It’s frigid here in northwest Michigan but I ventured out the other evening to a local Democratic event. Oceana County has always been conservative but like most Right leaning places it has gone wackjob Right, so I have to find my people.

The event was a holiday gathering. I sat with a couple from Chicago who retired here and a local landowner/farmer. We had two speakers – one a young woman who is running for State Senate and the other the woman who runs The Lakeshore Food Club, which she describes as a “nonprofit grocery store”. It’s a neat idea, really. Anyone who is under 200% of the poverty level (about 64k for a family of four) can purchase a membership in The Food Club for 12 dollars a month. In return they can shop as often as they want for that month. The 12 dollars a month = hundreds of dollars in food and personal care items for lower income families. I kept thinking about the national freak out over Mamdani’s public grocery stores and smiled – The Food Club has been serving white, rural, lower income Midwesterners for a decade and there hasn’t been a single think piece in the NY Times accusing them of communism.

We’ve talked quite a bit here about the political ramifications of data centers and Michigan could be Ground Zero of the resistance judging by the energy at this event. This area of the country on the shores of Lake Michigan is just flat-out beautiful (while still being probably undervalued as property so affordable further from the lake) and locals are very, very attached to it. They are pissed about the data centers and it gets louder every week. There’s now a statewide org that is organizing people in every Michigan county.

We’ve also talked quite a bit about here about white rural voters and what it might take to get back to our old 45 D-55R margins instead of 25D-75R and I think we have to be honest with ourselves about what a heavy lift that might be. While it is true that white rural voters in the Great Lakes region prefer liberal economic policies, when one gets involved in an issue campaign with them one starts to see why it is so hard to go from those liberal economic policies to a real liberal Democrat/conservative Democrat alliance.

Data centers are a good example. White rural Democrats (and probably lots of Republicans) object to data centers for a lot of good reasons – they use up our drinking water, they use massive amounts of energy which causes our bills to go up, and no one outside of tech bros (and tech bro curious men) sees any productive or positive use to AI. AI was presented to people as “sure, we’ll destroy your potable water and raise your energy bills and not pay any taxes and we’re all asshole antidemocratic billionaires but look at the bright side – we’ll also make sure you never have another job”.

The problem is that in order to create an issue coalition around data centers, we have to accept that many rural white Democrats also oppose wind and solar. They object to the sale of open ground to put up solar arrays and wind turbines.  This kind of conundrum has happened every single time I have tried this alliance. I tried working with a group who opposed mega farms in my home county in Ohio but then the group expanded to include Right leaning Dems and Republicans and all of a sudden we had Ron Paul devotees insisting we could all homestead on an acre, just going on and fucking on about how I had to drive 11 miles to buy a carton of eggs from The Egg Lady after work. They like “our issues”, sure, but they also bring their own.

This trickles down to the personal level too. I had a good conversation with the farmer – he must spend a lot of time alone because he seemed eager to talk. He’s (actually) wealthy just based on the acreage he owns and where it is located. He has one 80 acre parcel that has been in his family for a hundred years, they never farmed it and it’s old growth forest. It’s also very close to the Lake Michigan shoreline. That parcel alone means he and his heirs will be just fine, no matter what happens to the asparagus market (that’s what he grows). He refers to Mexicans who come here to harvest asparagus and cherries as “illegals” and wanted to tell me all about the “white trash” who go to food banks. “Problematic” as the kids say. He’s the reality in these places, in my home county of Ohio just like rural Michigan and we can’t romanticize it or paper it over.

We just need to be brutally honest with ourselves that my friends in DSA are not exactly clear-eyed about the challenges of a true working coalition that focuses just “on issues” because liberal Democrats don’t actually agree with rural Right leaning Democrats on a lot of “issues” and that will eventually surface. It always does.

Still, opposition to data centers might be good for us politically. Trump is absolutely 100% in bed with them and horrible people like Sinema are lobbying for them on Fox News. Good luck with that.

