dining plans.

And, yeah, if you're going to forgive student loans, gotta do them all.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I would not be college educated without Pell.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

What you’re describing is also a scourge in public education. My wife has been a teacher for 15 years, and she has seen her fair share of administrators hoovering up money at the expense of everyone else.