Since this blog is pretty tough on Ruben Gallego, I wanted to give his immigration plan [pdf] a fair hearing. It has 5 “pillars”:

  1. More enforcement

  2. Reform (read: eliminate) asylum

  3. Expand legal immigration and pathways to citizenship

  4. “Bring people out of the shadows” - explained below

  5. Address root causes of migration (more work with our allies to the south to host asylum seekers, limit fentanyl production, etc.)

The fact that (3) is included, and it’s pretty good, is a real change from the total defensive crouch on immigration. (1) is going to be a tough sell after ICE has been wilding through the population in ski masks. There’s some logic to (2) if it is really coupled with (3) because what’s happened is that the only legal immigrants in the US are asylum seekers, because the quotas for legal immigration are ridiculously small and the backlogs are effectively infinite.

But the real issue with this immigration reform plan is (4). Gallego makes the case that throwing out dreamers by ending DACA will cost us billions. But his “pillar” is pretty weak since it only addresses Dreamers and the undocumented spouses of legal residents. What about the millions of undocumented immigrants living and working peacefully in the US? Gallego’s proposal is silent on that. His pillar (3) talks about expanding pathways for legal immigration, but says nothing about immigrants already in the country.

Gallego’s plan has zero chance of becoming law, but it’s at least a start. I’m guessing that the techbros and techbro remoras that he hangs with are all about a reasonable immigration plan. From what I can tell, most of them aren’t as invested in white supremacy as Musk. And it’s way, way past time that we make our immigration quotas reasonable. So, 5 points to Slytherin, I guess.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

It may literally be impossible to spend more on border enforcement - it’s already a massive money sink. Can’t we just say we did it and not actually spend the money? No one will be able to tell the difference. Keep it at 60 billion a year wasted instead of a 100 billion a year.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

We wouldn't need as much enforcement if we had reasonable quotas. Then it would just be bureaucracy (processing visas) rather than storm troopers.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

On topic, found at Jamelle Bouie Bluesky regarding DOJ prosecution instructions:

https://bsky.app/profile/davidmenschel.bsky.social/post/3lp2vfgtqdc2e

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Private GEO concentration camp goings on at Delaney in Newark:

"Several arrests were made as clergy from New Jersey and neighboring states stood in front of the detention facility, arms locked, as employees with GEO Group, the company that runs the facility, attempted to leave the property. Clergy and others in support of the detention center being shut down gathered in prayer, and also to demand that the Department of Homeland Security release the names of the people being held inside Delaney Hall."

https://newjersey.news12.com/several-arrests-made-during-interfaith-rally-outside-delaney-hall-detention-center

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

I just read an article on Maine Public from NPR that there are currently almost 500,000 open manufacturing jobs right now. Trump wants to mass deport immigrants and stop immigration while simultaneously reshoring factory jobs even though we can’t fill the ones we have now. It seems like messaging about the reality would be helpful given that we are constantly stuck in a defensive messaging situation on this issue and on the economy.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

No one aspires to be sweatshop labor.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Manufacturing boomed under Biden.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

This piece from the BlueGreen Alliance, if the numbers are to be believed: https://www.bluegreenalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Then-and-Now-US-Manufacturing-Under-the-Trump-and-Biden-Harris-Admnistrations.pdf

Contrasts the 775K manufacturing jobs created under Biden vs a projected 1.7m such jobs projected being lost by 2030 if Project 2025 rolls out like clockwork.

I think it's useful to break and and discuss the specifics of the label 'manufacturing jobs', what they pay, unionzed vs not, geographic location, etc.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

Yeah it’s useful to discuss. The problem is I don’t think half of the general population has a single clue about the economy, immigration and manufacturing and how they intersect.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

The first pillar is totally based on Republican framing, so at least one point is deducted from Slytherin. But hey, Marc Andreesen is worried about having access to a steady stream of indentured servants, so it’s a definitely a place to start — even if that place is off to the right.

AZ Democrats must be thrilled with the “progressive” they elected.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

The Overton Window has shifted too far for my comfort in discussing these matters. So I am paying attention, but quietly. I feel my opinions are unauthorized because I am a privileged white woman. But I am an ally so I try to stay as educated as possible. Thank you for doing your part in that ongoing effort, M.M.!

If I see an opportunity to oppose IRL I will (and actually have in the past) put my body between the offenders and the victims.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

"More enforcement."

Oh look, the same solution we've been implementing for four decades, only to wake up the following morning pretending that it never happened so we can go back to demanding it again.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

None of this addresses "What do you do when an unaccompanied minor shows up at the border?" Eliminate asylum would mean "send them back" but "back to where" if they can't say or only speak some Mayan language that you have no translator for. One of the problems during the Obama administration was that the unaccompanied minors were getting younger.

There are various international adoptees whose parents just did not bother to do the paperwork correctly.