Good luck with that. I cannot remember an issue that has generated as much “ordinary people” resistance as this - these monstrosities are WILDLY unpopular and with unpopular spokespeople like Trump, Sinema and the loathsome billionaire tech bros, that opposition isn’t going anywhere but up.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

This just popped up at 'The Nation' which goes along with my comments below about the real fight to make this a political wedge issue, isn't red/rurl voters but our own party:

https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/democrats-ai-regulation/

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I love how clueless media is about this - that TIME cover! In media it’s still 2007 and tech bros billionaires are still Americas heroes. These people are loathed all over the country. AI is wildly unpopular.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

https://x.com/brahmresnik/status/1999355963686682878

Chandler City Council voted unanimously to reject the data center.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Relating to Sinema, one of the best comments I saw had nothing to do with the actual issue at hand but rather her:

Her evolution from "Prada socialist" Jill Stein voter and Code Pink activist to this is truly fascinating.

I think we can all agree that we wish she'd never left the Mormon church which probably would have changed her life trajectory and that we all would have benefited (or at least be less harmed) by it.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I didn’t think she would be hired as a lobbyist since both Republicans and Democrats loathe her. But I once again underestimated how clueless America’s tech bros billionaires are.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

I was invited to speak at the big annual Martha’s Vineyard DSCC Fundraiser when I was running for US Senate. Cinema was running also for the first time. It was a disgusting donorfest. After watching her speak and spending some time chatting with her one-on-one and in clusters with donors, I actually went up to Chris Van Hollen who was then the head of the DSCC and told him I thought she was a narcissist, was all about herself and he should know that. Not sure where I got the guts to do that or why I did it, but little did I know…

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

Was there any discussion at the meeting about the House Republicans using a cork in the rules to unilaterally cut 645 million in work projects out of the budget? It's pretty much the big news here in Lansing.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Yes- the young woman running for state senate spoke on that.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I hope food co-ops are The Way of our future. I love reading about that success!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Maybe the loser stink bully trying to Executive Order what states can do will mobilize some opposition. Yes I am trying to remain hopeful.

https://crooksandliars.com/2025/12/broligarchy-ass-kisser-trump-signs-eo

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Hoosier Daddy

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

and there hasn’t been a single think piece in the NY Times accusing them of communism.

Well, they're the ones at fault here. Why? Because they should realize the onus is on them to hang out all day at diners. /s

I posted the link of Sinema flapping her pie hole on Faux "News" about AI/data centers using less water. She's a lobbyist hired to fluff a data center in Chandler AZ. According to local media there, input from the community is running 20:1 against it.

Your example of "expansion" back in OH is, in part, symbolic of where the Dem party already's at. Anytime I hear "We nEeD To gRoW ThE TeNt", it's often by somebody wanting to drag us further to the right, you see that sentiment elsewhere on a daily basis.

I lived in a county you describe and don't overlook the demographic shift that's caused them to go 25D-75R over the last 20 years: so many have left to become pale-blue D transplants in metro areas like Denver leaving behind a more conservative populace.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Well, by the numbers we DO have to peel some of them off or we lose. We only won Ohio because we held Republicans to 55 in rural areas instead of 75. Sherrod Brown right now needs 1 in 5 Trump voters to win. Miami didn’t change demographics from 2020 to 2024, yet it just flipped. Some Latino voters came back. All I’m saying is it’s difficult and will be more difficult going forward to act as a coalition party.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

This is a good discussion and I know (and saw), all too well, what you're describing in OH back in Misery.

I agree with what I think is your core point: Use AI/data centers as a political wedge issue to peel-off/get-back votes in otherwise red/rurl areas. I was pointing out 2 things:

  • Agreeing that in a red-tilt political context it will be difficult for a variety of reasons, demographics, overcoming decades of propaganda, etc., and the problems that might have with a friggin "expanded tent" that turns out to be little different than the GOP of 30 years ago, and

  • That the other half of the equation, convincing the (D) Party that it's worth doing will be equally hard. The entire Abundance/WelcomeFest/Centrist crowd work to permanently sever the Party’s relationship with unions and replacing it with a vastly expanded alliance with Big Tech and Crypto. Abundance "liberals" exist to put a nicer face on the tech billionaire agenda.

  • Avatar

    Scott H1 year ago

    And they represent over half of the House caucus (counting Blue Dogs and Blue Dogs v2.0, aka the New Democrats Coalition). Given their aims vis a vis AI/crypto are no different than (R) aims at a strategic level, that represents ample political majority to roll out AI/data centers willy nilly.

    So, getting Dems onboard with using AI/data center construction as a political wedge issue is problematic. Hell, tech billionaire Marc Andreesen spent, by some accounts, more than $200m in political donations during Biden's term to oust crypto opponents and elect industry allies and had willing takes of money on both sides of the aisle.